Insight & Outlook
Getting To Yes: Small Changes That
May Spark Big Results
Author Noah J. Goldstein offers insight on five key principles
of persuasion
Advisors who are looking to convert more prospects and grow their
businesses may want to take a lesson on the power of persuasion from
Noah J. Goldstein, Ph.D.
Goldstein, an Associate Professor of Management and Organization at
UCLA Anderson School of Management, is also the coâ€author of Yes! 50
Scientifically Proven Ways to Be Persuasive. At a recent Fidelity Inside
Track presentation in Boston, Goldstein enumerated principles of
persuasion that may sound intuitive but, he noted, are rarely applied in
client or prospect conversations, pitch meetings, or business
negotiations.
“People typically feel
guilty about saying no.
By going to a smaller
request, which is easier
to say yes to, you can
alleviate this feeling of
guilt.”
Have You Herd?
—Noah J. Goldstein
During his presentation, Goldstein discussed the concept of “social
proof” and “the herd mentality.” He explained that when people are in a
state of uncertainty and are not sure what to do, they look to the
behaviors of others—especially “similar others”—for guidance on what
to do.
As an example, Goldstein cited a study he conducted that showed that,
when asked by a hotel to reuse their bath towels at least once during
their stay, 75% of guests did just that. Curious to pinpoint how the hotel
achieved such a high compliance rate, Goldstein collaborated with a
local hotel chain to experiment with different room signs that
encouraged customers to reuse their bath towels.
The first sign, Goldstein explained, bore a “typical environmental
message” that stressed saving water, saving the environment, and
reusing towels. Other signs used variations, but one sign produced a
further 20% increase in towel reuse.
That sign read: “In a study conducted in Fall 2003, 75% of the guests
participated in our new resource savings program by using their towels
more than once. You can join your fellow guests in the program to help
save the environment by reusing your towels during your stay.”
As Goldstein explained, people often tend to follow “the herd,” but
being invited to follow a “similar herd” produced even better results. For
example, when another sign stated, “75% of people who stayed in this
room reused their towels,” the 20% bump in compliance rose to 33%.
.
Goldstein suggested that financial advisors can apply
this principle in their own work. For example, letting
prospects know your firm’s assets under management
may be viewed as a sign that other investors find you
trustworthy.
You might also consider posting a variety of case
studies on your website to show how you help
different types of clients. Goldstein suggested that a
prospect who is under age 40 with no kids would be
looking to see that you serve others in a similar
situation. “By having a diverse assortment of client
information on your firm’s website, that’s going to
indicate, “OK, it’s safe to invest with you,” says
Goldstein.
Reach and Retreat
When pursuing appointments with prospects, you
may encounter resistance from busy professionals. By
maintaining a fallback position, however, you may be
able to achieve your goals.
For example, while some prospects may decline a
request for an hour of their time, following up with a
request for 15 minutes is more likely to get someone to
say yes, Goldstein said.
The difference between a big request and a smaller or
“retreat” request, says Goldstein, is that it creates a
perceptual contrast that makes the asker seem
reasonable and accommodating, someone to whom
you’re more likely to say “yes.”
“People typically feel guilty about saying no,”
explained Goldstein. “By going to a smaller request,
which is easier to say yes to, you can alleviate this
feeling of guilt.”
it’s safe to invest with you.”—Noah J.
Goldstein.”
“Suddenly, with only one or two accounts, moving the
assets to you doesn’t seem nearly as onerous as
compared to moving a greater percentage of their
portfolio,” said Goldstein. “The fact is that it’s very
hard for someone to say “no” to you twice in a row.”
Say Yes to Authority
The “authority principle” also comes into play when
people are uncertain about how to behave in certain
situations. This is when they look for honest,
knowledgeable people to help them make a decision,
said Goldstein.
As an example, Goldstein cited physical therapists,
who often have difficulty getting patients to perform
their exercises at home. This is an example of what he
calls “nonâ€compliance.” Advisors often face the same
challenge: clients who don’t follow their advice.
In his presentation, Goldstein explained how a simple
tweak to one physical therapist’s office environment—
posting staff diplomas and awards in the waiting
room—reduced patient nonâ€compliance by 30%
within six months. The projection of authority and
expertise engendered more trust, said Goldstein,
which in turn induced patients to actually perform
their physical therapy exercises.
Goldstein suggested that advisors can apply the same
strategies by strategically communicating and
reinforcing their expertise and authority. This could
include posting diplomas, certifications, and press
clippings in a meeting room.
Advisors can put this concept into practice when
discussing a request to consolidate assets with a client.
While some clients may resist holding all of their
assets with one firm, Goldstein suggests first asking
the client to move all or a large percentage of their
portfolio to your firm. If they resist, you can follow up
by suggesting they transfer just a portion of their
portfolio.
In addition, the next time you’re meeting with a
prospective new client, Goldstein suggested having
staff members introduce each other, highlighting each
person’s expertise and achievements. This allows team
members to communicate their expertise without
sounding boastful.
“By having a diverse assortment of
client information on your firm’s
website, that’s going to indicate, “OK,
The Trust Factor
Another key component of the authority principle is
trustworthiness, said Goldstein. He suggested that one
2
.
nonâ€intuitive way to build trust is to admit a
weakness, but then turn that weakness into a strength.
One famous example of this approach occurred when
Ronald Reagan was debating Walter Mondale in 1984.
Some people had questioned whether Reagan was too
old to serve a second presidential term.
Reagan turned a perceived weakness into a strength
when he quipped, “I want you to know I will not
make age an issue of this campaign. I am not going to
exploit for political purposes my opponent’s youth
and inexperience.”
If you work for a small advisory firm that is going up
against larger competitors, Goldstein suggested that
you acknowledge that fact right away. He also
suggested that you could position this as a strength by
stressing your ability to offer service that is more
personalized and more nimble than what a larger
organization can provide.
Another example of this approach may occur when
you’re dealing with a prospect who is contemplating
investing with another firm because he or she prefers a
more conservative investment approach than what
you’re recommending. Goldstein suggested that you
could build trust by offering to recommend other
firms that invest conservatively. But first, you would
explain your rationale and why you believe a
conservative approach is not right for the prospective
client.
Consistency Counts
Getting prospects and clients to honor their
commitments is a challenge many advisors face. For
example, a client may offer to make a referral but not
actually follow through.
Goldstein believes that “people are most likely to act
consistent with their commitments when those
commitments are made publicly and actively.” As an
example, he cited a restaurant owner who was trying
to reduce the number of noâ€shows—people who made
dinner reservations but failed to cancel them.
To remedy the situation, the person taking phone
reservations tweaked her signâ€off line from “Call us if
your plans change” to “Will you please call us if your
plans change?”
“Gifts and favors are most powerful
when they are both personalized and
unexpected.”—Noah J. Goldstein
Changing from a declarative sentence to a question
reduced the noâ€show rate from 30% to 10%, according
to Goldstein. He suggested that compliance improves
dramatically when people are asked to make a specific
public affirmation.
Advisors can put this theory into practice when a
client promises to make a referral. Goldstein suggested
that, instead of just saying “thank you,” you could
add, “great, when do you think you could do that?”
By asking a simple question, you are subtly
compelling your client to make a public commitment
that they are more likely to honor.
Goldstein suggested using this same tactic when
setting deadlines with employees or colleagues. For
example, rather than telling a colleague to get you
something by the end of the week, you could instead
say, “will you get this to me by Friday at 3:30?”
“You’re going to see compliance improve
dramatically,” said Goldstein.
The Principle of Reciprocity
When it comes to giving gifts or doing favors for
people, Goldstein believes strongly in what he calls
the “principle of reciprocity.” “If you do favors or you
give gifts to people, they’re going to want to return the
favor,” said Goldstein.
As an example, he cited an experiment that was
conducted at a restaurant in New York State. To see if
they could increase tip amounts, the restaurant’s
owners tinkered with different ways of distributing
afterâ€dinner mints to customers. Rather than simply
leaving a bowl of mints by the door, servers delivered
mints to customers with their check, one mint per
customer. This change increased tips by 3.3%.
Next, the restaurant experimented by giving two
mints to each customer, and tips increased by 14.1%.
In a final twist, servers changed the way they
delivered the two mints to customers. They would
deliver one mint for each customer at the table, take
two steps away, and then say something to the effect
3
.
of “eh, for you guys, here’s another mint each.” Even
though customers were still receiving only two mints
each, the way in which they were getting those two
mints, caused tips to increase by a whopping 23%.
Advisors can put the principle of reciprocity into
practice when giving gifts to clients, suggested
Goldstein. “Gifts and favors are most powerful when
they are both personalized and unexpected,” he said.
Therefore, instead of giving clients the same old gifts
during the holidays, Goldstein suggested that advisors
might get better results by giving highly personalized
gifts at random times of the year.
“Gifts that are unexpected, those are going to be the
ones they remember, “said Goldstein. “They’re not
going to remember the ones that they’re getting over
Christmas, because you know what, everyone else is
sending them gifts at that time as well.”
By focusing more closely on these tactics of
persuasion, Goldstein believes that advisors can
achieve better results with prospects and clients.
“Small changes to the way people persuade others can
pay big dividends,” he said.
4
.
200 SEAPORT BOULEVARD Z281
BOSTON, MA 02210
For Investment Professional use only. Not for distribution to the public as sales material in any form.
The information contained herein is as of the date of its publication and is subject to change and general in nature. Such information is
provided for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, or compliance advice. Fidelity does not provide legal, tax, or
compliance advice.
Fidelity cannot guarantee that such information is accurate, complete, or timely. Federal and state laws and regulations
are complex and are subject to change. Laws of a specific state or laws that may be applicable to a particular situation may affect the
applicability, accuracy, or completeness of this information.
This information is not individualized, is not intended to serve as the primary or
sole basis for your decisions, as there may be other factors you should consider, and may not be inclusive of everything that a firm should
consider in this type of planning decision. Some of the concepts may not be applicable to all firms. Always consult an attorney, tax
professional, or compliance advisor regarding your specific legal or tax situation.
The third-party provider(s) listed herein are neither affiliated with nor an agent of Fidelity, and are not authorized to make representations on
behalf of Fidelity.
Their input herein does not suggest a recommendation or endorsement by Fidelity. This information was provided by the
third-party provider(s) and is subject to change. The content provided and maintained by any third-party website is not owned or controlled
by Fidelity.
Fidelity takes no responsibility whatsoever nor in any way endorses any such content. There is no form of legal partnership,
agency, affiliation, or similar relationship among an investment professional, the third-party service provider(s), and Fidelity Investments, nor
is such a relationship created or implied by the information herein.
Third-party marks are the property of their respective owners. All other marks are the property of FMR LLC.
Fidelity Clearing and Custody provides clearing, custody, and other brokerage services through National Financial Services LLC or Fidelity
Brokerage Services LLC, Members NYSE, SIPC.
200 Seaport Boulevard, Z2B1, Boston, MA 02210.
© 2016 FMR LLC.
All rights reserved.
748920.1.0
1.9864769.100
5
.