2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
Lightbulb Moments that Show the Way: Insight into Action
. Business Development is Women’s Work
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
Of all the 57-year-old white guys with accounting degrees, my husband should be one who gets it.
He has three grown daughters whom he has mentored with useful, relevant career advice. He champions rising women
at the high-tech lighting manufacturing company he co-founded.
For heaven’s sake...he’s married to me! And for 35 years, too. Since 1998 when I first started designing and managing
research that analyzes the talent pipeline for women and multicultural employees, he has endured running commentary. Best practices, worst practices, and the practices in the middle.
Women who have navigated their careers with
grace and purpose, and women who found themselves sidelined by corrosive cultures, clueless bosses, erratic
economies and their own missteps and hesitancies. He has heard it all.
Or so he thought last June, when we went out to dinner as the 2014 Accounting MOVE Project report had just gone to press.
I had news, I told him over smoked whitefish (a regional favorite on the west coast of Michigan), that I had a great
conversation with a key partner at a major regional CPA firm based a few hours away.
She and I plotted how we might meet for lunch. We thought we’d meet in the middle of the mitten, which is what
Michiganders call Grand Rapids.
The Grand Rapids Art Museum often hosts exhibits of art quilts. I am a huge fan of
contemporary quilts. And it turned out that my acquaintance wanted to learn more about this new quilt aesthetic.
She
and I thought that a quilt exhibit would be just the venue to become better acquainted.
“Really? Quilts? Really?” asked my husband. To be fair, he has witnessed many bags of fabric come in the front door
and many finished quilts go out the same door, headed to homeless teen moms, foster parents, family and friends.
“Substitute ‘golf ’ for ‘quilt’ in everything I just told you,” I said.
And I watched him have his own lightbulb moment.
Moments like these can’t be designed, engineered, forced or manipulated. They emerge from daily relationships with
people we know and trust.
These are the moments that clarify culture and convert change from theory to reality.
This, the sixth edition of the Accounting MOVE Project, is a string of lightbulb moments.
I wish I could claim that this
energetic and inspirational concept originated with me, but it came from the ever-insightful MOVE steering committee. Jen Wyne and Tricia Bencich of Moss Adams, our founding sponsor; Risa Lavine, Michelle Lifschitz and Carolyn
D'Anna, of CohnReznick, our national sponsor; Ericka Harney, executive director of the Accounting and Financial
Women’s Alliance, and Kim Fantaci of the American Woman’s Society of CPA’s had a collective moment that resulted in
this report, a fireworks display of personal lightbulb moments.l
Lightbulb Moments That Show the Way:
Personal Insights in Action
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
Lightbulb Moments: inspiration, insight & action
Stacie Kwaiser, east region managing principal, Rehmann, based in
Troy, Mich.
Moment: Good intentions sometimes insulate men from deeper insights. When it comes to
advocating for women, “men get it from a theoretical perspective, but often it hasn’t sunk in to
their everyday point of view.”
Insight: “When we were early with our women’s initiative, one of the sponsors was a male.
He
sat in on one of our lunch & learn sessions, and he walked out of there saying, ‘I never realized
that men often aren’t intentional about introducing women to clients.’ It changed his perspective
about how he advocated for women. He thought he looked out for women…But he never heard
a woman say what her perceptions were.”
Action: It’s nearly impossible to over-communicate when it comes to sharing, and truly hearing,
diverse points of view. “We can’t think that the problem is solved.
It’s an ongoing process, and we
need to recognize that.”
Risa Lavine, principal, chief of staff, CohnReznick, based in New York
Moment: After a partner’s meeting, a firm senior leader observed that only men commented.
Women – all of them partners and principals – were silent.
Insight: “We didn’t raise our hands, and we didn’t speak and it was noticed. And that person did
me a favor: He noticed. He took the two minutes to say, ‘I know how important this is.
Did you
happen to notice that not a single woman raised her hand?’ That was a gift. It reminded me that
you have to show up everywhere. It was a moment of profound awareness.”
Action: “When you see something like a meeting in which no women speak up, it’s less about
defending the occurrence, and more about thinking through, why did this happen? How can
this not happen in the future? What one thing can change in the structure of the next meeting
to encourage more women to participate? That’s what raised awareness looks like.
The next
time, would we think differently about how we set up the meeting? I think we would. And as a
group of women partners, yes, we’ll remember that last time we didn’t say anything, and this
time we should.”
Denise Gueli, partner, The Bonadio Group, based in Pittsford, NY
Moment: “When I became a principal, I had no business development experience. I’d never seen
myself as a rainmaker, and that became a self-fulfilling prophecy.”
Insight: “I followed one of our partners to open a new office in Buffalo, and I was nervous about
being the top audit person in the new office.
He said, ‘You’ll never learn how to market out of a
book. Look at yourself, who wouldn’t want to do business with you? You need to put yourself out
there a little more.’ Client service equals relationships.”
Joanne Y Cleaver
President, Wilson-Taylor Associates, Inc.
Action: “I started to network just a bit, and I realized that women don’t picture themselves as
rainmakers because it’s such a macho caricature. Now, I bring in lots of business and what I
thought was a weakness is a strength.”
2
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
.
LaChel Hird, chief career officer, CliftonLarsonAllen, based in Minneapolis



Moment: “As we become a full-fledged professional services firm, this is not the moment to
compare our firm with our competitors, old and new. Our organization needs to reflect the clients we serve, the communities in which we live and the employees we want to attract and retain
today and for the future.”
Insight: A living infographic would make the point to all firm leaders.
Action: At a firm leadership meeting, women were evenly distributed among the tables. Hird
had all stand. Then she had all the men sit.
There was a collective buzz as “the group realized we
aren’t as diverse as we should be. They didn’t collectively realize it until they saw it.”
Adelle Erdman, director of marketing, Frazier & Deeter, based in Atlanta
Moment: “I noticed that when we announced that we were sponsoring an event, or had tickets
available for a networking event, that women rarely asked for tickets.”
Insight: Women rarely ask.
Action: “Now, to make sure that we have a balanced mix across gender, practice areas and level,
I offer spots to women instead of just offering places on a first-come, first-served basis firm wide.
It’s a small adjustment that will have big results.”
Alan Whitman, office managing partner, Detroit, and slated to become
CEO, June 2016, Baker Tilly Virchow Krause, based in Chicago
Moment: As he integrates into his new role of CEO, Whitman joined the steering committee for
GROW, the firm’s women’s initiative. As he listened to the ongoing discussion about GROW’s
strategic direction, he realized that “we need to treat this as systematically as we do any practice
area.”
Insight: “We have business plans, goals and accountability for the services we provide.
We need
that for our GROW activities. This is part of our stewardship of making the firm better tomorrow than it was yesterday.”
Action: “We need to communicate with the management committee so that we have visibility
with what GROW is accomplishing.”
Cindy Harper, partner, Lattimore, Black Morgan & Cain, based in
Brentwood, TN
Moment: “As part of our on-going efforts to make WIN@LBMC (our women’s initiative) effective, an informal partner meeting was held to ask what WIN could be doing to ensure the success of our female senior managers. We discussed what barriers there may be for them, whether real or perceived, and how we could help resolve those.
During the meeting, the partners
discussed flexibility and the idea of flex time partners as a real possibility in a very honest and
open manner. The consensus is that there really are not obstacles that the firm can’t resolve. The
meeting confirmed that WIN is on the right track and leadership is open to the idea of flex time
partners and continues to embrace flexible work arrangements.
At a subsequent partner retreat,
the HR director provided our annual update on our business case and numbers regarding WIN.”
Insight: By appealing to both the “head” with the business case and the heart (personal connections), leadership begins to see the issues in a different manner.
4
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
. Action: To help move the effort forward, several partners are now emailing articles and ideas to
the head of the women's initiative.
Michelle A. Sullivan, director, Freed Maxick CPAs, P
.C., based in Buffalo
Moment: “Being charged with our firm’s women’s initiative, I realized that we had to be selfaware about our own actions, and we had to demonstrate a commitment to developing women
within our firm, while also developing ourselves.”
Insight: “I felt empowered, being able to be a change agent with the firm and given the opportunity to lead this initiative.”
Action: “Because Barb [Sullivan] and I are leading our firm’s initiative, we are now aware of the
numerous times that other directors and partners have had diversity top-of-mind when they
were making selections for a team, sending someone to a conference, or any other opportunity.
We have heightened the awareness for an inclusive work environment to promote individuals to
have access to all opportunities.”
Michelle Lifschitz, manager, CohnReznick
Moment: Hearing an office managing partner attribute a newly promoted senior manager’s
qualifications to her involvement with WomenCAN, the CohnReznick women’s initiative. “I’d
been coaching her, and the office managing partner commented that what she accomplished
with WomenCAN shows her leadership abilities.”
Insight: Unprompted recognition of WomenCAN as a unique mode of building leadership
skills is evidence of culture change.
Action: Sharing short anecdotes like this helps other firm leaders ‘know it when they see it,’ too.
Toni Diprizio, partner, Plante Moran, based in Southfield, MI
Moment: “At a holiday party in December 2012, the husband of one of my female teammates
said, ‘Do you realize how much your opinion means to my wife? What you say means so much.’
At the time I was a new partner and a working mother with three children. It didn’t sink in at
that moment.
But his saying that gave me a different lens as to how I was developing the women
beneath me.”
Insight: “It’s so easy to come to the office, bring your brown bag lunch, get your work done as
efficiently as you can, and get home to those kids. Men don’t operate that way. They’re very social.
They don’t mind asking anybody at any level for anything. I never hesitated to ask. But some
women need to be invited.
And I realized that some of the women I mentor aren’t wired as I am.
And, they aren’t necessarily thinking about their career development the way I did about mine.”
Engineering Light Bulb Moments That Catalyze Culture Change
Once you have a genuine lightbulb moment, you never see things the same way again.
You can’t force a lightbulb to switch on in someone’s brain, but you can lay wiring to increase the
chances that they’ll be struck with insight – and then do something with it.
“Lightbulb moments illuminate the way for others when leaders weave them into stories that
become part of company culture and lore,” said Anne Perschel, a leadership and business psychologist and president of Germane Consulting, based in Worcester, Massachusetts. “When
the light bulb clicks ‘on,’ you see things differently. This difference informs your decisions and
actions.
You behave differently and you have a different affect. People notice, and because, as a
leader you are a role model, they often follow suit. The affect is even greater, when you tell your
light bulb story, which gets told, retold and modeled far and wide.”
Advancing women is a complex issue that evolves along with firm growth, personal goals,
economic conditions and business opportunities. That means that there are plenty of opportunities for lightbulb moments, for women and men.
Communication experts and senior leadership at CPA firms agree that the most powerful
moments are those that permanently flip a switch.
Here’s how to capture lightbulb moments to
lasting change in staff, workplace culture, and client service.
Lightbulb moments can happen many ways:
Collaborating with people who have different experiences, backgrounds and points of view.
After sharing an office with three women colleagues as a graduate assistant, Duncan Spelman,
professor of management at Bentley University in Waltham, Mass., realized that women had a
different experience in the workplace than men did. These conversations prompted him to focus
much of his research on gender issues. He said that if managers spend all their time around people just like themselves, then they have no chance of gaining a deep understanding of the issues.
Realizing the implications of data and trends.
Fifteen years ago, Lari Braun, director of human
resources at Henry & Horne, LLP, based in Arizona, was filling out EOE paperwork and realized
that men significantly outnumber women in the firm. She championed work life balance changes to make the firm more attractive to women. Partly as a result, Henry & Horne has nearly
achieved equity, with women comprising 47% of its partners.
One of its most effective changes
was to allow professional employees to largely set their own hours, such as coming in at 6
a.m. and leaving at 3 p.m. to pick up their children from school.
The firm also added a rainmakers [i.e., business development] program along with leadership training.
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
MOVE Forward Faster!
6
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
ership Conference, hosted by the
American Woman’s Society of
CPAs, and at the Annual Conference of the Accounting and
Financial Women’s Alliance.
MOVE Scorecard
MOVE Presentations
and Workshops
In-depth recommendations and
comprehensive benchmarks on all
Action: “I may need to mentor people differently. Mentoring is helping the protégé find her
own best path forward. That may not be the path that worked for me, and that’s ok.
But I do
want women at Plante Moran to think about their careers long term. There’s a ton of flexibility
and the financial rewards are fabulous. It’s worth hanging in there for it.
They need to realize
how this will benefit their whole families.”
MOVE factors enable your firm to
invest in programs, practices and
culture that actually work. Insight
scales with your firm’s size and
growth objectives.
Attend MOVE workshops at the
Women’s Accounting and Lead-
Wilson-Taylor Associates communication workshops for partners and
rising managers equip them with
insight and tactics to convey firm
values, expertise and goals.
These additional MOVE tools
can help your firm recoup its
investment in women and
rising leaders.
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
. Getting in on the conversation. Yeo & Yeo, Saginaw, has created a career advocacy team that
maps emerging career paths that anticipate needs of growing practice areas and offices, reports
Kym Hess, director of human resources.
Being challenged by an outside perspective. Johanson & Yau, based in San Jose, Calif., recently
launched a quarterly Leadership Speaker Series to feature community and business leaders who
share their paths to leadership, major influences and leadership style. These events occur in a
casual setting during breakfast, and the firm avoids large speaker fees by inviting participants to
participate at no cost (although the firm provides modest thank you gifts).
Jon D’Agostino,
human resources director at the firm, said that many light bulb moments occur during these
events. At a recent breakfast, a local Latino politician spoke about his experience and journey and D’Agostino said that several Latino associates were especially inspired. “We try hard
to structure the program with relevant speakers who can connect with our diverse staff.
This
provides them opportunities to envision their own leadership roles by hearing from emerging or
recognizable leaders,” D’Agostino said.
Personal Connection = Lightbulb Moment
Lightbulb moments are especially powerful when a man has a close family or friend relationship with a woman, often a mother, wife, or colleague, who was held back from opportunities due to her gender.
Submerged cultural issues are not evidence of a conspiracy, said Jeffery Tobias Halter, president
of YWomen, a consulting firm in Atlanta, that focuses on engaging men in women’s initiatives.
Instead, his research has found that bias, cultural friction and other factors are theoretical until
they hit home. “We are largely unaware of gender issues until it affects us personally,” Halter said.
“Cultural norms have conditioned men to not engage on these types of issues.”
That is why so many men have lightbulb moments when they become fathers of daughters – an
experience shared by male partners at several MOVE firms.
“My generation of men has always wanted to raise strong daughters. We cheered at their
soccer games and sat in the front row during dance recitals.
But one day it hits us that
when she walks out of college to her own life that she is going to earn 78 cents on the dollar to the man sitting next to her,” said Halter. “And we fail to make the connection that if
we don’t advocate for Phyllis down the hall, then who is going to advocate for our daughters?”
And in fact, those collective lightbulb moments by dads can add up to real change for
women when those dads are workplace leaders. According to the researchers Michael S.
Dahl at Aalborg University in Denmark, Cristian L.
Dezső at the University of Maryland
and David Gaddis Ross at the Columbia School of Business, chief executive officers with
daughters are more likely to implement gender-related wage policies that reduce pay
inequity for females.
Turning Lightbulbs into Energy
Light bulb moments help you see things that were previously dim or invisible. But what
really matters is what you do.
Present the business case for women’s issues. “Engaging men is 75 percent logic and 25 percent heart,” said Halter.
Talk with employees regarding how the number of women graduating
in accounting outnumbers men and how the firm will only succeed if it can hire and retain the
top talent.
8
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
Encourage men to attend women’s leadership events. Remind them that the uncomfortable
feeling they have walking into the room the first time is how women feel working in a male
dominated office. “Men showing up at women’s events is a very powerful gesture towards making lasting change,” Halter said.
Make gender issues and accountability part of every employee’s job.
When everyone shares
responsibility, everyone shares in the success. MOVE firms see individual partners take charge
of advancing women on their teams when they see how the firm’s overall aspirations are translated to ambitions for their offices and their lines of business. Take it a step further by equipping office managing partners with metrics that show how women fare at their
offices and how that affects the firm’s overall progress.
Moss Adams, based in Seattle, isn’t
resting on its laurels, either. Though 26% of its partners are now women, the business case for
advancing women continues to evolve with business conditions and firm goals, said Tricia
Bencich, human resources manager who oversees Forum W, the firm’s culture change initiative. Moss Adams has framed the firm’s overall approach to sponsorship; now asking partners
to set sponsorship goals and report on progress.
This has increased awareness and accountability for Forum W and the firm’s overall diversity and inclusion efforts.
“The emerging generation of partners has grown up with Forum W, so
they’ve seen the benefits and they know the difference it makes.”
—Jen Wyne, director of human resources, Moss Adams, based in Seattle,
citing the cultural influence of the firm’s longstanding women’s initiative.
Create rewards and recognition for employees who initiate positive change on gender
issues. Employees need to know that the firm cares about gender issues.
Give employees the time to build relationships. “When the message from the firm is to be on
task at all times, then employees are unable to develop the relationships and have the conversations that both create light bulb moments and turn those moments into positive change at
the firm,” said Spelman.l
MOVE 2015 Results
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
Firms of all sizes are seeing a steady, gradual increase in the proportion of women partners.
While the proportion of women in the pipeline is also increasing, the retention rate of women
from the brink of partnership (senior manager) to partner or principal is improving slowly.
In
2014, the retention rate was 45%; in 2015, it is 47%. This pattern holds at firms of all sizes.
Those with higher-than-average proportions of women employees and managers also retain
women to partner at about 47%. In other words, firms with high proportions of women employees and managers still lose almost half of them in the transition to partnership.
“We are stoked about having 26% female partners, but we can’t wait to
go further.”—Jen Wyne
A major advance is the proportion of women as members of firm management committees:
.
while many firms still have none, women now comprise 23% of management committee members at MOVE firms, up from 19% in 2014.
And, he adds, employees – especially millennials accustomed to freely sharing all kinds of
information — can piece together salary comparisons anyway from online sources. It’s better to
provide an official point of reference than to leave an information vacuum.
Public Accounting Report
The Pipeline of Women—2015 MOVE Project Metrics
All MOVE CPA Firms
Women Employees and Managers as a Proportion of ALL
2015
17%
17%
41%
43%
27%
25%
44%
44%
40%
38%
51%
51%
52%
46%
54%
48%
62%
56%
45%
45%
44%
46%
48%
48%
49%
48%
48%
53%
52%
51%
48%
50%
51%
49%
51%
% Women Full-Time U.S. Employees
19%
51%
% Women New Hires
19%
52%
% Women Associates
17%
52%
% Women Supervisors/Senior Staff
23%
47%
% Women Professionals
20%
57%
% Women Career Professionals
19%
50%
% Women Managers
2011
47%
% Women Senior Managers
2012
30%
% Women Directors
2013
22%
% Women Partners & Principals
2014
23%
% Women on Management Committee
51%
51%
51%
51%
Source: 2015 MOVE Project
(MOVE uses the AICPA definition: a professional at the senior or manager level who will work in the current role for the indefinite future.)
Money:
Pay equity policies and practices
Build Trust Through Proactive Pay Practices
•
47% of firms conduct internal pay equity surveys of all pay plus performance, up
from 29% in 2014
•
41% of firms conduct pay equity surveys of base pay only, compared to 32% in 2014
•
Aulik-Beere’s approach is to conduct comprehensive analysis of market data to determine what
market rates are for various positions. Baker Tilly, as an organization, aims to pay the market
rate; however, he explains, individual salaries can be adjusted up or down based on a candidate
or employee’s experience, additional skills, and other factors.
“Sharing information on the process builds trust between employers and employees,” said Aulik-Beere. “They understand what
information the organization uses to make its decision process, and what the process is. “
How MOVE Helps Your Firm Win at Pay Equity
The MOVE Project examines pay equity practices and policies.
Through the survey and interviews, MOVE synthesizes compensation practices to see how firms ensure that women and men
are paid equitably for comparable work. MOVE also looks at how managers are trained to apply
pay policies consistently and without bias (conscious or unconscious) and how pay trends and
patterns are measured and challenged within each firm.
Every firm aspires to pay strictly for performance. Yet, many factors can converge to prevent women
from being paid equitably.
The best practices in this section can help your firm be proactive by taking
extra steps to hold your managers and firm leaders accountable for actually paying for performance.
The business case for pay equity sharpened in 2014:
•
The Office of Federal Contract Compliance proposed a rule that would require a pay
equity report for all federal contractors or subcontractors whose workplaces included 100 or more employees
•
In lieu of a Federal pay equity law, many states and municipalities passed paycheck
fairness laws. From New Hampshire to Seattle, employers must comply with new
disclosure, compliance and reporting requirements.
•
By creating a pay equity tip line, Rhode Island has created a streamlined channel
for employees at any workplace in the state to open a query about workplace pay
disparities
Best practices for pay equity include:
25% of firms conduct internal pay equity surveys by gender and by race, compared
to 21% in 2014
•
56% of firms offer employees communication that provides context for pay discussions and decisions, compared to 46% in 2014
Employers often consider pay equity discussions a minefield. They want to pay equitably and to
reward performance, but do not want to touch off challenges or external inquiries.
10
But pay equity can be a point of trust that builds employer brand, said Mark D.
Aulik-Beere, Baker
Tilly, “Be upfront about the process,” recommends Aulik-Beere. “You don’t have to share every piece
of data about how you make your decisions. But it’s important to tell employees, this is our process.”
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
•
Training recruiters and managers to explain the firm’s pay equity policies and
how they are applied consistently.
It is not enough to point to boilerplate policies.
With pay equity making headlines, employees and candidates are keenly aware of
the pay gap in general, and have easy access to statistics about pay gaps for industries and job titles. Managers and recruiters need to be able to explain how the firm’s
leaders review pay decisions and conduct audits to ensure that pay policies become
pay reality.
•
Building trust through transparent pay practices. A constant stream of news
about pay gaps and inequities understandably fuels suspicion.
Women wonder if
. they are on their own to investigate a suspected pay gap and then to figure out how
to approach managers about it. Simple, straightforward explanations about how
your firm proactively scrutinizes base pay and bonuses by gender, longevity and
other factors proves to women staff that they share pay equity values with their
employer.
•
Removing barriers to equalizing pay for staff whose compensation has stagnated or fallen behind market rates. Often, employees on alternative schedules or
alternative career tracks accept minimal pay raises because they value nonmonetary
benefits. At some point – often when a new employee comes on board – the longtime employee realizes that she is paid less than a newcomer with less experience.
This discovery undermines her loyalty to the firm.
It is up to managers and compensation/human resource staff, who have access to firmwide compensation data, to
ensure that women’s pay does not fall behind. When a market pay inequity is discovered, managers should be able to tap a fund outside their departmental budget to
correct the inequity. This ‘equity pot’ concept is being widely adopted at universities
because it means other staffers’ compensation does not suffer to free up funds to
correct an inequity.
Owning up to the fact that unintended inequities can creep in leads to heightened vigilance, said
Maureen Adolf, president of the Financial Women’s Association of New York and senior vice
president of government relations at Nelson Brown Co., a legal firm.
She recommends that firm
leaders show the way by taking time to examine underlying assumptions about pay decisions
before the decisions are finalized, thinking through the factors that validate a pay decision, and
conducting pay audits to ensure that well-intended decisions do not contribute to inadvertent gaps.
O
pportunities for leadership and
professional development
The business case for advancing women is inescapable: without women, firms cannot both grow
and replace baby boomers, who are starting to retire. Progress is uneven, but some firms are
breaking through.
•
78% of firms offer internal leadership development training, compared to 82% in 2014
•
38% of firms rotate rising women into client-facing roles, compared to 36% in 2014
•
44% of firms use talent management systems, compared to 43% in 2014
•
66% of firms offer women’s initiatives or networks, compared to 71% in 2014
“The question isn’t ‘what’s the business case for diversity?’, but “what’s the business case for homogeneity?”—Robert Elton, former CEO, BC Hydro
When asked what he said to men who complain about women’s initiatives, Darin Goehner,
a partner with Moss Adams, usually replies: “When women are 51% of the partners, that’s
when you get your initiative. You already have the benefit of numbers.
Why do you need an
initiative?” On the topic of leading women’s initiatives, Goehner believes, “Male champions have
12
Stalemate to Strategy to Success
Diversity and unconscious bias training can get the conversation going and equip staff with
constructive language for discussions. But what makes a long term difference, according to a
steadily increasing number of studies, are two factors: formal accountability for making equitable decisions, and a culture of mutual accountability among peers.
The difference is often most obvious in the way each gender approaches problems, both professionally and personally. “Men tend to solve problems by compartmentalizing and using a hierarchal approach,” said Andres Tapia, senior partner, Korn Ferry, Los Angeles.
“Women think more
holistically and take a more relationship approach to situations.”
Studies prove that women and men bring different strengths to the table:
•
A Korn Ferry study showed women rated higher than their male counterparts in 17
critical leadership skills, including operating, interpersonal, courage and drive.
•
If employees perceive their workplace as welcoming to diverse employees, they are
also more likely to be more co-operative, more satisfied and have higher morale,
according to a study conducted by MIT and George Washington University.
Both men and women tend to transfer power to white men, according to a recent study by Penn
State researchers. This is one instance of ‘unconscious bias’ that frames assumptions that all
people make about others. Unconscious bias can be insidious when leaders make unquestioned
assumptions about who is considered for growth opportunities, when, and why.
Best practices for converting gender diversity to a business advantage:
•
Win skeptics by leading with data, which resonates with accounting culture.
“There
is so much gender language typically used in these conversations that there is often
unconscious bias,” said Tapia. For example, he recommends, “Instead of saying
women tend to be more relational show the scientific data about how women and
men’s brains function differently.”
•
Align the development of women with your firm’s organic growth. About 35% of
BeachFleischman PC’s marketing budget is devoted to nonprofit sponsorships and
events – and the firm has documented that most of its clients have stemmed from
these sponsorships.
The Tucson-based firm aligns development of women’s business
development skills accordingly.
•
Understand the intrinsic strengths of women at your firm and cultivate those
strengths through tailored development programs and coaching. Women managers
more effectively engage employees of both genders, according to a Gallup poll.
Women outscore men on 11 of 12 elements of developing employees, including
giving consistent, specific feedback and encouragement, and investment in
employees’ development.
47% of firms have formal succession planning, compared to 36% in 2014
•
to speak up. When someone who doesn’t have an obvious self-interest is a champion, it’s a strong
statement that you’re about what’s best for all.”
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
Recognizing that women often underplay their achievements for fear of appearing too aggressive.
Tara Mohr, author of Playing Big: Finding Your Voice, Your Mission & Your Message,
(Gotham, 2014) said that most women have a core belief that good work will be met with praise
and view anything less than praise as criticism.
“Women then become more reluctant to share
. controversial ideas and ask provocative questions that could possibly bring criticism,” said
Mohr. Leaders at some MOVE firms have observed this first-hand, as women expect that their
heads-down work will be automatically recognized. Often, women who have limited themselves
in this way are relieved when a mentor or sponsor challenges the parameters they have put
around their own potential.
Lightbulb to Legend
“Silver bullet’ stories that summarize a moment of insight and a pivot point are shared because
they are simple and actionable. Stories that resonate become firm lore, shaping culture because
they change the home they hit.*
Tapia’s own ‘lightbulb moment’ occurred when he was coaching a team of ten-year-old soccer
players.
The girls, he noticed, tended to wait until the ball came to them, instead of chasing it.
One day, he realized that the same pattern played out at the large company where he was then
chief diversity officer.
“The women waited to be tapped for a promotion. They weren’t as likely to voice an idea. And
they didn’t ask for raises, but expected them to be given for good work.
But every day he saw
men apply for promotions they weren’t totally qualified for and ask for raises, while women were
much more likely to wait for the ball no matter what their age or the situation,” Tapia recalls.
That’s why some firms are opening their women’s initiatives to women of all ranks and levels
of experience. New York based, Freed Maxick, for instance, discovered that ambitious younger
women were being turned away from initiative events. Now, women senior staff are welcome.
Chris Millias, managing partner, OUM, based in San Francisco
Moment: “As a staff person, just starting, I would get invited to poker games with partners, and
I could see that women didn’t have a chance.”
Insight: “Life is unfair.
It’s not that you work hard and it all happens. Then I realized that I could
change the world that my daughters would enter.”
Action: “My world view changed. My partners felt the same way.
We determined to be as flexible as we could be in terms of schedules and opportunities. We put women in situations where
they are influencers, and that means they are invited into more projects. We want women to see
that if they stick around, it’s worth it.”
Intentionally Inclusive
“Accounting is a profession that was built by men for men,” said Richard J.
Caturano, national
leader of culture, diversity and inclusion at McGladrey LLP, Boston, and past chair of the American Institute of CPA’s. “As a profession we have an unconscious bias towards men in the way
that we work and the things we value. We need to be more conscious of this bias so we can find
ways to be intentionally inclusive.”
‘Intentionally’ is the operative word, as male leaders at MOVE firms echo Caturano’s point.
Caturano compares inclusion to a gear with three modes – inclusion, neutral and exclusion.
“For 98 percent of accounting professionals, no one would ever exclude women on purpose.
*Need help crafting and telling firm and leader stories? Check out the strategic communication training and
coaching services provided by Wilson-Taylor Associates, Inc., which manages the Accounting MOVE Project.
14
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
Men just don’t always think about consciously including women both in invitation and setting of
events,” he said.
“While many people don’t think of neutral as a negative, if you park a car facing
uphill in neutral then it will roll backward.”
But change for such a core part of a firm has to begin at the top. “It’s more than just making
programs for women or hiring more women and minorities. The firm leader has to make a conscious decision to change the attitude of the firm to one of intentional inclusion,” Caturano said.
If a firm’s culture is left in neutral, then it will succumb to gravity.
And no one wants to find their
firm at the bottom of a hill.
Starting a women’s initiative is just that: a start. As reported in the October 2014 edition of the
Harvard Business Review, evidence is accumulating that diversity initiatives only succeed when
they are accompanied by direct responsibility for diversity results. Similarly unconscious biases
training needs to be translated to specific practices and coaching to actually change how decisions are made.
The same Harvard Business Review article cites the power of having pairs of
decision makers jointly consider the qualifications and potential of employees and candidates,
rather than relying on just one person’s judgment. Such tactics translate the intention of diversity
and unconscious bias training into everyday habits that change culture.
V
ital supports for work-life
•
88% of MOVE firms offer telecommuting on a case-by-case basis, and 31% as a
formal practice
•
But only 16% of managers are trained to manage virtual teams
•
53% of firms offer work-life supports specifically for tax season
Work-life blend is a pressing concern for both women and men. As millennials start to have
families and baby boomers increasingly care for aging parents, Gen Xers are dealing with teens.
It seems that everybody is vulnerable to direct conflicts of family and work obligations.
MOVE firms offer a spectrum of flexwork (81% as a cultural practice, and 59% with formal
flexwork policies.
And, 50% of MOVE firms are backing up their policies with training that
helps managers effectively and fairly apply them. That’s consistent with the findings of the 2014
National Study of Families and Employers, by the Families and Work Institute, which found that
that 48% of employers (down from 62% in 2008) assess managers’ use of flexwork policies.
But, women and men often take advantage of policies in different ways, which means that firm
leaders must be on the alert for assumptions about what types of programs might most benefit
various employee populations. For example, an on-site fitness center might appear to be a gender-neutral benefit, but research finds that women feel judged by co-workers for taking time to
work out during the day, while men detect no such stigma.
With proliferating expectations of all generations, work-life programs can feel like a moving
target.
But a new genre of research indicates that these programs pay off, at least for the category
of employees for whom such programs were originally designed. Programs that retain working
mothers are worth the investment because working moms actually are more productive in the
long run, according to no less a source than the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
It found in a
recent study that while mothers of preteen children were up to 33% less productive – justifying
a scaled workload and alternative career tracks – those same mothers “outperformed women
without children at almost every stage of the game.”
. Kositzka, Wicks and Co., based in Alexandria, VA, has nearly achieved perfect pipeline retention, with women comprising 63% of its employees and 55% of its partners and principals.
Ten years ago, when it was half its current size of 72, firm leaders went all in on flexible work
arrangements in hopes that the practice would retain women. It worked. “Our makeup makes
us unique,” says senior manager Connie Hammell. “And now we’re making that a differentiator”
as the firm ramps up marketing outreach geared to women-owned businesses.
Action: “Now I work with employees to create individual career plans and schedules.”
MOVE firm best practices for providing vital support for work-life include:
•
Consider hiring employees from day one with a reduced schedule.
By actively
recruiting professionals looking for a flexible environment, you are giving yourself
the largest pool possible to find the most qualified person for your needs. At Atlanta-based Windham Brannon, P.C, a number of employees are hired with a flexible
schedule. Kim Hensarling, director of talent & human resources, said that the firm
was recently able to hire a highly talented CPA from another firm because of the
ability to start off with a 75 percent schedule.
•
Recommend optimal technology and model working remotely from the top down.
Many MOVE firms cited technology as a barrier to remote access, either employees not having adequate access to be efficient or IT departments being reluctant to
provide tools and support.
A partner at Lattimore Black Morgan & Cain worked
with the IT director to determine the ideal equipment for remote access and the
firm handles ordering the optimal hardware/software for the employee while the
employee pays for the equipment. “Working with Internal Technology to ensure employees have technology in place that supports efficiency and reduces frustration has
been key in LBMC’s success in the area of remote access,” said Jessica Utley, human
resource director at Lattimore Black Morgan & Cain.
•
Encourage partners to be transparent about working remotely, showing the way. If
employees view that there is a career limiting stigma to working remotely or having a flexible schedule, then they will of course be reluctant to use the option.
“We
reminded some of our partners who thought you had to be at your desk to be productive that they often were out of the office with clients and that they were actively
working during that period,” said Utley. “As our partners began to work remotely
and maintain efficiency, employees began to see it as an accepted practice.”
•
Ask every employee how many hours he or she wants to work. Every May,
managers at St.Paul-based Mahoney Ulbrich Christiansen & Russ ask employees to determine the number of hours they want to work as part of the formal
compensation process.
This reduces the stigma of asking for a reduced schedule because everyone is asked the same questions. Employees can customize
the exact number and schedule of the hours they want to work. “People pick
very personalized numbers based on daycare schedules, commuting times and
spouses work schedule,” said Bonnie Russ.
Greg Erickson, tax partner, Lattimore Black Morgan & Cain,
based in Brentwood, TN
Moment: “After five out of 25 employees in my office had babies during busy season, I saw
firsthand the demands of working parents.
One of my employees who was pregnant told me how
much daycare was going to cost her and the daycare she wanted had a two year waiting list. My
wife stayed at home so I had no idea how much daycare cost. I was shocked to learn that daycare
could consume up to 25% of their after-tax paycheck.”
Insight: “Childcare is expensive and often claims a high proportion of parents’ take home pay.
Getting children into the best and most convenient daycare is often challenging and stressful.”
Action: “I called the HR director to see if she was aware how expensive daycare was (as a working mom, she was).
I am now trying to figure out solutions, such as onsite daycare for my employees. The regulatory obstacles you have to deal with when trying to address this issue are cost
prohibitive, and we have to address that as a society if we really want to make daycare affordable.”
Donna M. Erbs, marketing director, Anders CPA, based in St.
Louis
Moment: “When my daughter was born in 1987, my boss sat me down and asked if I wanted to
work three days a week while keeping my title as marketing director. This type of arrangement
was unheard of 27 years ago. I worked very hard for the company because I was grateful for the
flexibility.”
Insight: “The flexibility meant so much to me and my family.
It has become personally important to me to provide this same flexibility to other families.”
Action: “I am committed to helping the members of my team balance work and family. Anders
works closely with individuals to help them design schedules and career paths that work for
personal goals and situations.”
Lance Brock, CPA, Mahoney Ulbrich Christiansen & Russ, based in St. Paul
Moment: “All three of my kids were born during busy season.
Since my wife works full-time,
I quickly experienced the challenges of a two parenting working family. I also saw our current
managing partner move through the ranks while working a reduced schedule for many years
during the non-busy season.”
Insight: “I realized that there is more to life than working 60 hours a week as well as there is
more involved in raising kids than I thought. I also saw that there is more than one career path
and that the traditional work model of working 50 to 60 hours a week is not the only way.
One
size does not fit all employees. Each employee has different needs and should be able to have a
career path that works for them. Additionally, with more women rising to leadership, the traditional male employee has changed and males are using flexibility as well.”
16
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
E
ntrepreneurship and Business Development
The most effective women’s initiatives integrate training with business development opportunities, said Melissa McClenaghan Martin, president, M3 Strategic Alliances, a New York women’s
business development consultancy.
Closely tracking results is essential, she adds. “If you don’t
track metrics, you help individual women, but you aren’t helping women in your firm overall,
which builds the business case,” she said.
•
47% of MOVE firms have marketing programs related to local entrepreneurship
•
56% of MOVE firms leverage alumni networks as a ‘talent halo’
. •
19% of MOVE firms offer a proven track for employees to transition to supplier or
contractor status
The most effective women’s initiatives integrate training with the creation of strategic business
development opportunities, said Melissa McClenaghan Martin, president, M3 Strategic Alliances, a New York-based consultancy that specializes in business development programs for women’s initiatives at professional services firms. “You must track business development metrics if
you want to build the business case for your women’s initiative – this includes tracking business
won, opportunities created and other marketing achievements of participating women,” she said.
“By coupling training with the creation of strategic business development opportunities, you
give participants opportunities to practice skills learned while pursuing conversion-oriented relationships,” Martin explains. “Firms need to move beyond women’s wine tastings, client events
and CPEs if they want real results,” she adds. “Firms could achieve exponential gains through
their women’s initiatives, but instead, too many settle for incremental gains, content with providing one-off trainings or typical ‘women’s’ events.”
Early, consistent business development skills training addresses several issues; It helps women
gain confidence and competence as they network with peers and capture some early wins – and
that helps them understand the expectations for becoming partner.
That’s the philosophy that
drives MCM, based in Louisville. Thirty nine percent of its partners are women, but MCM’s
WIN, or Women’s Inspirational Network, fosters internal networking among women that helps
them as they enter into its formal business development pipeline, said Beth Geiser, director of
practice growth. The initiative is expanding at all three MCM offices, opening opportunities for
mentoring and sponsorship firmwide.
Bonnie Russ, Partner, Mahoney Ulbrich Christiansen & Russ, based in
St.
Paul
Moment: During succession planning to prepare for upcoming retirements, partners at Mahoney Ulbrich Christiansen & Russ realized that the majority of the staff lacked the business
development and entrepreneurial skills needed for the firm to continue to succeed.
Insight: People who start accounting firms or join early typically have an entrepreneurial spirit.
However, people who work for established firms are not typically entrepreneurs and do not have
those skills or instincts that come naturally to others. Founders often don’t realize that these
skills are not second nature to everyone.
Action: “We need to show our employees, especially top performers, how to run a business and
be entrepreneurs. The firm started a new coaching program where each partner is responsible
for mentoring specific senior managers and is accountable for the manager reaching specific goals.”
“You have to get a couple wins at the beginning of your career,” said Erbs.
“You don’t just bring
in new business without practice. People don’t just wake up and have the skills to be a partner
or even a manager. You have to start by bringing donuts to a potential client.” Once the associates
move up the career ladder, basic networking tasks are expected so points are only given for more
advanced tasks and results to represent the increased expectations of higher level employees.
The
goal of the program is to bring in any new engagement, any type, any size, any dollar amount.
The firm’s investment paid off. In 2009, six percent of new business came from non-partner
employees, but now 21 percent of new business comes from staff. Erbs said that the ROI on the
advertising budget has been greater than any media advertisement would have netted, plus the
employees have learned skills that benefit both themselves and the firm.
Anders is in the process
of rolling out a “graduate” level of the PVS for supervisors, managers and principals who have
been using the PVS their whole careers and are now ready to concentrate on growing in more
specific business development areas.
Taught and Caught
For many rising accountants, business development is a skill that must be taught. Here are
additional winning ideas for teaching and encouraging business development skills:
Make it easy for clients and potential clients to see what’s happening with your women’s initiative. Give the initiative a unique social media hashtag, such as the #CRWomenCAN hashtag
that is used for WomenCAN related posts on CohnReznick’s social media accounts.
Hire a business development manager who also coaches CPAs at all levels.
Johanson & Yau
recruited a business development manager whose focus is creating new business opportunities
as well as coaching employees at all levels to build business development skills. By including
newer staff on calls with him and helping employees find opportunities to become active in the
business community, he provides strategic situations that build skills from the ground up.
Use external personalized coaching for partner track candidates. Hood & Strong, based in
San Jose, Calif., hired an external coach for a senior manager who had partner qualities to help
her gain business development skills.
The coaching combined with expanded client responsibilities gave her the skills she needed and she was named partner earlier this year. By using external
coaching on a case-by-case basis, Hood & Strong can select the coach specializing in the areas
and skills the employees needs to excel.
Meet monthly with young staff to help them assess what type of clients they’d
Dollars from Doughnuts
like to work with and detect how they might develop relationships with those
A $500 1040 client and a $20,000 new piece of business hardly seem equivalent.
But for a young professional, the former is an initial step in business development that may culminate in the latter years down the road.
In 2006, Anders marketing director Donna Erbs designed the Points Value System (PVS) for
each career level on a sliding scale to reward people on the effort that they put on their business
development efforts. The system awards points for all types of business development activities,
including taking a college contact out to drinks, attending a networking event, handing out one’s
18
business card, and serving on a community board, right up to winning new business.
She then
took her advertising budget and created an expense account for every employee to use for business development, ranging from $450 for associates to $1800 at higher levels.
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
clients from their current peer network.
—Lurie Besikof Lapidus & Co., Minneapolis
Offer a Lead Generation Incentive Program. In 2014, Lattimore Black Morgan & Cain paid
employees over $65,000 in bonuses through its Lead Generation program, which encourages
all employees to keep on the lookout for potential business. Both men and women have commented that the program showed them that business development often stems from existing
relationships, rather than intimidating cold calls.
. When Baker Tilly launched an internal newsletter to increase employee
awareness of GROW, its women’s initiative, the committee began using analytics to determine what type of content interests employees most, explained
Kimberly S. Herlitzka.
Using insight gained from the open and click-through rates of the newsletter
articles, the GROW committee can evaluate interest in the content and tailor
the material to what resonates with employees: editorials from firm leaders,
profiles of role models from across the firm; information on upcoming GROW
events in the firm’s offices; and links to additional resources.
Methodology
All employers strive to advance women. Public accounting firms with innovative programs and metrics to match can deepen trust and relationships with
clients by sharing both process and results. “I didn’t realize how important
WomenCAN was until we were in the model and doing it,” said Sharon Sullivan, a director with CohnReznick.
“As accountants, we are sometimes introverted. We don’t usually talk about our successes. You’d consider that bragging.
But through WomenCAN, we can make others aware of your contributions.
Personally, I wouldn’t have made that leap unless I was part of this program and
learning how to bring the women’s group to other people."l
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
The 2015 Accounting MOVE Project results are based on surveys and interviews with 47 firms that employ a total of 21,664 employees.
Research was
conducted from November 2014 through March 2015 by the Wilson-Taylor
Associates team. The Accounting MOVE Project is possible with the invaluable guidance and sponsorship of founding sponsor Moss Adams and national
sponsor CohnReznick.
Firms provided supplemental data and materials explaining their programs
intended to advance women. Interviews were conducted with firm partners,
human resources directors, and women managers, accounting academics and
consultants, and with women at all stages of their careers in public accounting.
The MOVE methodology is unique in that it indexes the proportion of women
in the leadership pipeline taught compared to the proportion of women employees.
For example, if women comprised 50% of all employees, and women
also comprised 50% of all managers, women would index at 1.00 for managers.
But, if women comprised 40% of the senior executives at this fictitious workplace, women would index at .80 — that is, women senior executives would be
under-represented by 20 points, compared to the proportion of women at this
workplace overall.
The MOVE methodology provides an apples-to-apples comparison of the status
of women across diverse industries, employer type (public or private), employer
size, and other factors that might otherwise obscure how well women actually
fare across the nation.l
20
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
About the Accounting/MOVE Project Partners
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
Moss Adams is one of the largest accounting and consulting firms
in the nation. Together with its affiliates, the firm provides insight and
expertise integral to its clients’ success, serving public, private and notfor-profit enterprises across the nation and in a wide range of industries.
•
Moss Adams LLP is a national leader in assurance, tax,
consulting, risk management, transaction, and wealth
services.
•
Moss Adams Wealth Advisors LLC provides investment
management, personal financial planning and insurance
strategies to help clients build and preserve their wealth.
•
Moss Adams Capital LLC offers investment banking and
strategic advisory services, helping clients create greater
value in their business.
CohnReznick LLP is one of the top accounting, tax, and advisory firms in the United States, combining the resources and
technical expertise of a national firm with the hands-on, entrepreneurial approach that today's dynamic business environment
demands. Headquartered in New York, NY, and with offices nationwide, CohnReznick serves a large number of diverse industries and offers specialized services for middle market and Fortune 1000 companies, private equity and financial services firms,
government contractors, government agencies, and not-for-profit
organizations.
The Firm, with origins dating back to 1919, has
more than 2,700 employees including nearly 300 partners and is
a member of Nexia International, a global network of independent accountancy, tax, and business advisors. For more information, visit www.cohnreznick.com.
The Accounting & Financial Women’s Alliance promotes
the professional growth of women in accounting and finance.
Members of the association benefit from opportunities to connect with colleagues, advance their careers and become industry
leaders. For 75 years, the organization has proudly upheld its
mission to enable women in all accounting and related fields to
achieve their full personal, professional and economic potential
and to contribute to the future development of their profession.
Visit www.afwa.org for more information.
.
AWSCPA is a national organization founded in 1933 dedicated
to serving all women CPAs. The AWSCPA provides a supportive
environment and valuable resources for members to achieve their
personal and professional goals through various opportunities
including leadership, networking and education. As the only resource exclusively for women CPAs and those aspiring to become
certified, the Society provides information as well as scholarships
to those in the profession. The Society is a leader in addressing
concerns such as gender equity, the glass ceiling, and work and
family issues.
AWSCPA members work in all segments of the accounting and financial profession, from individual practitioners
to professionals in industry, academia, and government, as well
as partners in all of the largest firms. Visit the AWSCPA Web site
at www.awscpa.org or call the Society’s office at (800) AWSCPA1
(297-2721).
Strategic communication firm Wilson-Taylor Associates, Inc.,
has been designing and managing national research projects that
measure the progress of women in the workplace since 1998.
Its methodology pivots on factors proven to remove barriers so
that women can fully participate in driving business results. Led
by veteran business journalist Joanne Cleaver, its current and
past clients include Women in Cable Telecommunications, the
Women’s Transportation Seminar, the Alliance for Workplace
Excellence, SitterCity, Ebyline.com, and many others.
Please see
Wilson-Taylor’s portfolio of work at
www.wilson-taylorassoc.com.l
External Sources
Best practices women in leadership. (2013, January 1). Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://issuu.com/kornferryinternational/docs/best_practices_women_in_leadership
•• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •• • •
Dads, not just moms, battle balancing work, family, exercise.
(n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2015,
from http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/10/141009100818.htm?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed: sciencedaily (Latest Science News
-- ScienceDaily)
Dahl, M., Dezső, C., & Gaddis Ross, D. (n.d.).
Like Daughter, Like Father: How Women’s Wages
Change When CEOs Have Daughters. Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://www.batz.ch/
wp-content/uploads/DaughtersofCEOs.pdf
Dizikes, P. (2014, October 7).
Study: Workplace diversity can help the bottom line. Retrieved
April 10, 2015, from http://newsoffice.mit.edu/2014/workplace-diversity-can-help-bottom-line-1007
Gino, F. (2014, October 10).
Ending Gender Discrimination Requires More than a Training Program. Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/10/ending-gender-discrimination-requires-more-than-a-training-program/?utm_content=buffer3440e&utm_
medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Kohn, S. (2014, December 17).
Stop denying the gender pay gap exists. Even Jennifer Lawrence
was shortchanged. Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://www.washingtonpost.com/
posteverything/wp/2014/12/17/stop-denying-the-gender-pay-gap-exists-even-jenniferlawrence-was-shortchanged/
Lapidos, J.
(2015, January 12). The Sony Hack and the Gender Pay Gap. Retrieved April 10, 2015,
from http://takingnote.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/01/12/the-sony-hack-and-the-genderpay-gap/?_r=0
Lowrey, A.
(2015, January 12). Charlize Theron versus the Gender Pay Gap. Retrieved April 10,
2015, from http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2015/01/charlize-theron-versus-thegender-pay-gap.html
Mohr, T.
(2014). Playing big: Find your voice, your mission, your message. New York, New York:
Gotham.
N.H.’s ‘Paycheck Fairness Act’ Takes Effect Jan.
1. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://
nhpr.org/post/nhs-paycheck-fairness-act-takes-effect-jan-1
Our Clients Shape The McGladrey Client Experience.
(n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2015, from
http://mcgladrey.com/content/mcgladrey/en_US/mcgladrey-client-experience/our-clients-shape-the-mcgladrey-experience.html
22
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
. Raimondo launches pay equity tip line, website - Warwick Beacon. (2015, April 10). Retrieved
April 10, 2015, from http://warwickonline.com/stories/Raimondo-launches-pay-equity-tip-linewebsite,99995?category_id=4&content_class=1&town_id=1&sub_type=stories
U.S. Department of Labor - Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) - Equal Pay
NPRM.
(n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2015, from http://www.dol.gov/ofccp/EPR.html
24
• 2015 Accounting MOVE Project Report
.