Invest Well
S e r i e s
STRENGTHENING THE FOUNDATION
OF YOUR INVESTMENTS
Leveraging a Manager of Managers Approach
— David Kahn, Managing Director
What’s inside our toolbox?
Implementation tools have proliferated to the point
that investors can find a fund, separate account, or
exchange traded fund (ETF) to access virtually any
investment opportunity, regardless of how obscure
it may be. This vast universe of investments
presents many possibilities, but many potential
complications as well.
At Convergent, we use an “open architecture”
model, meaning we have the freedom to access
essentially any investment vehicle across the world
for our clients. Below, we will delve into the details
of how we select what we believe to be the optimal
investment vehicles from the thousands available.
Portfolio Building Blocks
The initial phase of our process involves defining each vehicle across two dimensions:
Scope
Is the fund specific or broad
across asset classes?
Benchmark Correlation
How closely does the fund
mirror its benchmark?
We prefer asset class specific vehicles over multi-asset class, flexible strategies. The reason is straight
forward—we want to control the asset mix of each client portfolio because that is the ultimate driver of both
return and risk.
Our team of research professionals has the skills and tools to craft what we believe to be
the ideal asset allocation for each client. We want the investment tools we choose to have predictable
characteristics that are consistent with our current investment outlook.
STRENGTHENING THE FOUNDATION OF YOUR INVESTMENTS | PAGE 1
. We analyze each asset class and assess the following factors:
What is the likelihood
that active managers
can outperform passive,
index-oriented vehicles?
What is the likelihood that
Convergent can identify
outperformers before they
emerge?
If the answer to one or both of these questions is limited or negative, we utilize passively-oriented
investment tools. For example, a passively-oriented strategy is typically applied with the bulk of our
allocation to U.S. equities. Here, we believe a very mature and developed market for security analysis
makes the opportunity for outperformance by active managers highly challenging.
In less mature areas, our
research suggests that markets are less efficient and we seek to identify active managers capable of
generating outperformance beyond the relevant index over time.
Beware the Closet-Index Manager (and “hidden” fees)
The vast majority of portfolio strategies fall in the middle ground. In order to retain assets
(and protect one’s livelihood), many fund managers broadly diversify across both stocks and
sectors. This approach often results in performance that roughly tracks the fund’s primary
benchmark.
As long as performance is generally in line with the benchmark, the thinking
goes, the fund can retain and continue to attract new assets (the term “closet indexer” is sometimes applied
to this approach).
What is wrong with this approach? Nothing really, except for those nasty things called fees and taxes. If a
portfolio correlates highly with its benchmark, but charges higher fees and generates more drag from
trading costs and taxes, the likelihood of after-fee, after-tax (what we call “net, net”) outperformance
becomes very low.
The Convergent Portfolio Approach—The Barbell
INDEX
PASSIVE
CONCENTRATED
PORTFOLIOS
ACTIVE
We deploy a “barbell” approach designed to capture
the best of both active and passive strategies. When
we believe the likelihood of “net, net outperformance”
over a market index is low, we use passively-oriented
strategies.
With the opportunity to harvest tax losses
on an ongoing basis, we believe these passive
strategies have a high probability of outperforming on
a net, net basis over time. Additionally, we utilize our
firm’s size and scale to negotiate lower fees for our
clients, so in certain circumstances, the incremental
cost above ETFs or index mutual funds is nominal.
STRENGTHENING THE FOUNDATION OF YOUR INVESTMENTS | PAGE 2
. In markets where we believe net, net outperformance is achievable, we use active managers that tend to
be fairly highly concentrated. With these managers, the bulk of fund capital is focused on their best
investment ideas. We believe if we are going to invest our client’s money with active managers, we only
want firms that possess the power of conviction. After all, who wants a fund manager’s 178th best stock
idea in their portfolio? However, with concentrated portfolios, you often get tracking error.
Inevitably, these
managers will experience periods of underperformance versus their benchmarks. That said, we believe only
those managers that are willing to make concentrated selections at the expense of hugging their benchmark
will have the opportunity to outperform over time, net of fees and taxes.
Lifting the Barbell
We believe our carefully defined and allocated client portfolios combine the best of both
worlds. In more efficient markets (e.g., U.S.
stocks and municipal bonds), we deploy low
cost, tax efficient passive vehicles. In less efficient market segments (e.g. European equities, high yield
bonds), we often utilize active managers that can add value through skill and unique knowledge of factors
that drive securities prices.
In combination, we believe our barbell strategy provides our clients with the best opportunity to outperform
over time, net of fees and taxes.
To us, that is the bottom line and the power of a barbell approach.
Convergent’s Live Well Series is produced to advance dialogue on topics to help people “Invest
Well. Manage Well. Live Well.TM” It is our hope that these articles will illuminate, intrigue, and
inspire—and we invite you to join the conversation.
If you have questions, or wish to discuss any of our thought leadership articles, please contact your
investment advisor or email us at: LiveWell@ConvergentWealth.com
Disclosure: Past Performance Is No Guarantee Of Future Performance.
Any opinions expressed by Convergent employees are current only as of the time made and
are subject to change without notice. This article may include estimates, projections or other forward looking statements, however, due to numerous factors, actual
events may differ substantially from those presented. While we believe this information to be reliable, Convergent Wealth Advisors bears no responsibility for the
advice or information provided in this article whatsoever or for any errors or omissions.
Moreover, the information provided is not intended to be, and should not
be construed as, investment, legal or tax advice. Nothing contained herein should be construed as a recommendation or advice to purchase or sell any security,
investment, or portfolio allocation. This article is not meant as a general guide to investing, or as a source of any specific investment recommendations, and makes
no implied or express recommendations concerning the manner in which any client's accounts should or would be handled, as appropriate investment decisions
depend upon the client's specific investment objectives.
Non-deposit investment products are not FDIC insured, are not deposits or other obligations of City
National Bank, are not guaranteed by City National Bank and involve investment risks, including the possible loss of principal.
STRENGTHENING THE FOUNDATION OF YOUR INVESTMENTS | PAGE 3
.