Asia
Outlook
Hiring Forecast
2016
Capital Continues to Flow from East to West
Focus on Core Assets in Asia-Pacific
Investors in Japan Climb the Risk Curve
China’s “Opportunistic” Debt Market
FPL ADVISORY GROUP
FERGUSON PARTNERS
FPL ASSOCIATES
FPL CONSULTING
. Introduction
2015 looks set to be a record-breaker for fundraising for
Asia Pacific, with many of the funds launched targeting core
investments. Traditionally, Asia has been a destination for
capital looking for opportunistic investments. However, over
the past few years, and especially in 2015, opportunistic
investing all but disappeared in most major Asian markets.
Instead, the focus increasingly has been on core and coreplus—a trend that will continue in 2016. However, core has
becomes an increasingly crowded area with more players
jumping on board in a tight deal environment.
The focus on
core assets in Asia-Pacific is a major theme for 2016. Other
trends for the year, as will be explored in this Asia Outlook
report, include the continued flow of capital from East to
West, investment opportunities in China and Japan, as well
as an in-depth look around the region.
In Japan, and especially in Tokyo, competition for core
assets is heightening, with activity being driven by domestic
players, such as private funds and JREITs. With few core
assets available in Tokyo, investors are venturing further
out along the risk curve, taking on regional, operational, and
development risk.
As we saw in 2015, capital continues to flow from east
to west, with New York and London among the primary
investment destinations.
China remains the No. 1 source
of investment capital in the region ($6.58bn at H1 2015),
followed by Singapore ($4.40bn), Australia ($2.92bn),
Hong Kong ($2.23bn), Taiwan ($1.79bn) and South Korea
($1.54bn). Bucking the trend is Malaysia, which has become
a net seller, capitalising on a weak ringgit and strong returns
on investments made post-global financial crisis.
Another major theme for the Asia Pacific region in 2016
continues to be China.
The big headline there has been
slowing economic growth, which is raising concerns about
China’s viability as a major international investor. In addition,
tightening lending practices and reduced access to capital
markets in China have set the stage for the emergence of
a distress market, which may attract some opportunistic
investors—but in debt, not equity.
Following is a discussion of the major trends that emerged in
2015 and the “hot topics” that are likely to influence hiring
activity in 2016.
© 2015 Ferguson Partners Ltd. | 2
.
2015 In Numbers
Global Capital Flows
January
• $329 million: Dalian Wanda
acquired office building Gold
Fields House in Sydney from
Blackstone.
• $220 million: APG entered into
a JV with Scape Student Living
in Australia.
• $201.5 million: CPPIB enters
into a JV with Longfor
Properties for a mixed use
development project in China.
February
• $1.9 billion: Anbang Insurance
completed their acquisition
of New York’s Walforf Astoria
Hotel from Hilton.
• $1.1 billion: Fosun Group
acquires Club Med holiday
group.
March
Capital continues to move from East to West. Asian investors, and most recently
those in Japan, led by Japan’s Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF), are
becoming active in overseas markets at a level that has not previously been seen.
This outward flow of capital into overseas real estate has stimulated a recruitment
need for distribution-focused roles in 2015. Demand for talent for such roles will
continue to be strong in 2016, particularly within the investment and private equity
space where there is a drive to export capital from Asia to Europe and North America.
With a lack of existing bilingual (Chinese, Korean, Japanese) real estate-focused
capital raisers, firms will have to identify the gaps in their existing Asia coverage
and balance the need for investor access and sales ability versus real estate product
expertise.
While the focus in Japan is around creating new access points and building
relationships in anticipation of capital moving offshore, with Chinese investors, the
emphasis is now on being able to differentiate diverse sources of capital in order
to understand their varying investment objectives. At the forefront of developing
relationships with the Chinese client base, many services firms have been expanding.
These include the real estate consultancies building their cross-border capital
markets teams, placement agents expanding their distribution capability, and real
estate advisory teams within the tax and accounting consultancies.
Chinese wealth
management platforms also will expand their offshore presence as domestic stock
market volatility leads to increased demand for international real estate.
In contrast to their Asian neighbours, Japanese institutional investors have taken
more of a conservative approach, but this looks set to change. Japan’s GPIF, the
largest public pension fund in the world, will start to invest in alternative assets and
is in the process of hiring a real estate team. As GPIF sets the trend, other pension
funds will likely follow suit, which will put capital into both offshore and onshore
investment products and vehicles.
The focus on capital raising across Asia will also continue to drive demand for
compliance and legal staff to enable firms to navigate the regulatory landscape.
• €21.5 million: Cordea
Savills acquired SEB Asset
Management’s real estate
business in Europe and Asia.
The combined entity was
rebranded as Savills Investment
Management.
• $365 million: Baring Private
Equity Asia closed its maiden
real estate fund.
April
• $1 billion: Blackstone raised for
its core investments in Asia.
• $500 million: China Life and
Ping An co-invested in Tishman
Speyer’s Pier 4 mixed-use
project in Boston.
Asia Outlook 2016 | 3
.
The following charts are based on Ferguson Partners’ data from completed and current mandates in 2015.
Hiring By Function
Hiring By Country
Australia
13%
Asset Management
5%
Development
7%
Korea
2%
Finance, Operations, Human
Resources
10%
Greater China
16%
Japan
53%
Singapore
16%
C-Suite
10%
Corporate Officers
2%
Board
5%
Vice President to
Managing Director
29%
Brokerage/Advisory
Services
20%
Hiring By Client Profile
Principal Investors
12%
Business Line Head
37%
Country Head
17%
Fund Management
13%
Capital Raising/Business
Development
18%
Hiring By Seniority
Acquisitions
27%
Operational
Management*
19%
Third Party
Investment Managers*
48%
Services/Brokerage
21%
*Operational Management: Hospitality, logistics, storage, student
housing, healthcare.
*Third Party Investment Managers: Private equity, hedge funds,
investment managers (listed and unlisted).
© 2015 Ferguson Partners Ltd. | 4
. Different Markets, Different Capital
In the last 12 months, we have continued to see major
Asian sovereign wealth funds, insurance companies,
conglomerates, developers, and trading firms
establishing a physical presence in overseas markets.
Developers from China, Malaysia, and now Japan, are
actively engaged in major projects in cities such as
London, New York, and San Francisco, placing equity
into multifamily developments on the U.S. West Coast,
and developing suburban residential projects in cities
such as Sydney.
For 2016, we also foresee Asian developers,
conglomerates, and insurance firms continuing to
establish offshore investment offices and starting to
hire local talent as opposed to relocating their Asiabased employees. Fosun Property Group, a Chinese
conglomerate, has been one of the pioneers thus far in
employing this strategy; it has been establishing offices
and partnerships, and hiring local talent in Australia,
Japan, Europe/UK and North America. The notable
benefits of this strategy include superior access to deal
flow and networks.
Following their lead, we will also see some of the major
independent Japanese asset managers continue to build
out regional operations in the U.S., Europe, and within
the Asia region, with a view to engaging with Asian and
international investors requiring advisory partners and
services in Japan.
Australia: Pursuing Core Returns
Where “Cash Is King”
Australia is one of the few countries in Asia Pacific to
offer investors opportunities for core returns; therefore,
it is of utmost importance that firms retain their edge
in this competitive market where “cash is king.” Global
capital sources across Europe, North America, and Asia
are all circling the same deals as domestic players—and,
indeed, much of the same talent, too.
For 2016, we anticipate that the global real estate players
who are not currently in Australia will look to build a
presence.
These platforms will focus on transacting on
behalf of their core funds, as well as accessing capital
from the superannuation funds.
India: Global Managers Starting to
Revisit
Southeast Asian sovereign wealth funds and private
equity funds have been chasing opportunistic returns
in India. Deal flow has mainly been facilitated by
forming strategic joint ventures with local developers
and partners to invest in this market. This approach
minimises risk as local partners provide insights
into demographics of a particular market and local
knowledge about deal flow.
Activity in India has been broadly split between large
private equity and institutional capital able to take a
long-term view on the one hand and domestic specialists
able to access deal flow on the other.
There is evidence
that the regional and global managers are starting to
revisit opportunities in India, and we are starting to see
the green shoots of hiring demand.
Hospitality
Hospitality was the asset class du jour for 2015, as
many Asian investors have been active in this sector and
turned their attention to key markets in Europe and the
U.S. There were several notable acquisitions including
Anbang Insurance Group’s $1.95 billion purchase of
New York’s Waldorf Astoria and Fosun’s acquisition
of Club Med. Closer to home, we saw ADIA ink an
agreement with New World Development for $2.4 billion
to buy a 50% stake in three hotels in Hong Kong, while
Gaw Capital led the purchase of the InterContinental
Hong Kong for $940 million.
However, the star player
regionally has been Japan.
Meanwhile, on the hotel manager side, operators are
examining their Asia strategies. The slowdown in
China, along with the anti-corruption agenda, has led
to pressure in the oversupplied upscale and luxury
sector and may yet create rebranding opportunities
for operators in a market that has been predominately
focused on new development. We have also seen a trend
of integration between local and global operators both
inbound and outbound.
Recent examples include Fosun
Group acquiring Club Med; Accor Hotels agreeing to an
alliance with China Lodging Group; and more recently,
speculation around Chinese hotel managers (Jin Jiang)
and institutional investors (CIC, HNA Group) bidding for
Starwood and IHG.
In Japan, tourism has been on the rise for the past
two years, thanks in part to relaxation of some visa
restrictions for Asian visitors. According to estimates,
some 14 million tourists had visited Japan by September
2015, well exceeding expectations, and numbers for
2016 are anticipated to surpass this level. Investors
and operators are focused on how they can increase
their footprint in Japan to capitalise on growth in an
undersupplied market and leading up to the Olympics.
Investors in the hospitality sector have also been trying
to build out their portfolios, in regional areas, such as
Kanazawa, which was linked to Tokyo by bullet train in
March 2015.
Another popular regional hub for tourism
is Osaka, which boasts Universal Studios Japan and a
major international airport, is in close proximity to both
Asia Outlook 2016 | 5
. Just as Japan has been promoting tourism, Prime Minster Abe’s economic policies
(“Abenomics”) also have encouraged business travelers to return. In response, international
and domestic owners and operators have been investing in and positioning mid long-term
serviced apartment accommodation, especially in Tokyo. Student accommodation also
has been attracting more attention with the arrival of an international group investing,
developing, and operating premium student housing.
Demand for talent in hospitality continues to be robust, with a focus on developing locally
based leaders who are equipped to react to a shifting market dynamic, which will put more
emphasis on strategy as opposed to pure room growth. Integrating loyalty programs,
sales and marketing teams, and creating corporate identity and a more culturally targeted
brand experience will all impact the approach to recruitment in the sector.
2015 In Numbers
Kyoto and Kobe, and is proving itself to be the main entry point and base for Kansai
tourism.
May
• $2 billion: DTZ acquired
Cushman & Wakefield.
• $2.4 billion: ADIA’s HIP entered
into a JV with New World
Development to buy a 50%
stake in 3 hotels in Hong Kong.
June
• $1 billion: CLSA closed their 3rd
pan-Asia opportunity fund at its
hard cap.
• $1 billion: Japan-focused
Fortress Real Estate
Opportunities Fund II closed at
its hard cap.
• $5.5 billion: 12 Asian private
real estate funds in H1 2015
contributed to the 2nd highest
post-crisis first-half capital
raise.
July
Japan: A Competitive Investment Destination
Tokyo remains a prime investment
destination, both for foreign capital and
for domestic investors.
Property supply in
Tokyo and Japan is very tight, which makes
it extremely challenging to find deals. The
deals that do occur are in the core or coreplus market, with far fewer opportunities
for value-add or opportunistic activities.
JREITs continue to be aggressive acquirers
of real estate, and for 2016 we anticipate
several new listings from both domestic
and foreign sponsors, taking the number
of JREITs to more than 60. The appetite
for A-grade assets among these REITs and
private funds will mean an ever-decreasing
supply, as assets “disappear” off market,
with no indication as to when they might
come back to be traded.
As with 2014,
major A-grade and portfolio deals in 2015
were primarily from international sellers
looking to capitalise on rising prime asset
values.
Despite these challenges, international
capital is still being attracted to Japan. In
2015, more Asian capital looked for deals
in Japan, along with global institutional and
sovereign investors that are underexposed
in Japan. Some of these players continue to
access the market remotely, from global or
regional offices, while others are looking
to establish Tokyo offices; for example,
the Norwegian sovereign group recently
opened an operation in Tokyo.
This trend
looks set to continue in 2016, with firms
already working on opening up new
operations or expanding existing regional
businesses into Japan.
• $1 billion: The size of GE
Capital’s Japan property
portfolio that was sold to PAG
Real Estate Partners.
• $1.8 billion: CIC International
acquired Investa Property
Group in Australia from Morgan
Stanley Real Estate Investing.
August
• 8.5%: Shanghai stocks plummet
on August 24th; China’s Black
Monday.
• $500 million: Invesco Real
Estate launch their first
opportunistic fund in Asia since
the 2011 acquisition of AIG.
© 2015 Ferguson Partners Ltd. | 6
. 2015 In Numbers
September
• $435 million: The State Oil
Fund of Azerbaijan make their
first foray into Japan real estate
in partnership with Mitsubishi
UFJ Trust and Banking
Corporation.
• $719 million: Ascendas REIT
acquire a portfolio of 26
logistics properties in Australia
from GIC and Frasers Property
Australia.
October
• $940 million: Gaw Capital
acquired the InterContinental
Hong Kong.
• $370 million: Saizen REIT
acquired by Lone Star.
• $1 billion: Hulic Co acquired
Simplex Invstment Advisors
from Aetos Capital.
Foreign investors have two strategies
when it comes to establishing a presence
in Japan, either organically or via a
platform acquisition. Given where
Japan is in the cycle and the difficulty
of growing an operation and a portfolio
organically, many firms are keen to
conduct corporate due diligence.
As new teams are built or existing
teams grow, the demand has and will
be centered on sourcing managers and
senior investment managers who can
lead Japan investment strategies. In
2015, we also saw more requests for
mid-level hires to support on execution
and asset management; we feel that this
will remain a theme in 2016.
Meanwhile, high-net worth and family
office capital is also flowing into Japan,
occasionally into smaller commercial
deals, but increasingly into residential,
and wealthy Asians are investing in offplan apartments in central Tokyo. This
has fueled an increase in residential sales
teams at both smaller domestic agencies
and global property services firms.
Moving Up the Risk Curve
November
• $1.6 billion: Evergrande Real
Estate set a record in Hong
Kong for an office asset when
they acquired Mass Mutual
Tower.
• $12.2 billion: Marriott acquired
Starwood Hotels & Resorts
creating the world’s largest
hotel company.
December
• $57 million: M&G Real Estate
acquired 2 industrial assets in
east and west Sydney.
• $16 billion: Asian Development
Bank and Government of Japan
announced a 5 year partnership
to invest in infrastructure
projects and developments
throughout Asia Pacific.
Echoing trends we saw in 2006 and
2007, the lack of supply is pushing
investors up the risk curve, and in order
to be active in Japan, many investors are
getting creative and becoming willing to
take on greater degrees of risk.
Operational Risk
In addition to hotels discussed earlier,
and logistics which is now well
established as an investment class
in Japan, investors are increasingly
taking on operational risk with serviced
apartments, student accommodation,
healthcare, self-storage, solar energy, and
infrastructure gaining greater interest
in 2015.
These are emerging as the
next wave of institutionally recognised
asset classes. As two new Japanese
healthcare REITs demonstrated in 2015,
these asset classes could potentially
form the base of new asset-specific
listed trusts in Japan in the future.
With few specialised players currently,
the pool of available bilingual talent with
direct asset experience required by these
operators is limited. As with logistics in
the past, they will most likely pull on real
estate professionals with solid technical
skills for underwriting and transaction
management,
or
development
experience to support the growth of the
property pipeline through new builds or
conversion projects.
A strong interest
and motivation to become a sector
specialist will be paramount for any hire
to be a success.
Development Risk
Development costs in Japan remain high,
driven by the continued reconstruction
following the 2011 earthquake, major
government- and city-backed urban
redevelopment programs, general office
and condominium developments, and
the 2020 Summer Olympics. Despite
these factors, the lack of supply has
encouraged investors to take on some
development risk, especially in hotels
and other operating asset classes; as
a result, bilingual candidates with a
mixture of development and investment
experience are highly valued.
Public to Private Risk
In addition, we have recently seen
evidence of major opportunistic players
looking to take down listed vehicles
to access the underlying Japan-based
portfolios. As in the US, we may see more
“public-to-private” themes and potential
consolidation of listed trusts, as larger
opportunistic investors target REITs
trading below net asset value in order
to capture their often regionally focused
portfolios.
Asia Outlook 2016 | 7
.
China – Economic Questions Dominate the Discussion
The big headline for China has been slowing economic growth and concerns about its growth rate in the future.
Adding to the speculation about China’s potentially waning financial strength, some Chinese insurance companies
and pension funds have pulled back from some high profile deals, such as Anbang’s anticipated investment in
London’s Heron Tower. A closer look at completed transactions suggests that Chinese investors are still doing more
looking than buying.
Mezzanine Debt Opportunities in
China
The economic situation in China is beginning to pique
investor interest. One such opportunity is providing
mezzanine financing to fill a “funding gap” caused by
limited access to the capital markets and tighter lending
controls by domestic banks. Further contributing to the
funding gap is the slowdown in residential sales, which
traditionally has provided development cash flow to
enable developers to hold and lease commercial office
assets.
In addition, weakness in the China stock market
has exacerbated the funding shortfall for developers
requiring additional financing. (Conversely, stock
market volatility has led to increased interest in global
real estate, as investment returns in the sector have
proven to be stable versus equity markets.)
Private equity firms, in particular, are looking at
mezzanine financing in China—one of the few
opportunistic plays in a major Asian market that offers
a relatively risk-adjusted strategy. In terms of talent, we
are seeing demand for candidates who are familiar with
investing across the capital stack and with specific debt
experience, both for private equity investors preparing
for more market fluctuations and longer-term capital
starting to see a gap in the domestic lending markets.
The second potential opportunistic play is in distressed
properties.
Tighter lending and recent evidence that
China may allow foreclosures have given rise to a focus
on debt—distressed investing (equity), as well as focused
mezzanine, senior debt, and mortgage strategies.
Listed Developers Face Thinner
Short-Term/Long-Term Property
Spreads
Several publicly traded Chinese developers, which
dominate the Singapore and Hong Kong stock markets,
have traditionally been very long-term holders of
commercial office and retail properties, while acting
more like traders in residential. The spread between
long-term commercial/retail and short-term residential
typically keeps their share prices steady.
Now, with the governments of Hong Kong and Singapore
clamping down on residential prices, this sector has
remained flat. And, with a potential lag in growth in
the commercial sector, developers are realising thinner
spreads.
As a result, their share prices could be affected.
In the future, some property developers may dispose
of commercial office assets that they normally would
have held for the long term. If this materialises, it would
create opportunities for funds to buy in these markets.
In addition, developers may turn to the capital markets
to generate some value. For example, some privately
held portfolios as well as listed companies could form
REITs from some of their asset holdings.
At this point,
we see this scenario as a potential opportunity, which
may or may not be realised.
© 2015 Ferguson Partners Ltd. | 8
. FPL ADVISORY GROUP
FERGUSON PARTNERS
FPL ASSOCIATES
FPL CONSULTING
About FPL Advisory Group
FPL Advisory Group (“FPL”) is a global professional services firm that specialises in providing executive search, compensation,
and management consulting solutions to a select group of related industries. Our committed senior partners bring a wealth of
expertise and category-specific knowledge to leaders across the real estate, hospitality and leisure, and healthcare sectors.
FPL is comprised of three primary operating companies that work together to serve a common client base. Ferguson Partners
Ltd. provides executive and director recruitment, succession planning, and board assessment services, FPL Associates provides
compensation consulting services, and FPL Consulting provides a range of organisational, financial and strategic consulting
services.
From Chicago, Hong Kong, London, New York, San Francisco, Singapore, Tokyo, and Toronto, we serve clients across the globe.
For more information please contact:
Peter Rackowe
Max d’Ambrumenil
President- International
Ferguson Partners Japan
2F Fukide Daini Building
4-1-21 Toranomon, Minato-ku
Tokyo, Japan 105-0001
Phone: (+81) 3 3436 6171
E-mail: prackowe@fergusonpartners.com
Regional Director
Ferguson Partners Hong Kong
17/F China Building
29 Queen’s Road Central
Central, Hong Kong
Phone: (+852) 3978 2195
E-mail: mdambrumenil@fergusonpartners.com
Martin Eastgate
Patrick Balfour
Director
Ferguson Partners Japan
2F Fukide Daini Building
4-1-21 Toranomon, Minato-ku
Tokyo, Japan 105-0001
Phone: (+81) 3 3436 6175
E-mail: meastgate@fergusonpartners.com
Director
Ferguson Partners Hong Kong
17/F China Building
29 Queen’s Road Central
Central, Hong Kong
Phone: (+852) 3978 2195
E-mail: pbalfour@fergusonpartners.com
CHICAGO HONG KONG LONDON NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO SINGAPORE TOKYO TORONTO
www.fpladvisorygroup.com
The Ferguson Partners recruitment practice consists of five affiliated entities serving FPL’s clients around the world: Ferguson Partners Ltd.
headquartered in Chicago with other locations in New York and San Francisco,
Ferguson Partners Canada Co. in Toronto, Ferguson Partners Europe Ltd. headquartered in London with a Japan branch located in Tokyo, Ferguson Partners Hong Kong Ltd.
in Hong Kong, and Ferguson Partners
Singapore Pte. Ltd. in Singapore.
Ferguson Partners Europe Ltd. is registered in England and Wales, No. 4232444, Registered Office: 100 New Bridge Street, London, EC4V 6JA.
Ferguson Partners Singapore Pte. Ltd. is
registered in Singapore, Business Registration No.
(UEN) 201215619H, Employment Agency License No. 12S6233. FPL Associates L.P., the entity which provides consulting services to FPL’s clients, is headquartered in
Chicago.
Asia Outlook 2016 | 9
.