THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forecasting
SPECIAL REPORT
HightowerReport.com
June 23, 2015
Are You Prepared for the June 30th USDA Reports?
Traders, especially end users and producers, face a significant
volatility event with the June 30th USDA Planted Acreage and Grain
Stocks reports. In the past these reports have helped set some of
the key price fundamentals for the marketing year in the corn and
soybean markets. For example, over the last six years November
Soybeans over have dropped an average of 18 ½ cents on the day of
the report. For December Corn, the market has dropped an average
CME WEBINARS
June 24 & June 30
See page 12 for details.
of 11 cents over the last twelve years.
In this paper, we will review
some strategies for end users and producers to consider going into
that critical report date. (See tables on pages 2 and 3.)
The corn and soybean markets both face huge ending stocks levels,
and their stocks/usage ratios levels are considered “comfortable.”
However, end users of vegetable oils face a very different setup, as
www.HightowerReport.com
Trade Recommendations
Pre-open and Midday Audio Updates
Fundamental & Technial Chart Library
Daily Fundametal & Technical Analysis
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 1
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
NOVEMBER SOYBEAN FUTURES REACTION
TO JUNE STOCKS/ACREAGE REPORT
Year
Price Changes
Day of Report
10 Days
Later
Aug 1st
Sep 1st
Oct 31st
1990
0.00
0.25
-37.25
-8.00
-40.25
1991
-11.00
-29.25
87.25
26.75
-2.25
1992
-4.00
-43.00
-68.50
-70.00
-69.50
Notes
Record Yield
1993
21.50
53.50
48.00
2.50
-38.75
1994
-6.25
-52.00
-68.75
-53.25
-86.50
1995
-4.00
60.00
10.50
29.25
80.25
1996
14.25
62.50
-8.50
49.25
-78.50
1997
-30.00
8.25
28.75
16.25
73.25
1998
10.75
-38.75
-64.75
-95.75
-58.25
1999
4.50
-33.50
2.50
34.75
9.75
2000
-15.00
-28.25
-20.50
36.00
-17.00
2001
23.00
44.75
27.75
20.25
-35.50
2002
15.25
26.50
34.50
42.75
58.50
2003
-5.75
-31.25
-36.25
22.00
241.75
2004
-30.75
-23.50
-103.00
-40.25
-141.50
Record Yield
2005
-22.75
65.25
38.25
-67.25
-101.50
Record Yield
2006
13.00
-11.25
-21.25
-68.25
7.75
2007
39.50
17.00
-27.25
25.75
128.25
2008
14.50
-58.00
-279.00
-275.50
-648.75
2009
-2.50
-76.50
49.50
-30.00
-3.00
2010
-9.50
85.50
107.50
106.50
323.50
Weather Impact
2011
-29.00
93.00
85.75
151.75
-86.50
Weather Impact
Record Yield
Record Yield
2012
24.25
162.75
188.75
340.50
119.25
Weather Impact
2013
-23.25
11.75
-70.50
134.75
28.25
Weather Impact
2014
-70.75
-71.00
-98.75
-125.25
-240.5
10
13
12
15
10
Higher
Count
Average
18.05
53.15
59.08
69.27
107.05
Max
39.50
162.75
188.75
340.50
323.50
14
12
13
10
15
Lower
Count
Average
-18.89
-41.35
-69.56
-83.35
-109.88
Max
-70.75
-76.50
-279.00
-275.50
-648.75
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 2
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
DECEMBER CORN FUTURES REACTION
TO JUNE STOCKS/ACREAGE REPORT
Year
Price Changes
Day of Report
10 Days
Later
Aug 1st
Sep 1st
Oct 31st
1990
3.25
-19.75
-40.25
-52.75
-57.75
1991
-4.50
-8.50
33.00
18.75
15.50
1992
-2.50
-23.00
-35.75
-37.50
-51.25
Notes
Record Yield
1993
4.75
6.75
8.50
-3.00
19.50
1994
2.25
-18.75
-20.25
-18.25
-26.25
1995
6.25
16.00
-2.25
12.50
52.00
1996
8.75
18.00
-37.00
-19.75
-95.25
1997
2.75
18.25
26.75
34.00
41.50
1998
7.00
-26.00
-39.00
-55.00
-40.50
1999
1.50
-21.00
0.25
-4.25
-26.75
2000
-8.50
-16.25
-14.75
-9.50
-1.50
2001
0.00
20.25
16.75
23.00
-2.75
2002
-1.00
-6.25
19.50
30.75
4.00
2003
-6.25
-11.50
-6.50
16.25
23.50
Record Yield
2004
-10.50
-16.75
-39.25
-30.75
-64.50
Record Yield
2005
-5.25
36.25
13.75
-14.50
-35.50
2006
5.75
7.75
4.00
-16.00
60.50
2007
-7.50
-2.25
-9.50
2.50
24.75
2008
-30.00
-90.25
-201.50
-187.75
-355.50
2009
-30.00
-29.75
1.75
-48.00
-1.25
2010
29.50
31.75
31.00
74.00
208.50
2011
-30.00
64.50
95.25
139.50
26.50
2012
2.50
137.75
161.00
170.25
121.00
2013
-27.50
-7.50
-47.25
-35.75
-82.75
2014
-22.00
-43.50
-63.00
-61.50
Record Yield
-104.00
Record Yield
Higher
Count
Average
Max
11
10
12
10
11
6.75
35.73
34.29
52.15
54.30
29.50
137.75
161.00
170.25
208.50
13
15
13
15
14
Lower
Count
Average
-14.27
-22.73
-42.79
-39.62
-67.54
Max
-30.00
-90.25
-201.50
-187.75
-355.50
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 3
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
supplies will be relatively tight going into the 2015/16 marketing year.
If El Niño brings significant dryness to Southeast Asia, vegetable oil
prices could trend sharply higher. In this report we offer some hedge
suggestions for vegetable oil end users as well.
Soybeans - COT - Disaggregated Futures and Options
Non-Commercial - No CIT - Net Position
Number Of Contracts
250,000
200,000
150,000
According to NOAA, May was the wettest May for the US since
records began 121 years ago. It was also the wettest MONTH
ever recorded. The map on page 1 shows the 14-day percentage of
normal precipitation for the period ending June 21st.
A large part
of the central and eastern Corn Belt has seen 200-600% of normal
precipitation.
50,000
0
-50,000
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
-100,000
2007
While it is a common perception that “rain makes grain” and that
good moisture in the spring will lead to big crops, the US weather so
far this year has been exceedingly wet. Soybeans do not do well with
too much moisture early in the year, and abundant and persistent
rains can cause significant ponding in many corn fields. Unless these
areas dry up and can be replanted in a timely manner, lower yield
is a strong possibility.
100,000
2006
Wettest Month EVER
US Soybean Crop Conditions
Percent Good / Excellent - Select States
77
74
71
68
65
62
One look at the Commitments of Traders reports and it is clear
that speculators believe the weather is bearish, with many traders
expecting good weather for July, but this is suspect.
59
6/21 Estimate: 65%
56
53
50
2013
2014
2015
10 Year Avg.
600
550
Ending Stocks
Stocks / Usage
Ending Stocks (Million Bushels)
500
22.0%
20.0%
18.0%
450
16.0%
400
14.0%
350
12.0%
300
10.0%
250
8.0%
200
6.0%
150
4.0%
50
2.0%
0
0.0%
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
100
Until a few weeks ago, traders were looking for planted acreage to
be revised upwards by about 2 million acres, and with good weather,
yield would end up around 46.7 bushels per acre (down 1 from last
year).
This would result in ending being a record 608 million bushels
and a comfortable stocks/usage ratio of 16.3%. (Scenario C, page 5)
14-Sep
7-Sep
31-Aug
24-Aug
17-Aug
10-Aug
3-Aug
27-Jul
20-Jul
13-Jul
6-Jul
29-Jun
22-Jun
US Soybeans - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
Stocks / Usage Ratio
On May 26th trend-following fund traders in soybeans held a record
net short position of 92,991 contracts. This was no surprise.
Record
planted acreage in the US, record production in Brazil and Argentina,
and record world ending stocks and a record stocks/usage ratio left
the market in a steady downtrend. However, for the week ending
June 19th, November Soybeans closed sharply higher on the week
after posting a contract low. This weekly key reversal was a strong
bottoming signal.
Why the sudden turn? The shift in the “what ifs”
for the US balance sheet has opened the door for a tighter outlook
than what the market has been expecting.
15-Jun
Soybeans – Tighter Old Crop Supply, New Crop
Concerns
8-Jun
1-Jun
47
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 4
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
"What If's" for 2015/16
USDA SUPPLY/DEMAND
US SOYBEANS
Jun
May
Jun
USDA
USDA
USDA
09-10
10-11
11-12
12-13
14-15
15-16
15-16
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
Planted Area (M Acres)
77.5
77.4
75.0
77.2
83.7
84.6
84.6
84.0
84.6
86.2
Harvested Area (Acres)
76.4
76.6
73.8
76.1
83.1
83.7
83.7
83.1
83.7
85.3
Yield (Bu/Acre)
44.0
43.5
42.0
40.0
47.8
46.0
46.0
44.5
46.0
46.7
Beginning Stocks (M Bu)
Production
Imports
138
151
215
169
92
350
330
280
330
330
3,361
3,331
3,097
3,042
3,969
3,850
3,850
3,698
3,850
3,983
15
14
16
41
30
30
30
30
30
30
3,514
3,497
3,328
3,252
4,091
4,230
4,210
4,008
4,210
4,343
Crushings
1,752
1,648
1,703
1,689
1,815
1,825
1,830
1,830
1,830
1,830
Exports
1,499
1,505
1,365
1,317
1,810
1,775
1,775
1,775
1,775
1,775
Seed
90
87
90
89
98
92
92
92
92
92
Residual
20
43
-2
16
38
38
38
38
38
38
3,363
3,282
3,159
3,111
3,761
3,729
3,734
3,735
3,735
3,735
151
215
169
141
330
500
475
273
475
608
4.5%
6.6%
5.4%
4.5%
8.8%
13.4%
12.7%
7.3%
12.7%
16.3%
Supply,Total
Use, Total
Ending Stocks
Stocks/Use Ratio
However, traders now see the potential for smaller beginning stocks,
smaller acres and smaller yield. Traders believe that the USDA’s
current estimate of 330 million bushels for 2014/15 ending stocks
is too high. The soybean crush for May was a record high, and the
basis has been very strong. In addition, the market has inverted, with
the July futures trading at a 16 ¼-cent premium to the August and
a 29 ½-cent premium to the September.
As a result, more and more
traders are looking for the USDA to revise 2014/15 usage higher
and production for lower, which could leave old crop ending stocks
closer to 280 million. This drop is supply could show up in the form
of a tighter than expected stocks number in the June 30th report.
The USDA’s June supply/demand update pegged old crop ending
stocks at 330 million bushels, down from their 350 million-bushel
estimate in May. For the new crop season, ending stocks were forecast
at 475 million bushels down from trade expectations of 487 million
and down from 500 million bushels in the May report.
World ending
stocks for 2014/15 came in at 83.7 million tonnes, down from 85.80
million tonnes expected. World ending stocks for the 2015/16 season
came in at 93.22 million tonnes versus expectations near 96 million
tonnes and up from 96.22 million projected in May. This was below
expectations but still a new record high.
Argentine production was
estimated at 59.5 million tonnes vs. 58.50 million forecast in May.
Massive rains for May and much of June in Kansas and Missouri
have opened the door for a loss of several million acres of soybeans.
In addition, ponding across much of the Midwest has left crop
conditions in a decline, and this suggests that yield may not be
as strong as suggested. For the week ending June 21st, good to
excellent readings are expected to be near 64-65% versus a reading
of 72% last year at this time.
If we were to assume a smaller acreage
number, a yield of 44.5 bushels per acre (still the second highest on
record) and smaller beginning stocks, ending stocks would fall to
273 million bushels for the coming year, with a stocks/usage ratio
of 7.3%. (Scenario A, above)
The key weather period for soybeans won’t occur until late July and
early August. For now, the price trend could go either way.
As of June
14th, there were still 3.3 million acres left to plant in Missouri and
1.6 million left in Kansas. However, any loss of acreage from here
will not show up in the June 30th report, as the survey was done in
early June. If the weather turns dry, the USDA raises acreage by a
few million acres, and August weather is favorable, there could be
more downside price action ahead.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 5
.
June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
Producer Hedges for Soybeans
End User Hedges for Soybeans
Short-term: SELL an in-the-money September Soybean Short Dated
New Crop (SDNC) $9.60 put for around 45 ½ cents and BUY 3
September Soybean SDNC $9.10 puts for around 19 ½ cents each.
The net outlay would be 13 cents.
Short-term: BUY November Soybean futures/BUY an August
Soybean SDNC $9.60 put for 26 cents, and wait to SELL an August
Soybean SDNC $9.00 put for 12 cents. The hedge portion of this
trade is the long futures position, which is protected by the purchase
of the put.
Selling the in-the-money put guards against a temporary recovery
following the report and even a surprise weather threat in the early
portion of the summer season that would reduce the sensitivity
of the long out-of-the-money put position. In the event of a near
term rally, the producer could bank some profits on the short put,
which would increase the sensitivity of the short side hedge for the
remainder of the growing season! On a 50-cent decline, the short put
could be expected to lose 36 cents, while the 3 long puts combined
could gain 84 cents, for an overall net gain of 48 cents.* If there is
a weather threat and the soybean market rallies, the net cost of the
hedge remains only 13 cents per bushel.
Longer-term: BUY 1 November Soybean futures/BUY 4 September
Soybean SDNC $8.80 puts for 10 cents each. The delta will be flat to
start, but it will become net short on good weather into the critical
growing season during late July and early August.
The long futures component is effectively a “hedge of the hedge,”
as it is designed to protect the short side hedge in the event of a
surprise bullish event.
If the hedge is not needed and the market
runs significantly higher, the hedger can recoup a large portion of
the lost options premium. This could be used to implement a fresh
hedge at a more favorable price level. The long futures component
makes the hedge a “volatility hedge,” where wide swings in either
direction will serve to benefit the hedger’s net position.
100
90
World Soybeans - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
Ending Stocks
Stocks / Usage
Longer-term: SELL 1 March Soybean futures at $9.50/BUY 10
March Soybean $12.20 calls for 6 cents each.
On a return to the June
lows in March Soybeans, BUY BACK the futures for a 43-cent profit,
hold the calls for a cheap, early 2016 hedge.
This is a leveraged, long-term hedge against higher prices that can
be partially or fully financed by market volatility, which is possible
given potential size of the crop and the state of flux in the weather.
With soybeans already rallying $1.56 per bushel into the report, it
would not be a reach to predict a $1.00-$2.00 range into next spring.
In order to see that range unfold on the downside, it would require
periodic rain and the avoidance of extreme heat. This strategy uses
the continuation of downward pricing to lay out protection for the
future!
34.0%
31.5%
29.0%
26.5%
60
24.0%
50
21.5%
40
19.0%
30
16.5%
20
14.0%
10
11.5%
0
9.0%
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
70
Stocks / Usage Ratio
80
Ending Stocks (MMT)
The short, further out-of-the-money put is a financing mechanism
that should provide the hedger with the confidence to pay more
for the more expensive $9.40 put. Selling the $8.80 put limits the
maximum protection of the long futures, but on an extremely sharp
break in soybean prices, the end user should begin to see significantly
lower purchase prices on the cash market.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 6
.
June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
Corn – Are Traders too Pessimistic about Demand and
too Optimistic towards Supply?
US Corn - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
2,250
Ending Stocks
22.5%
Stocks / Usage
20.0%
1,750
Ending Stocks (Million Bushels)
2,000
17.5%
1,500
15.0%
1,250
12.5%
1,000
10.0%
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
1993
World Corn - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
230
Ending Stocks
50%
Stocks / Usage
150
30%
130
25%
20%
15%
70
10%
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
35%
90
Ending Stocks (MMT)
170
Corn - COT - Disaggregated Futures and Options
Non-Commercial - No CIT - Net Position
Number Of Contracts
400,000
300,000
200,000
100,000
0
-100,000
-200,000
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
-300,000
2008
The June USDA supply/demand update was considered bearish for
the world numbers and neutral for the US numbers. The USDA
pegged 2014/15 US ending stocks at 1.876 billion bushels versus
1.859 billion expected and 1.851 billion in the May report. For
40%
2007
Pork is also seeing an expansion. For the June 26th Quarterly USDA
Hogs and Pigs report, traders are looking for the number of market
animals on hand June 1st to be 8% above a year ago.
While it is easy
to talk about lower feed demand, we are not seeing the statistics to
need to see a decline.
190
2006
For the five weeks ending June 6th, the average number of chicks
placed per week for broiler production has been up 3.7% from the
same period last year. Second-quarter broiler production totaled
10.1 billion pounds, up 5% from last year.
45%
110
The trade media is full of reports of the potential decline in feed usage
in the US due to bird flu as egg prices surge higher. But so far the
key broiler production areas have not been affected by the flu, and
there has been little or no impact on broiler meat production.
The
primary impacts have been declines in egg and turkey production
and poultry exports.
210
Stocks / Usage Ratio
The trade may be too bearish going into the key growing season traders may be too pessimistic about demand and too optimistic
about supply. Stocks are high in the US and worldwide, but they do
not appear burdensome in the face of current usage levels. It may
take some major weather concern to force the market to put in a
significant low, but building a more bearish case from here may also
be a difficult task.
2000
0.0%
1999
0
1998
2.5%
1997
250
The excessive moisture in the Midwest could curtail any replanting
of ponded areas in a timely fashion, but even if this is a significant
issue, it will not show up in the June 30th report.
Yields could be
dragged down, and there could be a final revision lower in acreage,
but will these factors be enough to offset the good start to the crop
and the current outlook for a lack of excessive heat in July?
1996
5.0%
1995
7.5%
500
1994
750
Stocks / Usage Ratio
Corn traders do not have too much to get excited about going into
the key June 30th reports. The slow pickup in US ethanol exports,
concerns that bird flu will hurt domestic usage, a much bigger
Brazilian crop that will leave a longer export tail, and massive corn
stocks in China are all seen as bearish factors. In addition, the
northern Midwest corn crop was planted on time, so the possibility
of seeing a significant decline in acreage from the March expectations
is limited.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 7
.
June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
"What If's" for 2015/16
USDA SUPPLY/DEMAND
US CORN
Jun
May
Jun
USDA
USDA
USDA
10-11
11-12
12-13
13-14
14-15
15-16
15-16
Scenario A
Scenario B
Scenario C
Planted Area (M Acres)
88.2
91.9
97.3
95.4
90.6
89.2
89.2
88.7
89.2
88.7
Harvested Area (Acres)
81.4
83.9
87.4
87.5
83.1
81.7
81.7
81.2
81.7
81.2
152.6
146.7
123.2
158.1
171.0
166.8
166.8
162.0
166.8
167.0
Yield (Bu/Acre)
Beginning Stocks (M Bu)
Production
Imports
1,708
1,128
989
821
1,232
1,851
1,876
1,876
1,876
1,876
12,425
12,314
10,755
13,829
14,216
13,630
13,630
13,161
13,628
13,567
28
29
160
36
25
125
25
25
27
25
Supply, Total
14,161
13,471
11,904
14,686
15,472
15,506
15,531
15,062
15,531
15,468
Feed & Residual
4,777
4,520
4,315
5,034
5,250
5,300
5,300
5,300
5,300
5,300
Food, Seed & Industry
6,425
6,421
6,038
6,503
6,522
6,560
6,560
6,560
6,560
6,560
Ethanol for Fuel
5,019
5,000
4,641
5,134
5,175
5,200
5,200
5,200
5,200
5,200
Domestic Total
11,202
10,941
10,353
11,537
11,772
11,860
11,860
11,860
11,860
11,860
Total Exports
1,831
1,541
730
1,917
1,825
1,900
1,900
1,900
1,900
1,900
Use, Total
13,033
12,482
11,083
13,454
13,597
13,760
13,760
13,760
13,760
13,760
Ending Stocks
1,128
989
821
1,232
1,876
1,746
1,771
1,302
1,771
1,708
Stocks/Use Ratio
8.7%
7.9%
7.4%
9.2%
13.8%
12.7%
12.9%
9.5%
12.9%
12.4%
2015/16, ending stocks were projected at 1.771 billion bushels versus
expectations for 1.779 billion and 1.746 billion reported in May.
In the same report, world ending stocks for 2014/15 came in at
197.01 million tonnes versus 192.5 million forecast in May. World
ending stocks for 2015/16 came in at 195.19 million tonnes from
191.94 million tonnes last month.
Trend-following fund traders held a massive net short position of
186,216 contracts as of June 16th. This leaves the market vulnerable
to short-covering if yield, stocks or acreage come in below trade
expectations.
For now, the trade is convinced that July’s weather will be cool, with
normal to above normal precipitation due to El Niño. The USDA
is starting the year using an above-trend yield of 166.8 bushels per
acre that would also be the second highest on record.
If the weather
stays normal, this may be a good projection. However, the heavy
rainfall in May and June has left some ponded areas that may not
get replanted in time, and this could drag down yield.
Given the acreage issues in a few parts of the western Corn Belt (such
as Missouri), acreage could ultimately be adjusted down by 500,000
acres. If we assume a yield of 167 bushels per acre, then ending stocks
would come in near 1.708 billion bushels.
(Scenario C)
However, if yield is adjusted down to the 20-year trend of 162,
ending stocks could slide to 1.303 billion bushels, with a relatively
tight stocks/usage ratio of 9.5%. (Scenario A)
The point of the exercise is to show that it may take some very good
weather to expect a 166.8 yield. If we look at the last 10 years and
keep the record year in and throw out the drought year, the average
yield is still only 154.9 bushels per acre.
If we use the current USDA
projections but plug in a 154.9 yield, ending stocks would drop
to just 798 million bushels, with an extremely tight 5.8% stocks/
usage ratio. Again, while it is easy to believe we can have another
excellent weather year like 2014, it will not take much in the way
of pollination issues or unexpected heat in July to cause reductions
in the yield outlook.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 8
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
Producer Hedges for Corn
End User Hedges for Corn
Short-term: SELL December Corn futures, and protect that position
by BUYING an August Corn SDNC $3.70/$4.00 bull call spread for
around 11 cents.
Short-term: BUY December Corn futures/BUY a September Corn
SDNC $3.60 put for 10 cents/SELL a September Corn SDNC $4.15
call for 6 ½ cents.
This strategy is appealing because of the recent rally of 73 cents per
bushel in corn off the June lows. The short corn futures position
makes the hedge very sensitive to the growing fears of a large
crop, while the bull call spread in SDNC options provides cheap,
temporary protection against a sudden rally. The producer has a
very responsive hedge but also has a modest “hedge of the hedge”
to protect against bullish surprises.
The net cost for the options will be 3 ½ cents. This hedge provides
sensitive long protection with the direct negative threat of option
time decay.
The long hedge remains sensitive until the December
corn futures expire. The purchase of a SDNC $3.60 put serves as
protection for the hedge, while the sale of the SDNC $4.15 call is
a tool to offset the cost of the put. If end users want full protection
against a shift in corn fundamentals into an outright bullish
environment, they should not sell the $4.15 call.
On the other hand,
end users can sell the call and be quick to take a profit on it or plan
to exit if and when the weather begins to turn more threatening.
Longer-term: SELL 1 December Corn $3.60 put for 20 cents and
BUY 5 September SDNC Corn $3.45 puts for 4 ½ each (22 ½ cents
total). The net outlay will be 2 ½ cents.
This strategy offers a leveraged and short side-hedge at a reduced
cost. It also allows for some protection and financing of the hedge
from the sale of a single, short-dated put.
If the December $3.60 put
moves deep into the money prior to the expiration of the September
SDNC $3.45 puts, the September puts should be even deeper into the
money and should be acting almost like short futures. If there is a
near term upside extension, the hedger can decide to bank profits on
the short December $3.60 put, which would increase the sensitivity
of the long puts and will add a limited, defined amount of exposure
to the net cost of the hedge. For example, if short $3.60 put position
is liquidated at 10, the added cost would be $500 per hedge, but
then there would be nothing to get in the way of benefiting from a
summer slide in corn prices.
Longer-term:
1) SELL 1 September Corn SDNC $3.60 call for 24 cents/BUY 4
December Corn $4.30 calls for 8 cents each.
This strategy employs long term leveraged call protection that is
partially financed by the sale of a single, closer to expiration, call.
Unless bullish conditions surface right away, the September SDNC
call will lose sensitivity, as it will only have 52 days until expiration
as of the report date.
Hopefully, initial weakness in prices will allow
for a profit to be banked in the short call, which would then allow the
hedger to open up coverage of the hedge and simplify the position.
2) SELL December Corn futures/BUY 5 May 2016 Corn $5.10 calls
for 6 cents each.
This strategy provides the end user with longer term coverage in a
leveraged option position. The premium outlay is initially protected
by the short corn futures, while the leveraged call position should
remain effective for almost 300 days! If corn prices dive in the wake
of the report or they decline due to improvements in crop conditions
during the growing season, the hedger should have to ability to bank
profits from the short futures and defray the 30-cent combined
premium cost for the calls. If corn prices fall to a significantly lower
level, this strategy would allow the hedger to recoup the entire
premium expense and reset it at a lower level!
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 9
.
June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
Potential Volatility in Soybean Oil
Sun
Palm
1500
1250
1000
750
500
250
9
8
World Palm Oil - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
Production
Stocks / Usage
21%
19%
5
13%
4
11%
9%
7%
1
5%
0
3%
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
15%
2
20
18
World Vegetable Oil - Ending Stocks vs.
Stocks / Usage Ratio
Ending Stocks
Stocks / Usage
14.00%
13.40%
12.80%
14
12.20%
12
11.60%
10
11.00%
8
10.40%
6
9.80%
4
9.20%
2
8.60%
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
16
Ending Stocks (MMT)
Argentina is the world’s largest soybean oil exporter, with 5.1 million
tonnes forecast for this year. US exports are projected at just 907,000
tonnes. It will be difficult to quickly find another 4.55 million tonnes
to make up for any shortfall of palm oil out of Southeast Asia. A
significant expansion of biodiesel usage in the US, South America
and Southeast Asia could also keep stocks tight.
6
Stocks / Usage Ratio
The primary reason that El Nino dryness in Malaysia and Indonesia
is such a concern is that 86% of world palm production comes from
that region.
If there are production difficulties and exports decline,
soybean oil exports will need to make up the difference. Global
soybean oil exports are projected at 10.77 million tonnes. If palm
exports drop 10%, soybean oil exports will need to jump to 15.3
million tonnes, a 42% increase from the current estimate.
17%
3
Production (MMT)
7
With record crops in Argentina and Brazil and record planted area
in the US, one would assume that there is (or will eventually be)
plenty of soybean oil to meet the world’s demand.
However, the
world vegetable oil stocks/usage ratio is historically tight, even with
record palm oil production and exports of 45.5 million tonnes onto
the world market.
May-15
May-14
May-13
May-12
May-11
May-10
May-09
May-08
May-07
May-06
May-05
May-04
May-03
May-02
May-01
May-00
May-99
May-98
May-97
May-96
0
Stocks / Usage Ratio
The potential for an El Nino event is initially a bearish force for
soybeans, as it can increase moisture in both the US and Brazil.
However, a severe and sustained El Nino event later this year and
into next year could have the greatest impact on palm oil production
and on palm, soy and vegetable oil prices. Burdensome supplies
of soybeans would seem to reduce the risk against oil buyers, but
the potential for a market-turning weather event should not be
discounted. With soybean oil prices already posting a low to high
bounce of roughly 15.5% from their early 2015 lows, it would seem
that the trade is registering some concern with future weather
conditions.
Rapeseed
1750
May-95
The outlook for global soybean prices has rarely presented a more
bearish case than the one facing the markets now.
World ending
stocks, stocks to use ratios and stocks in the hands of exporters are
all registering bearish signals, but the potential for even lower prices
looms if the feared supply builds become a reality.
Soybean
2000
$/Ton Rotterdam
Vegetable oil end users and speculators are in a tough position
this year, as the oilseed production outlook is extremely bearish
but vegetable oil stocks are relatively tight. If any El Niño weather
problems develop in Southeast Asia, world vegetable oil prices could
advance.
Cash: Weekly Vegetable Oils - Rotterdam
2250
It will be important to see normal monsoon rains in India. Otherwise
their import requirements could increase as well.
Chinese demand
continues to advance, too.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 10
. June 23, 2015
THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
SPECIAL REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
Vegetable Oil Exports Comparison
End User Hedge for Soybean Oil
This is essentially a “volatility” hedge. With the long multiple call/
short futures position, the worst case scenario for the hedger would
occur if market fails to swing up or down. Our interest in this strategy
stems from the potential for good production weather in the US to
be followed by unfavorable production weather for Malaysia and
Indonesia later this year. If a hedger buys 3-4 out of the money May
calls and sells a May futures contract, the short futures position
can be lifted on weakness early this summer, leaving the end-user
covered against any uptrend into 2016.
Malaysia Palm
Argentina Soy
Indonesia Palm
23.500
21
18
Million Metric Tonnes
18.000
15
12
9
6
5.100
3
0.907
15
14
13
12
11
10
09
08
07
06
05
04
03
02
01
00
99
98
97
96
95
0
94
We suggest that they consider buying multiple May 2016 (or later
expiration) calls as a hedge against a change in the current outlook.
Given that soybean oil prices for May 2016 delivery are 3.5 cents
above their 2015 lows, hedgers might consider hedging the premium
outlay for the calls with the sale of a soybean oil futures contract.
This is a volatility play that needs a significant range-up move to
provide a windfall.
However, if bearish weather for the US crop
pushes ending stocks expectations even higher and/or the El-Nino
threat dissipates, a significant portion of the hedge premium outlay
could be recouped with the short futures position.
US Soybeans
24
S
USDA
India Vegetable Oil - Production vs. Usage
24
21
Production
Domestic Consumption
18
Million Metric Tonnes
Given the potential for the current forecast for historically high
ending stocks being undone by adverse weather, the prospect of
significant volatility in soybean oil is high. This is something that
end users could use to their advantage.
27
15
12
9
6
3
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
0
China Vegetable Oil - Production vs.
Usage
36
33
30
Production
Domestic Consumption
27
Million Metric Tonnes
24
21
18
15
12
9
6
3
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
0
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 11
. THE HIGHTOWER REPORT
Futures Analysis & Forcasting
June 23, 2015
SPECIAL REPORT
CME Webinars:
Are You Prepared for the USDA Acreage Report?
June 24 | June 30
2:30 - 3:30 p.m. CT
Both events will be hosted as online webinars
To help commercial hedgers and end users prepare for the June 30 USDA Acreage Report, we're
bringing in the experts. In this two-part webinar series, top industry analysts share their insights pre- and postreport to help you prepare for any major impacts to the agricultural markets.
Pre-USDA Webinar
•
•
The impact of El Nino – Blu Putnam, Chief Economist, CME Group
Expectations and Strategy – David Hightower, President, The Hightower Report
Post-USDA Webinar
•
Analysis and outlook panel discussion – Dan Basse, AgResource
Click here to register!
Disclaimer
The information in this report may be considered dated upon its release and should not be considered interpersonal advice. This report is merely an
opinion on the market and is a reflection of conditions as of its publication.
Market conditions change! Traders should not consider entering positions without their own independent analysis of the market’s current situation, nor without further consideration of any changes to the information
contained herein that may have occurred since this report was written. The authors are not responsible for any verbal or written claims and opinions
that might be provided in conjunction with this report. The trading suggestions contained herein have been provided merely as a general guide and
only for the purpose of quantifying the authors’ opinions.
This report includes information from sources believed to be reliable but no independent verification has been made and we do not guarantee its
accuracy or completeness.
Opinions expressed are subject to change without notice. This report should not be construed as a request to engage in
any transaction involving the purchase or sale of a futures contract and/or commodity option thereon. The risk of loss in trading futures contracts
or commodity options can be substantial, and investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial
condition.
Any reproduction or retransmission of this report without the express written consent of The Hightower Report is strictly prohibited.
141 West Jackson • Suite 4002 • Chicago, Illinois • 60604 • 800-662-9346 • 312-786-4450 • info@HightowerReport.com • @HightowerReport
Trading futures contracts and commodity options involves substantial risk of loss, and thus is not appropriate for all investors.
Investors should carefully consider the inherent risks of such an investment in light of their financial condition.
Page 12
.