Private Equity/Capital Markets
SPRING 2015
INNOVATIONS IN GLOBAL
CONNECTIONS
PRIVATE EQUITY
IN THE MIDDLE MARKET
HEADING for the
Owner, Investor and
Banker Perspectives
featuring
insights from
Grant Thornton LLP
NewSpring Capital
Raymond James & Associates
Relay Network
. INNOVATIONS IN GLOBAL
CONNECTIONS
PRIVATE EQUITY
IN THE MIDDLE MARKET
. Table of Contents
01
Letter to Our Readers
02
Market Environment:
The Macro Overview
06
The Exit Process: Key
Questions and Players
14
Industry Attractiveness:
Where to Find the Deals
20
Timing, Preparation and
Momentum
30
Valuation, Best Buyer and
Certainty Around Closure
37
Conclusion
38
SPEAKER profiles
40
ABOUT DUANE MORRIS
. a leTTer To our readers
s
Successfully selling a privately-held middle-market business—
whether outright, retaining a portion, or in an initial public
offering (IPO)—is one of the greatest personal, financial and
legal challenges an owner will face. Though the stakes are
indeed high for the owner, they are also considerable for
investors, employees and the legacy of the business.
“MORe IMPORtANt
tHAN tHe wIll
tO wIN IS tHe wIll
tO PRePARe.”
-Charlie Munger,
Berkshire Hathaway
Consequently, much can be gained from owners who have
“gotten it right” and especially those “serial owners” who have developed a true talent from
repeatedly selling their businesses. Similarly, the accumulated experience and know-how of
the key players in the exit process—investment bankers, investors, legal counsel and financial
advisors—are also worth careful review and study.
Duane Morris organized its “Heading for the Exit” event, held in Philadelphia last November,
specifically to bring together these key players to discuss the nuances around exiting a company
in today’s complex and crowded marketplace. We are honored to have the participation of the
following individuals who contributed to what was a lively and insightful discussion:
• DAVID ClARK, Managing Director, Head of Financial Sponsors Group, Raymond James & Associates
• MIKe DiPIANO, Managing General Partner and Founder of NewSpring Capital
• MAtt GIllIN, CEO and Co-Founder of Relay Network, formerly the Founder and CEO
of Ecount, which was sold in 2007
• DARRICK MIx, partner in the Duane Morris Capital Markets Practice
• JOHN StINe, Assistant Office Managing Partner and Tax Partner, Grant Thornton LLP
Ultimately, what an owner wants to achieve—in what can be a drawn-out, unpredictable
process—is a “good exit.” This may have many dimensions; however, we think it comes down
to owners’ receiving a fair price and feeling a sense of accomplishment, both for themselves,
as well as the broader business and its stakeholders.
.
A key takeaway from the event is the overriding importance of preparedness—getting out ahead of the
process, e.g., clearly understanding what you as an owner-manager want to accomplish, deciding what
approach to take to get there and choosing your team. Although preparedness may not guarantee a
“good exit,” unpreparedness is most likely to lead to a “bad exit”—the sale does not close, a founder
suffers seller’s remorse, employees feel let down and the legacy of the business is in question.
We trust that you will find this publication, a collaborative effort of Duane Morris’ Private Equity and
Capital Markets groups, to be both thought-provoking and a helpful guide to the exit process. Please
let us know what you think.
Pierfrancesco Carbone
Co-Head of Private Equity –
UK / Europe
Duane Morris LLP
Richard P. Jaffe
Co-Head of Private Equity
Duane Morris LLP
Darrick Mix
Partner
Capital Markets
Duane Morris LLP
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
1
.
From left: NewSpring Capital’s Mike DiPiano, Relay Network’s Matt Gillin and Raymond James’ David Clark
contemplate the market environment.
MarkeT environMenT:
The MaCro overview
D
“Deal Boom Feeds on Surging Stocks” was the front-page story in The Wall Street Journal
the day before Duane Morris’ “Heading for the Exit” event.1 The story noted that global
M&A volume had already breached the $3 trillion mark for the year, up 32 percent over
the similar period in 2013, as companies took advantage of rising stock prices and cheap
credit, both a function of the Federal Reserve’s easy-money policies. The U.S. accounted
for about half of this amount by value, up 37 percent relative to 2013 (See Chart 1).
2
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. Chart 1: Big Year for North American M&A
6000
1,200.00
1,000.00
800.00
600.00
percent in 2014—indicating it was another good
3000
1,400.00
the majority of the value of IPOs—by nearly 62
4000
1,600.00
2000. Financial sponsors continue to account for
5000
1,800.00
$Billion
non-financial sponsors) were the highest since
year for investors of private equity funds.2
2000
400.00
1000
0.00
The corporate buying spree and strong IPO market
0
200.00
are occurring despite serious headwinds, such as
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Deal Value ($B)
Deal Number
Source: Capital IQ
Includes transactions with disclosed value over $10mm
recent market volatility, a weakening Chinese
economy, Japan falling back into recession,
continued lackluster economic performance in
Europe and a faltering Russian economy.
2014 was also a big year for IPOs, which by value
jumped by nearly 77 percent from the previous
Panelists at the Duane Morris event were
year to nearly $60 billion (See Chart 2). The
generally upbeat, with Mike DiPiano, Managing
291 North American listings (by financial and
General Partner and founder of NewSpring
Chart 2: Value of Financial- and Non-Financial Sponsor-Backed IPOs
110
450
100
400
90
350
80
$ Billions
60
250
50
200
40
Number
300
70
150
30
100
20
50
10
0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Non-PE IPO proceeds
PE IPO proceeds
2012 2013 2014
0
PE IPO number
Non-PE IPO number
Source: EY
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
3
. Capital, observing that he did not see interest
Office Managing Partner and Tax Partner at Grant
rates rising much; hence, “there’s going to be
Thornton LLP, notes that his firm is “unbelievably
debt available.” In addition, he continues, “There
busy on transactions right now,” which is not the
is a fair amount of capital with buyout shops
norm for this time of year.
like ours that are paid to put money to work,”
which would encourage the industry “to continue
In Clark’s view, 2015 “is going to be another
buying” and “the IPO market to perk up.”
strong year” and “the IPO market is going to
continue to be solid,”—barring any unexpected
David Clark, Managing Director, Head of Financial
events. Plenty of prospective buyers and an
Sponsors Group at Raymond James & Associates,
improving economy translate into a seller’s
agrees with DiPiano—“Our economist’s view is
market. A number of private equity firms, as well
that interest rates may go up, but they are not
as family-owned businesses, “have reached out
going to go up by that much, so there’s still
to us to talk about their business,” he says. The
plenty of capital out there.” In addition to private
question on their mind is: “Is this a good time
equity money, “there is a lot of cash on the
to exit, and if so, how is the best way to do
balance sheets” of strategics, he noted.
Clark also
it?” That said, from a buyer’s perspective, “The
highlighted that limited partners increasingly want
market is very frothy with a lot of capital chasing
co-invest opportunities.
deals,” Clark observes.
Turning the spotlight on another leading indicator
Indeed, the successful exit market last year, which
saw private equity funds return an expected $479
of the market’s direction, John Stine, Assistant
T he Duane Morris V i e w
You can’t time a sale, but . . .
A significant factor contributing to the liquidity the industry is experiencing is that the
constellation of potential buyers and strategies has expanded well beyond the usual suspects.
This phenomenon provides sellers—provided that they are well prepared—with more leverage
so that they can better tailor an exit to address their particular goals and needs.
4
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
.
Chart 3: 2014 Saw Jump in Distributions and Fundraising
($Billion)
Distributions
500
Fundraising
400
300
200
100
0
$171 BN
Annual Average
2009-2013
$479 BN
$270 BN
2014 Annualized Annual Average
2009-2013
$450 BN
2014 Estimate
Source: Triago, The Triago Quarterly, November 2014, p. 1
billion globally, is likely to create an even more
crowded deal market in 2015 as investors reinvest (See Chart 3).3 According to Preqin data,
the proportion of funds that reached or exceeded
their “hard cap” (i.e., maximum amount the firms
set out to raise) in 2014 was at its highest level
since 2009.
capital—has been growing over the past few
years. Hamilton Lane estimates that this pool of
capital represents about 50 percent of the cash
raised by traditional U.S. funds.4 Therefore, going
into 2015, close to $670 billion in capital will
be looking to get invested in deals—exclusive of
money the strategics bring to the table.
In addition to more capital cycling back to
commingled funds, “shadow fundraising”—which
includes money investors set aside for coinvestment, separate accounts and secondary
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
5
.
The exiT ProCess: key
QuesTions and Players
C
Careful preparation and execution are two preconditions to a successful exit. “The
key is getting prepared and getting everything done upfront, and running as efficient
a process as possible,” observes Clark at Raymond James. “At the end, that’s where
the value’s going to be,” he says. Thus, Clark spends considerable time with owners
to provide guidance on whether “this is the right time for your business to come to
market and exit,” and if so, “How do you want to do it? What is the best process?”
.
Part of the answer on whether “this is the right
time,” Clark notes, turns on “What are the
intentions of the management team?” Owners
may want to exit the business completely or
perhaps stay on longer, but gain some liquidity.
Clark indicates that “It is always harder to exit
a business if the management team—senior
management and CEO—is looking to retire and
move on.” Having a good management team
in place makes the business more stable and
attractive, especially for private equity firms that
typically are focused on backing management
teams. As an interim step, he suggests that “the
number two [in charge] be elevated to the CEO
position to run the business for a period of time
before the exit.”
energy and funds wasted when owners have
pulled back from an exit at the last minute. “If
you are only halfway committed, it will not work
well,” Stine observes.
Considerations about the timing of an exit, says
Clark, are really about the business: “Where is it
in the cycle, what growth is expected down the
road, and if there is a lot of growth expected—
can the owner get value for that growth today?”
He adds that “to really position the company
for the best exit,” it is vital to “understand the
business opportunity over the next couple of
years and how value can be generated, whether
through organic growth or by acquisitions.”
Exit Alternatives
Alternatively, a CEO may agree to stay for a
transition period. Stine at Grant Thornton
emphasizes that “owners need to be committed,”
as announcing their plans to exit the business puts
the firm at risk.
He has witnessed tremendous
Owners can exit a business in a number of ways.
Clark outlines that owners can sell their business
to a strategic or to a private equity firm, or exit
through an IPO (See Chart 4). A private equity
buyer, he says, “will typically want management
Chart 4: Alternative Exit Opportunities and Implications
CEO / Owner Responsibilities
Business Case for
New Owner
Sell to a Strategic
Complete Exit
Synergistic Growth Opportunities
Sell Control Stake to PE
Stay on / Find Replacement Early
Platform or Add-on
Partial Exit
Maintain Ownership / Leadership
Current Owner Gains Liquidity
IPO
Maintain Ownership / Leadership
Capture High Valuation /
Potential Secondary
Exit Alternatives
Source: Duane Morris, 2015
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
7
. or prior owners to keep some equity in the
business,” and “will basically invest alongside
them.” Finally, owners may choose a partial exit,
“to take some money off the table and diversify
their net worth,” Clark notes.
There are key differences between a sale to
a strategic versus a private equity firm. Clark
indicates that “a strategic buyer typically can
buy 100 percent of the stock,” which enables
the owner to exit the business completely. “The
owner may end up getting shares in the acquirer’s
Through a minority recapitalization (recap), an
owner can gain some liquidity by selling an
interest in the business, but continue to maintain
control. At NewSpring Capital, DiPiano has done
a number of recaps and says, “Usually we do
them when we think there is a lot of runway
in the business for growth,” but he adds, they
“retrigger timing.” He notes that “Once you take
capital from somebody, and sell a portion of your
business, you are setting a new clock for two,
three or four years,” to enable the new investor
to get the value they are looking for, which is a
multiple of what they invested.
stock,” but, he adds, “the owner is going to get
value based on the business today.” Conversely,
a private equity firm will generally look to
management and owners to contribute some
equity into the business and to continue to be
involved.
By investing alongside the new owner,
“Management will have equity that increases in
value over time as the business grows,” said
Clark.
8
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
In today’s market, the IPO market is a very
attractive exit option, Clark maintains. It has
advantages and disadvantages. The upside of an
.
IPO, he says, is that “an owner will gain stock
that reflects the firm’s growth prospects” and will
have liquidity that enables the owner to monetize
that value. The downside, Clark continues, is that
when an owner exits the business through an
IPO, he or she “is not truly exiting the business
because the owner will continue to own a
meaningful amount of the equity for a period
of time and, thus, be subjected to the equity
markets.”
“I thought an IPO would be the most exciting
thing in the world,” declares DiPiano, “and
although it is exciting, it also turns out to be
painful in some ways.” While “you hope to get
a higher price than you would in an outright
sale, you are subject to a lot of SEC scrutiny.”
Moreover, he says, many CEOs do not like the
limelight, as analysts covering the stock will
shop the company. “I have found if you get a
reasonable value, an all-out sale is one that we
would prefer,” DiPiano concludes.
That said, DiPiano agrees with Clark that it has
been a good IPO market, thanks to plentiful debt
and high stock market valuations. “We are seeing
a number of successful IPOs and a very strong
pipeline,” so it is clearly an option at this point in
time, Clark observes.
“I think part of the reason
why the M&A market is attractive right now,” he
indicates, “is because of the positive IPO market.”
The Quarterback and Key Players
Making sure an exit goes smoothly and is
successful requires a team effort. “It’s very
important to have a strong team,” says Clark and
“it’s going to be accountants, lawyers and bankers”
(See Chart 5). Matt Gillin, CEO and Co-Founder
of Relay Network, learned this as a CEO and
Founder of Ecount, which he successfully exited
in 2007.
“You’ve got to choose your team wisely,
both from a lawyer and a banker perspective,”
he emphasizes. Fortunately for him, through the
many twists and turns of selling Ecount, his team
“was willing to do whatever it took.”
As he relates his experience, Gillin says his
training told him that “The best way to get the
deal done was to get consensus across the
board.” As the founder of Ecount since 1997,
he knew the company’s intimate details, and
having been burned a couple of times on prior
exit attempts, Gillin wanted to ensure he was
receiving as much advice as he could. “In our
case, because we got everyone on board with a
number up front [minimum transaction value], I
was able to play the quarterback role,” he notes.
(See Box: Ecount: Key Milestones on the Road to
a Successful Exit, p.
12).
Chart 5: Deal Team
Investment
Banker
Financial
Advisor
OWNER
Lead Board
Member/
Investor
Legal
Counsel
Source: Duane Morris, 2015
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
9
. In Clark’s view, selling a company requires “a
point person from within the company,” and
it makes sense that this is the CEO “because
ultimately, they have to sell the story to the
buyer.” He adds that sometimes it actually makes
sense for the owners and management to step
back—for example, “when you are really trying to
get down to the final deal valuation and terms.”
Then, “The lawyers and the bankers can step in
and basically be the bad guys, be in front of the
buyer and push a particular point,” Clark says.
DiPiano at NewSpring Capital tends to agree that
the quarterback “is almost always your CEO.”
Though he notes that “it’s sometimes your CEO tied
together with a stakeholder that has experience,”
or “sometimes there’s a trusted lawyer.” The CEO’s
From left: Mike DiPiano of NewSpring Capital, Matt Gillin
of Relay Network, David Clark of Raymond James and
John Stine of Grant Thornton.
10
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
and lead board member’s vantage points can be
instrumental to see a deal through and not get
bogged down by minor details.
Investment Bankers
Another set of key players are investment bankers.
DiPiano says NewSpring Capital has used a
banker literally in every transaction where there
was an exit because “they know the ropes, the
market and the terms.” Whereas an owner and
an investor may start to negotiate the transaction,
the banker is “dealing with it every day” and is paid
to deal with the “really contentious discussions,”
he notes. As an investor, even if the owner has
already picked a buyer, DiPiano retains a banker
“to check out other options to make sure that
. the buyer is being held accountable and there
is a high certainty to close at the valuation we
were hoping.”
Stine at Grant Thornton recommends that “two,
three, four years out from selling, owners of
companies develop a relationship with one or
more banks,” as they will “gain a tremendous
amount of information.” He sees a massive upside,
as bankers will “pick apart your numbers for free,
give you a lot of insight into the market, help
prepare you for the exit and give you a road
map as to where you’re going.” The alternative,
Stine says, is “waiting to the last minute and
doing a ‘beauty contest,’ which means rushing the
process,” and increasing the probability for failure.
In Gillin’s experience, investment bankers are
an “incredible resource.” While not engaging a
banker in his first attempt to sell Ecount, the
second time around, “we interviewed a bunch of
them”—and asked each the same five questions.
They included: “How would you tell the Ecount
story? What valuation do you think we will
get? Who exactly would you target at these
companies?” Gillin says the process yielded an
“incredible road map,” especially around how to
“tell the Ecount story.” It helped his team “realize
that to sell your company, you had to package it
up like a product.”
Another key role for bankers is to provide
introductions. To help family-owned firms gain
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
11
. Ecount: Key Milestones on the Road
to a Successful Exit
1997 Ecount’s birth in the basement of the home of Matt Gillin’s parents.
2000
Softbank set to invest $50 million into the company, but the deal was sidelined with the
crash of the market following Black Friday.
2001
Investment made by NewSpring Capital for minority share of company and board seat;
at the time, other shareholders included: Gillin’s family, himself and Cross Atlantic.
2004 “Experian shows up, and they said, ‘Hey, we’d like to buy your company for $40 million.’
We brought everyone into the room, said, ‘We got a deal for $40 million’ and did not
verify any of it. Did not really know how to sell a business.”
“We went through a process, and we did absolutely everything wrong.“
“We kept it to a small group of employees and the board. Ultimately, they lowered their
valuation and we decided to pass.”
2005
Conversation with Grant Thornton “about tax impact a year and a half before we sold the
company—we made the decision to take a loan from the company to exercise whatever
options we had. We also got great tax advice on how to set up GRATs (grantor retained
annuity trusts) for your kids and all that stuff.”
2006
Gillin convinces NewSpring Capital that “regulatory issues swirling around this new
electronics payment industry were real and the cash required to deal with them was going
to be significant.
It was agreed that if the valuation was $150 million, we would sell. It
was well over that.”
The industry was getting “hot” and the company was performing well. Brought in
investment bankers and asked five core questions.
The key question: “How would you tell
the Ecount story?”
Board advises Gillin to get a number (on capital distribution) for all stakeholders in order
to align management team and board and gain sense of urgency.
Bank put a book out on the street in the summer of 2006. Interest was strong, and the
management team conducted a roadshow.
2007 Sold Ecount to Citibank for $200 million.
Source: Matt Gillin, CEO and Co-Founder of Relay Network, formerly the Founder and CEO of Ecount
. better insights into how private equity firms look
at their businesses, Clark says he “will introduce
them to two or three firms who are willing to come
in to learn about the business, and tell them how
they think about partnering with management
teams, how they look at investments, and just
really helping the owner and the management
team understand what it means to work with
a private equity firm.” It often results in a great
learning experience for owners, he continues, as
the private equity firms will say, “Here’s how we
see your business, and here’s where we see the
opportunities going forward.”
Lead Board Member
What is the role of a lead board member,
specifically one who is a non-controlling investor?
According to DiPiano, as an investor, he is
focused on “harvesting an investment return.” To
achieve this requires balancing the dynamics of
the different stakeholders, including management,
the owner and other investors. “The advice we
give is to get in a room and decide what it is
you want, both monetarily and from a timing
perspective,” he suggests. This makes sure that
“you are purposeful about whether you really
want to sell,” he emphasizes. If you are ready to
sell, DiPiano continues, “You need to determine if
the books and records are up to date, and if the
data room that you are planning to put together
will be robust and complete.”
As an experienced quarterback, Gillin says he
has “learned, through some good mentorship,
to keep open the communication lines so there
are no surprises.” In his view, “The kiss of death
in any deal is a surprise.” He continues, “You
don’t want the board to be surprised, you don’t
want the management team to be surprised,
and you certainly don’t want the buyer to be
surprised.” Managing communication during an
exit requires “a full-time, 24/7 effort” and “you
need someone who has a lot of skin in the game
and is committed.”
Legal Counsel
Lawyers can play various roles during the exit
process and serve as a key party to drive the
transaction to a close.
Depending on the situation
and existing relationships, legal counsel can be
the quarterback or the owner’s trusted advisor.
They will be responsible for all legal matters,
such as drafting a stock purchase agreement.
Engaging a lawyer prior to initiating the process
generally provides more opportunity to anticipate
and address potentially problematic issues.
Wealth Planning
Finally, wealth planners are another set of key
players, and they can be particularly important
for owners to meet with earlier rather than later
in the process. Stine stresses that “Thinking about
your tax structure on the front end, in terms of
how the ownership is structured, whether trusts
are in place and picking the right form of entity,
will reap huge rewards on the back end.” In his
view, the big gains from proper tax planning,
such as being able to “move an entire company
down a generation,” require getting involved
years—not weeks—before the exit.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
13
. From left: Duane Morris’ Darrick Mix, NewSpring Capital’s
Mike DiPiano, Relay Network’s Matt Gillin and Raymond
James’ David Clark.
indusTry aTTraCTiveness:
where To find The deals
the Middle Market Is Next up
A
As 2014 came to a close, the already good exit environment got better when the
Dow Jones industrial average in late December posted a record high, just over 18,000
(See Chart 6). Strong economic growth in the U.S., readily available and inexpensive
debt, soaring stock markets and plentiful IPOs are anticipated to encourage more
owners to exit their businesses.
14
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. Chart 6: U.S. Market Performance
120%
115%
110%
105%
100%
95%
90%
85%
NASDAQ Composite Index (^COMP) - Index Value
Russell 2000 Index (^RUT) - Index Value
Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) - Index Value
S&P 500 Index (^SPX) - Index Value
Source: Capital IQ
81%
60%
Global
The U.S. middle market is anticipated to follow
the bulge bracket end of the market and become
more active in 2015. According to EY’s survey,
more than 70 percent of U.S.
executives expect
deals in the $50 million to $250 million range
Chart 7: U.S. Executives More Bullish on
Improving M&A Market
U.S.
Growing optimism in the stability of the U.S.
economic environment and recovery from
the financial crisis are fueling U.S. executives’
confidence in the M&A market, according to
EY’s October 2014 edition of its Capital Confidence
Barometer.
It found that more than 80 percent of
the U.S. respondents expected the global market
for mergers and acquisitions to improve in the
next 12 months. Reflecting geopolitical instability
outside the United States, only 60 percent of global
respondents were as optimistic (See Chart 7).
Respondents expect the M&A
market to improve
Source: EY, “Big Deals Persist Generating Momentum in the
Middle Market for 2015,” December 8, 2014
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
15
.
Chart 8: Middle-Market Deals Expected to Pick Up
80%
71%
October 2013
60%
April 2014
56%
40%
October 2014
43%
40% 39%
26%
20%
18%
4%
3%
0%
Less than $250m
$251m to $1b
Greater than $1b
Source: EY, “Big Deals Persist Generating Momentum in the
Middle Market for 2015,” December 8, 2014
to become the “sweet spot” over the next 12
months (See Chart 8).5 In previous M&A cycles,
megadeals and upper-middle-market deals have
generally preceded the upcycle in lower-middlemarket deals.
Shareholder activists are also playing a role as
deal catalysts by pressuring management of larger
(generally public) companies to focus on their
core business, demanding that non-core units are
spun-off. Thus, large transactions are anticipated
to create M&A activity further down the deal
chain as smaller-sized strategics and financial
players, such as private equity, take advantage
of available corporate assets to build out their
platform companies.
As indicated in Chart 9, since 2006, the great
majority of value of buyout deal exits—generally
80 percent or more of buyout exits—have
involved the small- and mid-cap (under $250
million size) deals.
Where Is the Deal Activity?
Although a strong and growing economy is
creating opportunities for exits across sectors,
certain industries are attracting more attention
by buyers and investors. According to Clark at
Raymond James, he is seeing a growing amount
Chart 9: Buyout Exits in North America by Value Band
100%
80%
60%
Large-Cap (More
than $1bn)
40%
Mid-Cap ($250 -
999mn)
Small-Cap (Less
than $250mn)
Source: Preqin, 2014
16
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
0%
2014
YTD
20%
. The Hot Sectors
> Technology – A hot M&A sector, last year, the number of deals reached 2,400, up more
than 13 percent over 2013 with deal value reaching $171.6 billion, a 26.7-percent increase.
> Life Sciences – Although the number of deals reached only 603, down 18.7 percent from the
prior year, deal value hit over $304 billion, up 49.5 percent compared to 2013.
> Healthcare – Deal volumes were up slightly to 406, a 4.1-percent increase, but transaction
values rose to $28.1 billion, up 25.1 percent from the prior year.
> Consumer Products – 2014 transactions hit 963, up just 1.9 percent, while the rise in deal
value jumped to $185.1 billion, or over 61 percent.
> Financial Services – Deal volumes leveled off at 1,008, down 3.2 percent in 2014, with deal
value also down 12.6 percent to $88.4 billion in 2014.
Source: EY, “Big Deals Persist Generating Momentum in the Middle Market for 2015,” Press Release,
December 8, 2014
of “interest in consumer-related sectors, whether
it’s restaurants and other types of consumer
businesses.” He says, “Institutional investors seem
to believe that the consumer is going to come
back and spend money.”
Ecommerce businesses are also attractive,
notes Clark, helped again by the “consumer
angle.” He is seeing considerable activity in the
technology sector, where people are betting on
the future growth of these businesses. Finally,
the master-limited partnership (MLP) structure,
he points out, has been an attractive way for
energy companies, especially midstream pipeline
businesses, to exit. The collapse in oil prices has
harmed MLPs recently, but some analysts note
their performance is not directly correlated to
oil-price trends as much as the E&P side of the
business.6
According to EY, the U.S. sectors to watch for deal
activity in 2015 include technology, life sciences,
healthcare, consumer products and financial
services.
In EY’s view, “Companies are either
stripping down to their cores, or consolidating
and pursuing acquisitions in order to fill gaps in
innovation.”7 EY sees momentum built up in the
five sectors over the last year being carried over
to 2015. (See Box: The Hot Sectors).
Over the past nine years, between 40 percent
and 50 percent of private equity capital has been
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
17
. Chart 10: Private Equity Capital Invested by Industry
100%
90%
B2B
80%
70%
B2C
60%
Energy
50%
Financial
Services
Healthcare
40%
30%
20%
IT
10%
Materials &
Resources
0%
Source: PitchBook 4Q 2014 U.S. PE Breakdown, p. 12
directed at Business-to-Business (B2B) and the
consumer (or B2C) sectors (See Chart 10). B2B
showed the most impressive growth for the first
three quarters of 2014.
Growing competition is
encouraging private equity groups to become
more specialized, shifting from a generalist model
to a sector-focused approach. With over $260
billion of dry powder and limited partners anxious
to co-invest, funds in North America are under
growing pressure to put money to work.
The JOBS Act – Any Impact?
In April 2012, the Jumpstart Our Business Startups
Act (JOBS Act) was passed to streamline the
IPO process for “emerging growth companies”
(EGCs), companies with less than $1 billion in
annual revenues. The JOBS Act created an “IPO
on-ramp” specifically designed to increase IPO
activity by “de-burdening” and “de-risking the
process.” For example, the Act exempts such firms
from providing some executive compensation
data and allows them to disclose two years of
audited financial statements instead of three, as
well as permits firms to confidentially “test the
waters” for an IPO.
18
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
It is apparent that several key factors impact the
IPO market.
According to BDO’s annual survey
of capital markets executives, the JOBS Act does
not rank as a significant driver of U.S. IPO activity
last year (See Chart 11).
What’s the verdict of our panelists? Clark is of
the opinion that the JOBS Act “is helping to
make the IPO process a more attractive option
for more companies.” In DiPiano at NewSpring
Capital’s view, “It helps the dual process” (either
an IPO or sale). Clark is in agreement, and notes,
“It helps keep the company off the radar a little
bit longer, before they have to publicly disclose
it.” Thus, he adds, “You can do the work you
need to; you can take your time putting things
in place, and then go when it’s right for you, as
opposed to being out there in the public market
and under public scrutiny early on.”
Empirical evidence indicates that the JOBS Act
has had a positive impact in revitalizing the IPO
market.
In a forthcoming Journal of Financial
Economics article, Michael Dambra, Laura Casares
Chart 11: What One Factor Do You Feel Has Had the
Greatest Impact on the Dramatic Increase in U.S. IPO
Activity in 2014?
Increased confidence in U.S. economy
33%
Continued low interest rates increase
demand for higher yielding assets
33%
Positive IPO performance encourages
more businesses to make offerings
Increased investor cash flow into stockfocused mutual funds
JOBS Act has encouraged more emerging
businesses to pursue offerings
21%
9%
5%
Source: 2015 BDO IPO Outlook, 2015, p.
2
. Chart 12: LP Expectations for the Closing of Today’s Exit Window
% of respondents
40%
39%
35%
30%
25%
26%
20%
15%
5%
0%
16%
15%
10%
4%
Within 6
months
Within 12
months
Within 24
months
Within 36
months
Source: Coller Capital, Global Private Equity Barometer, Winter 2014-15, p. 10
Field and Matthew Gustafson provide evidence
that, after controlling for market conditions, the
Act has increased IPO volume by over 20 IPOs
per year, a 25-percent increase over pre-JOBS
levels.8 IPO activity was found to increase most
for firms with high proprietary disclosure costs,
such as biotechnology and pharmaceutical firms,
suggesting that they saw greater upside in taking
advantage of the Act’s de-risking provisions—
allowing firms to file the IPO confidentially while
“testing the waters.”
Within a
longer
timeframe
Finally, how long will the exit window remain
open? Taking an international perspective of
the exit environment—from the views of global
private equity investors—the recent Coller Capital
Barometer found that most LPs expected the exit
environment to deteriorate within two years (See
Chart 12). The same survey found that “almost
40% of LPs expected the next major downturn
to happen within the next three years.”9 Is this
harbinger another reason to start preparing for
an exit now?
T he Duane Morris V i e w
JOBS Act Driving IPOs?
Although it is early to judge the full merit of each provision of the JOBS Act, Duane Morris
believes that the IPO “on-ramp” provisions of the Act have facilitated the IPO process for many
companies. In particular, our biotech clients who have recently gone public have appreciated
the ability to confidentially file a draft of the registration statement.
We believe that these
on-ramp provisions contributed to the highest number of IPOs in 2014 since the year 2000.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
19
. TiMing, PreParaTion
and MoMenTuM
N
Market Conditions and experience
“No tree grows to the sky forever,” is a saying often used to indicate the natural
limitations to growth that all companies and markets face. It also highlights the
significance for owners to consider how to time the exit from their companies.
Generally, company founders may look to exit for a variety of reasons—to diversify
their wealth, or on the negative side, because of one of the three Ds: death, divorce
or a dispute.10
20
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. To what does Gillin at Relay Network attribute
“the failure led to a playbook for how to do it
the success of getting the exit process and
right the next time,” he emphasizes (See Box:
timing right for Ecount, the business he sold in
Gillin’s Exit Playbook).
2007? A failed earlier exit, in 2004, provided a
highly valuable learning experience. As he tells
Market conditions are a key factor in determining
the story, “We did absolutely everything wrong.”
the timing of an exit. When he was navigating
With a $40 million offer from Experian on the
Ecount’s exit the next time around, Gillin’s big
table, Gillin remembers bringing everyone in the
focus was on “things we cannot control.” As a
room to announce the deal before we “verified
new type of payments company offering a new
any of it.” He did not think it was necessary for
technology, this meant the regulatory environment
Ecount to run a full exit process since a suitor
would be a big deciding factor. Unlike PayPal,
“came to us.” The deal did not get done—but
he says, which was fighting these battles, “We
Lessons Learned:
Matt Gillin’s Exit Playbook
>
Be clear on the likely outcome (IPO, sale or other)
>
Prep early for the process
>
Get the board “on board”
>
Remember your fiduciary responsibility to all shareholders
>
Interview several bankers and hire the “right” one
>
Hire an experienced lawyer who’s been there, done that
>
Prepare targeted communications campaign to employees
>
Find a way to make all employees “feel good” about the outcome
Source: Relay Network, LLC (2015)
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
21
.
did not have the war chest to really contest the
decision.” Gillin had the choice of taking stock,
regulatory stuff that was coming down the pike,
which Stine says, “typically is going to be a tax-
and we knew that a financial institution could.”
free or tax-deferred deal until you sell the stock.”
Alternatively, he continues, Gillin “could have
Luck is also involved. At the time Gillin signed
taken cash, which is all taxable.” While offering
the deal to sell Ecount to Citibank in March 2007
tax benefits, the downside risk is that “now you
and chose to take cash instead of stock, the
have got somebody else’s paper and you do not
market was frothy. “In hindsight, we looked like
control the company anymore,” declares Stine.
geniuses,” recalls Gillin as the market was about
to collapse. The decision was made easier, as
Identifying the Exit Tipping Point
prior to the sale, he had discussions with five
As an investor and board member of Ecount
bankers that provided comfort and clarity over
at the time, DiPiano at NewSpring Capital was
“how the exit would shape up.”
not convinced it was time to sell.
As he recalls,
“We were executing superbly, Matt’s team and
Stine at Grant Thornton underlines an important
leadership were great, we had turned the corner
lesson: “Do not let the tax answer force you
on profitability, and cash was flowing significantly.”
into a decision that is not the right economic
Attendees listen to our panel discussion, their rapt attention evident.
22
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. With “very high recurring revenue,” the business
of investments, NewSpring Capital had the safety
was attractive to hold, notes DiPiano, especially
of a diversified portfolio whereas Gillin, focused
because “we did not know that the world was
on one business, did not. “Well, I can solve for
going to enter into a recession.”
the bank account by doing a recap if we really
think there’s a lot of growth in the business,” is
Having worked with many entrepreneurs, DiPiano
how DiPiano approached the problem.
says he was cognizant that as the chief owner of
at least on paper, but “it was not necessarily in his
Market and Regulatory Conditions
Matter
pocket.” As an investor and board member, a lot
Ultimately, recalls DiPiano, Gillin convinced him
of DiPiano’s discussions “were trying to verify that
that “the regulatory issues were real, and that,
the pressures of the regulatory environment were
while we may be able to deal with them, the
influencing Matt and not potentially what was
cash required to do that was going to potentially
going to be in his bank account.” With a number
create difficulties.” From there, we “agreed that
his company, Gillin had created significant value,
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
23
. if the valuation was $158 million we would sell—
In answering the question, “Is this the right time?”
and it was way over that,” he says. DiPiano gives
he also recommends putting yourself in the
Gillin substantial credit for “doing the right thing
buyer’s shoes. “You want to leave some upside
as a leader to work out the exit process with
and some growth opportunities for the next
his board members and shareholders and, in his
owner, especially if it is a private equity firm,”
case, some of his family members, who were
Clark stresses. From the perspective of the next
also shareholders.”
owner, “They want to be able to say, ‘I’m going
to buy the business and there is going to be
Clark at Raymond James cautions against trying
growth for me.’” Conversely, “If all the growth is
to sell at a market peak.
He notes, “The problem
out of the business, it is not really that exciting,
is, you do not know the peak until you have
and you are not going to get the valuation for it.”
actually hit it, and at that point, you are now
go right now.’” In his view, people also “make the
Moving Forward with Purpose:
Managing Communications,
Positioning the Company and
Achieving Momentum
mistake in waiting too long,” saying, “Well, there
The playbook Gillin created from the first failed
is a little bit more opportunity here, the market is
exit proved highly valuable in preparing him for his
still strong, I’m going to wait.”
next attempt. “We started interviewing bankers a
going down the other side.” And given that the
exit processes take a while, Clark believes, “You
cannot just say, ‘I see the peak and I am going to
Relay Network’s Matt Gillin (center) discusses his sale of Ecount, with NewSpring
Capital’s Mike DiPiano (left) and Raymond James’ David Clark (right) listening closely.
24
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. year before we wanted to sell,” he says, and “we
to the banks was, “We want to get a sense as to
kept the process to a small group of employees,
what the market would be willing to bear.”
and the board.” Gillin underscores that how you
Clear
communicate to the marketplace is vital, because
management team is also necessary to move
“you need to manage the marketplace’s opinion
the deal forward. Speaking about the board’s
of a company that is running through an exit
perspective, Gillin says that “the best advice I got
process.” At this early stage, he says, the message
was to get a number” from the key constituencies.
communication
between
board
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
and
25
. 26
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. He explains, “The moment you come in with what
all prospective bidders “heard the same pitch.”
the numbers are, the moment the number leaves
In addition to taking questions from potential
your mouth, it’s human nature that you want
bidders, the firm addressed its own questions
more.” By getting “a number” from everybody,
with answers that “really positioned the company
the management team and the board were
as effectively as possible,” he mentions. As a
aligned. Another key step Gillin learned through
result of this novel approach, “we didn’t have to
the failed transaction “was to go through the cap
do a bunch of sit-downs” and “we cut down the
table, understand what the distribution looks like
number of bidders to a manageable number—
and make sure that there were no surprises.”
from 34 to 9.”
As the process advances, “You have to start
In getting ready for a transaction, “the most
letting in more people at the company,” and Gillin
important thing” is that the process “doesn’t shut
emphasizes you have to manage this carefully,
down your business,” Gillin notes. Making sure
given that a message that the founder is cashing
your business is in order before initiating an exit
out may negatively impact employees who are
is essential, says DiPiano.
Delays in closing a
responsible for achieving the firm’s growth. “So
transaction can become permanent, he mentions,
the first and most important thing you can do
and “not crossing the goal line can be disastrous.”
is to make sure that it is a win for everybody,”
In his experience, the exit decision sets in motion
he says. We achieved this, he recounts, by
a number of decisions, “everybody has counted
making certain all the employees “knew what the
the money, everybody is trying to figure out their
transaction meant to them.” Gillin adds, “All of a
new roles [and] some people are already starting
sudden, everyone is on the same page moving
to interview for new jobs.” Thus, “You really
two steps at a time to ensure, for example, the
want to evaluate your own business, your legal
data room is set up properly.”
records, everything you can think of to make sure
your house is in order,” DiPiano emphasizes.
Running an Efficient Auction
Communication is especially vital in positioning
Generating a sense of urgency is another key
a company in an auction, which Gillin decided
step, according to Gillin, which he learned the
was the best way to maximize the value of the
hard way.
He relates that back in 2000, “We had
firm. The downside of an auction, he says, was
a transaction with Softbank to put $50 million
that it could involve many players, which could
into our company.” In pushing a deal discussion
be distracting and a lot of work. The firm took
from Friday to Monday, which became Tuesday,
an innovative step by creating an interactive
“the day the market crashed—so we never got
webinar to position the company and ensure
that money.” Therefore, in preparing for the deal
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
27
.
The crowd is engaged and focused on the stimulating discussion.
with Citi, “everyone was aligned with the urgency
Clark points out that “When they buy a business,
of getting it done quickly,” he notes. “As a matter
most private equity firms are already starting to
of fact, we moved our closing up a month.”
think about the exit.” This is part of the process
of visualizing a firm’s growth path and how it
Starting Gun: When Should the
Clock Start?
is going to get there, and asking: “Where do
How long should owners expect the exit process
helps to “make sure you’ve got good numbers,
to last? “To run a sale process from the time you
you’ve got your accountants looking at the
engage a banker to when you close is going to be
numbers and being prepared, and you’ve got
around six months,” says Clark. This is the time
the lawyers looking at structure and everything,”
it takes for the banker to do their work—“doing
he says. Initiating discussions with bankers and
their diligence, preparing the information that
private equity firms will provide better answers
needs to be prepared and getting the data room
to questions like: “Where can I take the business
ready.” But for owners to really ensure everything
and what’s going to make my business attractive
is prepared, they need to “start thinking about it
to a strategic, or to a private equity firm?”
a year before [they] start a process.”
28
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
I ultimately want to see the business?” This
.
“If you’re central to your company, and don’t
Gillin, who is onto his third business, says that
want to be with the buying company, you might
“If there’s a high probability that you’re going to
want to think about it two years in advance,”
sell the company, then there are things that you
DiPiano suggests. “If you want to avoid being
can do every day.” In his view, these are “simple
swept into the purchase, then you have to start
things like how you store your data and how you
thinking even earlier about your succession to
tell the story about how you operate.” Changes
put a professional leader in the company,” he
that “help in managing the business better, the
notes. Stine at Grant Thornton agrees, saying
type of people you hire, the systems you put in
that “When we sold Smart, we started two-and-
place,” he continues, are all things “you can do
a-half years in front.” In the end, he continues,
on day one.”
“it worked out very well,” as it provided time
“to restructure the firm, create the buzz and
accomplish a whole ton of stuff.”
T he Duane Morris V i e w
Thinking About Your Exit? Remember the Boy Scout Motto.
Yes, the Boy Scout Motto—“Always be prepared”—together with its corollary, “If you’re
not prepared, start getting that way, now,” should be twin beacons for a business
owner contemplating the sale of a business. In this regard, owners should pay special
heed to the methods of private equity groups, masters of focus and preparedness, that
start thinking on day one about what their exit will look like—possibly years down the
road.
Depending on the company, “preparedness” could mean a top-to-bottom scrub
down—cleaning up the books; ensuring protection of intellectual property, including trade
secrets; and possibly even hiring a CFO if the company does not have one. If an IPO is
a viable option—as opposed to selling to strategic player or a private equity group—the
level of scrutiny will take on a whole new level of intensity; for example, composition of
the board of directors. Owners who have been through the process before maintain a
state of preparedness for sale as a basic operating principle.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
29
.
From left: Duane Morris’ Darrick Mix addresses the audience and our panelists.
valuaTion, besT buyer and
CerTainTy around Closure
I
In Clark’s view, coming up with a valuation for a company is a key step, but one that
must be taken into context with other factors, such as “determining the right process
to go down, and who is the right partner or buyer you want to be dealing with.” For
example, if an owner of a family owned business wants to stay involved and continue
to own a meaningful stake, “the highest valuation may not be the most important
objective.” Instead, he continues, “finding the right partner, investor or private equity
firm to help grow the business” takes precedence.
30
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. More important, Clark stresses, is the story—
have helped to fuel a surge in offerings over the
“How are you going to position the business
past two years and outperformance for IPOs (See
and the story to attract the most interest, create
Chart 13). In addition, the JOBS Act, by allowing
the most competitive process and, ultimately,
EGCs to “test the waters” with institutional
get the highest valuation?” The “valuation is very
investors to gauge interest in an IPO, opens up
subjective, and at the end of the day, the market
a vital channel for feedback on what could be a
is going to speak.” Thus, telling a credible story
potential valuation for a company.11
around a firm’s future growth prospects becomes
As part of his job, Clark says, “We’ll tell you
paramount.
what we think the valuation is, and it’s based
Most of the panelists agreed that in certain
upon what we’re seeing in the marketplace.”
industries an IPO would likely attract the highest
Right now, “Valuations are pretty high,” he notes,
valuation. This is particularly true given today’s
“with lenders being as aggressive as they are and
conditions, including steady economic growth
leverage levels being as high, a lot of excess
and a strong stock market performance, which
capital available and a lot of private equity firms
Chart 13: U.S. IPO Pricing and Performance
+19.3%
first-day
average return
Equity indices
DJIA
+27.8%
increase in
offer price vs.
December 3, 2014
US$ 390m median post-IPO
+8.1%
S&P 500
+12.2%
VIX®
-9.1%
market cap
Source: EY, “U.S.
IPO Highlights 2014” (pricing and performance based on 277 IPOs on NYSE and NASDAQ that were priced
and started trading by December 3, 2014; year-to-date returns of equity indices are also as of December 3, 2014).
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
31
. Chart 14: Average Debt Multiples of Middle-Market LBO Loans
6.0x
5.6
4.8
4.7
4.1
4.0x
4.2
4.0
3.9
4.7
4.7
5.3
4.5
4.2
4.3
4.5
4.8
5.0
3.8
3.4
3.3
2.0x
FLD/EBITDA
SLD/EBITDA
13
12
14
4Q
14
20
20
11
20
10
09
Other Sr Debt/EBITDA
20
20
20
07
08
20
20
05
06
20
20
03
04
20
20
01
02
20
20
99
98
00
20
19
19
19
97
0.0x
Sub Debt/EBITDA
Source: Capital IQ
with capital waiting to be invested” (See Chart
focusing on, ‘How can I take the business from
14). “If I look at where we are today as compared
where it is today and continue to generate
to where we would have been a couple of years
significant growth going forward?’” (particularly
ago, the leverage and valuations for companies
for an SaaS-based recurring revenue model). He
of all sizes are higher,” Clark mentions.
believes “smaller companies tend to be less on
the strategics’ radar, so that’s where the private
“Leverage is really less of a factor” influencing
equity and venture firms come in to help support
valuations, Clark observes. “It’s much more
and grow the business.” Once they reach a
Raymond James’ David Clark (center).
32
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
.
Conversations continued flowing, even after our panel discussion wrapped up.
certain size, “the strategics jump in,” and with a
bigger customer base and opportunities to crosssell, they can justify paying a big multiple for the
business.
A key takeaway for DiPiano is that it is “a huge
mistake to focus on one valuation that’s the
highest in your peer group when you’re selling.”
Clark agrees, noting that “It’s not in anybody’s
interest to give an inflated view on value and
set expectations too high.” His goal is “to set
expectations at a reasonable level and then,
ultimately, exceed that during the process.”
DiPiano stresses, that in addition to being realistic,
“also look at your cap table to ensure everybody
moves forward with a purpose.”
Exclusivity and Quality of Earnings
Report
To gain certainty to close and keep the bidding
process honest, DiPiano suggests sellers have
two bidders go through exclusivity. NewSpring
Capital has been involved in this approach twice,
and in both cases, “the seller offered to pay the
losing bidder’s expenses.” He notes that “When
one bidder has exclusivity, the seller loses some
leverage,” and there is a fear of losing momentum.
Both deals had a high degree of certainty to
close and the close happened, relates DiPiano.
Another practice to lessen uncertainty around
closure is to “have the seller pay to do a quality-of-
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
33
. Do’s and Don’ts –
Lessons from Exit Frontlines
>
Start by building an enduring business, as businesses are bought, not sold.
> The owner must be committed.
> Decide what you want monetarily and from a timing perspective, so that
you’re purposeful.
> Focus on getting ready for transaction—make sure process doesn’t shut down
your business.
>
Choose your team—lawyer, banker, accountant—wisely and early.
>
Make sure your house is in order—your business, your legal records, etc.—as delays in
the sales process can become permanent and disastrous.
>
Develop a relationship with one or more banks early to gain insight into the market,
positioning of the firm and its valuation.
>
Start tax planning—how the ownership is structured, trusts in place, etc.—early to
achieve greatest savings.
>
Manage the marketplace’s opinion of the company.
>
Make sure that the sale is a win for everybody and that everyone knows what it means
to them.
>
No surprises—surprises are deal killers from perspectives of board, management team
and buyer.
>
Prepare to manage communication full-time—24/7 effort.
> The story around the business is vital—it will go a long way to attracting interest and
determining valuation for the business.
>
Be realistic; don’t make a selling decision based on the highest valuation in your
peer group.
>
Don’t try to play the market to sell at the peak—you are bound to miss it.
>
Don’t rely on the IPO as your exit, but reach out to potential buyers to gauge interest
and consider dual track.
>
Pick the buyer carefully—sometimes, it is not the buyer with the highest price, but the
buyer with the highest certainty of close, combined with a good value along with it.
> Learn from your failures—create a playbook for the next exit.
Source: Panelists
34
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. earnings report prior to the process,” which Stine
very fluid process and it is hard to predict who is
says Grant Thornton is doing more and more.
going to be the ultimate winner.” (See Box: “Do’s
Some of the “biggest discussions between buyers
and Don’ts.”)
and sellers,” he notes, are around adjustments
to earnings—e.g., “what is the true EBITDA or
Clark reiterates that the best outcome will come
revenue that we’re valuing the business off of”—
from “getting everything done upfront and running
which can be the “biggest trade on valuation.”
as efficient a process as you can.” The highest
Doing quality of earnings ahead of time, before
price is not always the best guide to selecting a
prospective buyers enter into a Letter of Intent
buyer, says DiPiano: “Sometimes the buyer with
(LOI), should speed up the process and create
the highest certainty of close, combined with a
more certainty around close.
good value,” is better than the buyer offering the
highest price.
In summing up, Clark says, “The job of investment
bankers is to package a story, run a process
and ultimately get as much competitiveness
in that process as they can and get the best
outcome they can.” He emphasizes that “It is a
T he Duane Morris V i e w
How to See Around Corners
The key to a successful process from the seller’s perspective is to engage advisers who
can anticipate the potential obstacles in a transaction so that the seller is never surprised.
One strategy to accomplish this is to ask the seller to look at his or her company as if it
were a target of an unfriendly active investor in order to identify any particular issues that
may be impacting the firm’s potential value so that they can be addressed in advance.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
35
. 36
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. ConClusion
M
Market conditions for U.S. middle-market owners considering exiting
their businesses may never have been better. A stable U.S. economy,
rising equity markets, easy access to favorable financing and a growing
number of financial and strategic
“I BelIeVe tHAt tHe
buyers, taken together, make
eNtRePReNeuR OwNeRfor a robust, seller-friendly exit
MANAGeR OF A PRIVAte
environment.
How long this
window of opportunity will last is
eNteRPRISe IS ONe OF
anyone’s guess.
tHe MOSt IMPORtANt
PRO-eCONOMIC AND PROAs detailed in this report, the
SOCIAl FORCeS ON tHe
exit process is a well-worn path
PlANet. tHAt IS BeCAuSe
that has become increasingly
eVeRYBODY SHAReS IN
professionalized and sophisticated,
tHe MASSIVe CAPItAl
with a busy intersection of buyers
GAINS CReAteD tHROuGH
and sellers. Owners interested in
tHe ReCAPItAlIZAtION
achieving a “good exit” should
OR SAle OF tHeSe
consider taking advantage of this
COMPANIeS.”
evolving set of financial, legal and
-Peter Worrell, Enterprise
investor resources.
Careful and
Value, 2014, p. 9.
early preparation with the right
team is essential to a successful
wealth creation event—one whose benefits flow beyond the owner to
investors, employees and broader stakeholders.
In our view, a principal signpost of a “good exit” is how well the original
owner and investors position the business to achieve future growth and
how well its growth opportunities are clearly and convincingly articulated
to the next owner. Exiting at a valuation that reflects future wealth
creation opportunities and a strong business legacy provides perhaps the
best and broadest measure of accomplishment and success.
Duane Morris’ Heading for the Exit: Owner, Investor and Banker
Perspectives was prepared with the assistance of the firm’s outside
advisor David Haarmeyer.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
37
.
SPEAKER profiles
David Clark
Managing Director, Head of Financial Sponsors Group, Raymond James & Associates
David Clark joined Raymond James & Associates in 2009. Prior to joining Raymond
James, he was a managing director at Lane, Berry & Co. International. Previously,
David was a Director at UBS Warburg in the Global Industrial Group.
At UBS Warburg,
He completed numerous debt, equity, M&A advisory and restructuring transactions.
Prior to UBS Warburg, David worked for Dillon, Read & Co. and at Bank of Boston
Corporation. David received his M.B.A.
from the Darden School of Business in 1997 and his B.A. in
Economics from Harvard College in 1989.
mike DiPiano
Managing General Partner, NewSpring Capital
Mike DiPiano serves as Managing General Partner, Partner and Managing Director
at NewSpring Capital. Mike co-founded NewSpring Capital and is a part of the
NewSpring Growth investment team.
Prior to joining NewSpring, Mike was a serial
entrepreneur and investor; he led or co-led the investment into six companies in the
business services, healthcare and information technology industries. He served as
the Chief Executive Officer at Maxwell Systems from 1998 to 2002. He co-founded venture-backed
startups; was affiliated with Safeguard Scientifics and its related funds; and served as Division Chief
Executive Officer for six years at Chemical Leaman Corporation.
He started his career in 1980 with
Baxter Healthcare Corporation. Mike holds an M.B.A. from the Stern School of Business at New York
University and a B.S.
from Pennsylvania State University.
Matt Gillin
CEO and Co-Founder, Relay Network
Matt Gillin is CEO and Co-Founder of Relay Network, a new technology company
that connects trusted brands to their customers on a private, mobile communications
network. At Relay, Matt is responsible for guiding the company’s strategy and
overseeing the day-to-day operations. He has been an active entrepreneur and
pioneer for nearly 20 years, and he has been widely recognized for turning innovative
ideas into successful businesses.
Most recently, Matt served as the CEO of Ecount, a company he cofounded in his parent’s basement. Over a 10-year period, Matt built Ecount into a recognized leader
in the prepaid card industry. In 2007, he sold the company to Citi and was successful in delivering
considerable value to his investors and shareholders.
Following the sale to Citi, Matt remained as CEO
of the renamed business and helped make Citi Prepaid Services the world’s first global prepaid solution
provider. Prior to starting Ecount, Matt was also the co-founder of C/Base, a consultancy business that
specialized in partnership marketing services for Internet-based companies. A recognized inventor and
holder of three patents, Matt graduated with a B.A.
from Denison University.
38
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
. Darrick Mix
Partner, Duane Morris LLP
Darrick Mix practices corporate law with concentrations in the areas of securities law,
mergers and acquisitions and corporate governance. He has experience representing
public and private companies in connection with their capital-raising activities,
including public offerings and private placements of equity and debt securities.
Darrick also advises companies with respect to SEC regulations, compliance issues
and other corporate and securities law matters, such as public reporting, Sarbanes-Oxley compliance
and communications with analysts and investors. He has substantial experience representing public
and private companies in selling and acquiring businesses, including private equity funds in control and
minority investments. His clients span a variety of industries, including retail, financial services and REITs.
Darrick is a 1997 graduate, with honors, of the Ohio State University, Michael E.
Moritz College of Law,
and a graduate of Georgetown University’s School of Foreign Service.
John Stine
Assistant Office Managing Partner and Tax Partner, Grant Thornton LLP
John Stine serves as the Assistant Office Managing Partner for the Philadelphia office,
and as a senior tax partner in Grant Thornton’s Philadelphia tax practice. John has more
than 38 years of experience with a wide variety of clients in varied industries, including
manufacturing and distribution, financial services, technology, service companies and
real estate. A teaming approach serves as the cornerstone of his business problem
solving and transactions, and he uses his network of relationships with experts both inside and outside
the firm to help his clients maximize value and reduce risks.
He has been involved in numerous business
transactions both for buyers and sellers, as well as intra- and inter-family transactions. He is an alumnus
of the Wharton School’s Accounting faculty, having served as a Lecturer for 20 years.
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
39
. About Duane Morris
Private Equity Group
With experienced private equity lawyers across our global platform, coupled with the
deep capabilities of more than 700 lawyers across all practice areas, Duane Morris
offers the resources to optimize transactional value for sellers and buyers; advise on
formation of funds and other investment structures; introduce its extensive network
of relationships; support portfolio company operations; and structure wealth planning
strategies for sellers.
Capital Markets Group
With attorneys in all major financial centers across the U.S. and throughout the UK,
Europe and Asia, Duane Morris routinely advises clients on securities issues specific
to public companies and assists with preparing and filing registration and proxy
statements, reports and other SEC filings, as well as private placement memoranda
and related private offering materials. A number of our lawyers have served in SEC
staff positions and hold leadership positions in professional and securities industry
organizations, enhancing our ability to provide keen insights into novel policy and
regulatory issues. We leverage our industry knowledge and contacts with underwriters,
placement agents, investment banks and private investment funds to identify possible
partners who can help our clients grow their businesses.
Duane Morris is proud to be an Official Sponsor of Growth® of the Association for
Corporate Growth (ACG).
40
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
.
Lo
Chicago
Lake Tahoe
San Francisco
Silicon Valley
Las Vegas
Los Angeles
San Diego
Pittsburgh
Atlanta
Houston
Boston
New York
Newark
Cherry Hill
Philadelphia
Wilmington
Baltimore
Washington, D.C.
Boca Raton
Miami
Mexico
City
Duane Morris Office
Representative / Liaison Office
London, UK
Chicago
Pittsburgh
Atlanta
Houston
Boston
New York
Newark
Cherry Hill
Philadelphia
Wilmington
Baltimore
Washington, D.C.
Shanghai, China
Oman
Singapore
exico
City
United States
Lake Tahoe
Las Vegas
Los Angeles
Miami
New York
Newark
Philadelphia
Ho Chi
Minh City
Sri Lanka
Boca Raton
Miami
Atlanta
Baltimore
Boca Raton
Boston
Cherry Hill
Chicago
Houston
Hanoi, Vietnam
Myanmar
Pittsburgh
San Diego
San Francisco
Silicon Valley
Washington, D.C.
Wilmington
International
Hanoi
Ho Chi Minh City
London
Mexico City (alliance)
Myanmar
Oman
Shanghai
Singapore
Sri Lanka (alliance)
DUANE MORRIS — CONNECTIONS
41
. Notes
1
Dana Mattioli and Dana Cimilluca, “Deal Boom Feeds on Surging Stocks,” The Wall Street Journal, November 17, 2014.
2
All IPO data was provided by EY.
3
Dawn Lim, “Investors Struggle to Get Into Some Private Equity Funds,” The Wall Street Journal, December 29, 2014.
Arleen Jacobius, “Assets Invested in Separate Accounts Starting to Add Up,” Pensions & Investments, December 22, 2014.
4
EY, “Big Deals Persist Generating Momentum in the Middle Market for 2015,” Press Release, December 8, 2014.
5
Michael Aneiro, “Do Natural-Gas MLPs Face More Downside Ahead?” Barron’s, December 30, 2014.
6
EY, “Big Deals Persist Generating Momentum in the Middle Market for 2015,” Press Release, December 8, 2014.
7
Michael Dambra, Laura Casares Field and Matthew Gustafson, “The JOBS Act and IPO Volume: Evidence That Disclosure Costs Affect the IPO Decision,”
8
forthcoming at Journal of Financial Economics; available at Social Science Research Network, August 26, 2014.
Coller Capital, Global Private Equity Barometer, Winter 2014-15, p. 10.
9
10
Luke Johnson, “How Entrepreneurs Can Secure a ‘Good Exit’ from Their Company,” Financial Times, December 30, 2014.
11
Edward Teach, “On the IPO On-Ramp,” CFO Magazine, September 15, 2014.
This publication is for general information and does not include full legal analysis of the matters presented. It should not be construed or relied upon as legal advice or
legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. The invitation to contact the attorneys in our firm is not a solicitation to provide professional services and should not
be construed as a statement as to any availability to perform legal services in any jurisdiction in which such attorney is not permitted to practice.
©2015 Duane Morris LLP.
. . INNOVATIONS IN GLOBAL
PRIVATE EQUITY
www.duanemorris.com
Duane Morris – Firm and Affiliate Offices | New York | London | Singapore | Philadelphia | Chicago | Washington, D.C. | San Francisco
Silicon Valley | San Diego | Boston | Shanghai | Houston | Los Angeles | Hanoi | Ho Chi Minh City | Atlanta | Baltimore | Wilmington | Miami
Boca Raton | Pittsburgh | Newark | Las Vegas | Cherry Hill | Lake Tahoe | Myanmar | Oman | Duane Morris LLP – A Delaware limited liability partnership
.