PROFESSIONAL ADVISORS GROUP, LLC
Complete Financial Management
Greece is the Word
Volatility and Uncertainty Continue
In March we commented on the volatility in the capital markets and observed that there was no
discernible path to a consistent unobstructed high rate of growth in economies both domestic and
abroad. We commented on slowing productivity in the United States and the consensus annual
GDP rate of growth of 2.5 - 3%. We noted that durable goods orders and capital expenditures
were restrained. Although there continued to be some improvement in the rate of employment,
wage gains were insubstantial.
We also noted that inflation was well below the Federal Reserve’s
target of 2%. And although the Federal Reserve declared its inclination to begin raising shortterm interest rates, they reaffirmed that any decision would be data dependent.
Abroad, we commented on the decelerating rate of growth experienced by China and the limited
impact that stimulus has had on reversing the trend. We were cautious with regard to the
European recovery as the European Central Bank’s quantitative easing program commenced.
We
had not at the time addressed the financial crisis in Greece as discussions between Greece, the
IMF, the ECB, other European governments and other creditors were underway and all were
hopeful.
As of the close of the second quarter of the year, there have been some modest gains in the
domestic economy. Economists anticipate that the economy grew in excess of 2.5% in the
second quarter of the year, bolstered by increased consumer spending and increased activity in
the housing market. Construction spending on both residential and nonresidential projects
reached its highest point since 2008, and automobile purchases were strong.
The manufacturing
sector continued to grow during the second quarter, although the strong dollar remains a limiting
factor for exports. Consumer spending was also supported by the “energy dividend” of lower
energy prices for consumers. Employment and job growth continue at a modest pace with the
unemployment rate coming down to 5.3% at the close of the quarter, notwithstanding the
downward revisions in the May and April employment numbers and the decline in the labor
participation rate to 62.6%.
Second quarter corporate earnings growth should reflect improving economic conditions,
although top line revenue growth continues to be challenged with the possible exceptions of the
auto industry and the healthcare sector.
Even excluding negative year over year earnings growth
in the energy sector, many analysts anticipate no EPS growth (and possibly negative EPS
growth) for the second quarter. First quarter earnings were similarly depressed as a result of the
downturn in energy prices and were also impacted by currency losses relative to the euro. In the
second quarter however, notwithstanding the resurfacing of the financial crisis in Greece, the
dollar weakened against the euro and therefore these currency gains should be reflected in
quarterly earnings (perhaps again reversing as the Greek drama unfolds).
1325 Avenue of the Americas, 14th floor ï‚·New York, NY 10019 t 212.355.0346 f 212.355.0413
www.klsadvisors.com
.
During the second quarter, the price of oil increased from first quarter levels but remained deeply
discounted from prior year levels negating EPS growth in other sectors of the S&P 500. Shortly
after the close of the quarter, oil prices again declined.
We continue to believe that inflation is not a substantial factor as wages have not begun to rise
meaningfully and there seems to be excess capacity in manufacturing and service sectors both
domestically and in China. We are, however, mindful that the skills mismatch affecting the jobs
market may give rise to higher wages and may affect operating margins, but such has not yet
been significant.
In all, the domestic economy continues to grow at modest rates while wrestling with declining
productivity and modest demand that places a ceiling on capital expenditures. Companies have
used free cash flow and borrowed (at low interest rates) to buy back shares to support stock price
and EPS growth.
Internationally, towards the close of the quarter, China and Greece injected more volatility into
the capital markets.
China’s stock market had experienced extraordinary gains during the first
five months of the year followed by sharp declines (approximately 30%) in the last several
weeks. Pre-correction valuations in the Chinese equity markets exceeded S&P 500 multiples for
its Shanghai Composite Index; its more technology heavy Shenzhen index surpassed U.S.
multiples reached in 1999 during the technology bubble era. This at a time of decelerating
economic growth and substantial questions regarding corporate governance and reporting.
On the final day of the quarter, Greece failed to make a payment of €1.5 billion due the
International Monetary Fund.
This failure resulted in Greece being in immediate technical
default on other debts of far greater magnitude. The ongoing ability of Greece to pay its debts
has been and continues to be the subject of a high stakes negotiation as Greece and its creditors
seek a possible resolution to the crisis. The ECB has maintained, but not increased, support for
Greek banks.
European governments who own Greek sovereign debt have thus far been reluctant
to compromise or partially write off such debts.
As the deadline approached, European and U.S. equity markets were roiled. Greek banks were
closed and capital controls were initiated.
Investors and Eurozone member states alike were
greatly troubled by the uncertainties that surrounded the Greek situation. If Greece were to exit
the Eurozone (“Grexit”) and establish its own currency, sovereign debts would not be paid and
economic turmoil in Greece would ensue. Equity markets and member states in the Eurozone
also feared the potential that other economically challenged members of the Eurozone could be
motivated to exit the euro or seek to compromise their own obligations following Greece.
Such
uncertainty continues to fuel volatility in currency and worldwide capital markets.
Because Greece has been especially reliant on imports, the cost of such imports would skyrocket
in the event of a “Grexit” relative to a much weakened local currency and there would initially
be a severe decline in living standard. Assuming that political stability could be achieved and
rule of law maintained sufficient to attract foreign investment, the advantage of a greatly
devalued currency could provide the stimulus for future growth. Whether or not there is a
“Grexit”, there are still many structural reforms that must be undertaken to right the economy for
the long-term.
These include reforms to the Greek tax and retirement systems.
2
. Absent the Greek exit from the Eurozone, a mechanism still must be developed to ensure there is
not a repetition of euro-financed trade deficits that eventually lead to local economic decline. It is
apparent that ex post facto austerity is an insufficient means of dealing with a crisis of excessive
debt relative to GDP (approximately 175% debt to GDP ratio) and high unemployment. The
immediate illiquidity in the Greek economy that resulted after the banks were closed and access
to cash was limited foreshadows the problems yet to come if Greece were to leave the Eurozone.
Individuals could not access their cash, pensioners were limited to a fraction of their monthly
pensions, businesses would not accept credit cards, and stores and restaurants had insufficient
resources to buy supplies and inventory. Without a currency circuit breaker there is presently no
self-enforcing mechanism to adjust trade imbalances to stabilize the individual state economies.
After Greece failed to make payment to the IMF, game theory and brinksmanship shifted into
high gear.
Creditors insisted upon additional austerity and the Greek negotiators resisted. Then,
for a brief moment it appeared as if a deal would be struck with Greece capitulating to the
demands of the creditors. Shortly thereafter, however, Greece issued a letter asking for certain
exceptions with respect to the austerity and tax proposals put forth by the creditors.
It then
appeared there was no deal to be had. A Greek referendum was held on July 5th to determine
whether Greece would capitulate to creditor demands for more austerity and taxes. The vote was
a resounding “No!”
The International Monetary Fund has gone on record stating that it is not possible for Greece to
pay all its debts.
The Greek people concur, yet many wish Greece to remain in the Eurozone.
Regardless of the outcome of the Greek crisis, Europe is in a position to withstand Greece further
defaulting on its debts. The absolute amount of debt that may be written off should not put the
European recovery in jeopardy. Greece’s total debt is approximately €323 billion.
Its GDP is
approximately €184 billion, or approximately 2% of Eurozone GDP. In the aftermath of
Greece’s failure to make payment, equity markets declined modestly, seemingly taking the
default and subsequent referendum “No vote” in stride. Finally, even if Greece should exit, we
note that it is unlikely that the euro will be unwound given international trade benefits and capital
markets access that its members enjoy.
Nevertheless, Eurozone leaders and investors are
concerned by the apparent polarization of some member states.
Meanwhile, closer to home, Puerto Rico announced that it could not pay its debts. At the last
minute, however, it made payments due on its bonds in July and entered into serious discussions
for compromise with creditors. The U.S.
territory’s excessive debts relative to its economy were
enabled by virtue of its U.S. dollar currency and the exemption from state and federal income
taxes for interest paid on Puerto Rico bonds. A problem not all that dissimilar from that of
Greece which was enabled by its increased access to the capital markets and its ability to borrow
at lower interest rates as a result of its inclusion in the Eurozone.
Puerto Rico also has the
additional complications of a high cost and U.S. regulatory structure (minimum wage and
employer payroll taxes) in the island economy without the long-ago expired U.S. corporate tax
incentives to support economic growth.
Puerto Rico bonds comprise approximately 2% of the
$3.6 trillion municipal bond market. Any default or compromise would not significantly affect
the U.S. economy but may add to increased municipal market volatility.
3
.
Domestic equity markets have largely been insulated from the turmoil in Europe, and now in
China. It should be expected, however, that the operations and earnings of multinational
corporations will be adversely impacted by any additional economic slowdowns abroad and such
will be priced into their shares.
For the quarter, the Dow Jones Industrial Average declined -.29% (+.03% ytd); the S&P 500 and
Russell 1000 Indices gained .28% (+1.23% ytd) and .11% (+1.71% ytd), respectively. The
Wilshire 5000 returned .06% (+1.67% ytd). The MSCI EM Index increased .69% (+2.95% ytd).
The Russell 2000 Small Cap Index increased .42% (+4.76% ytd) while the S&P 400 Mid Cap
Index declined -1.06% (+4.19% ytd).
The MSCI EAFE Index gained .62% (+5.52% ytd). The
MSCI All Country World Index returned .35% (+2.26% ytd), and the MSCI European Equity
Index gained .36% (+3.82% ytd) net of currency losses.
Portfolio Construction
At quarter close, the price-earnings ratio for the S&P 500 was approximately 18.0x 2015
estimated EPS. Mid- and small-cap shares are valued at approximately 21x and 24x 2015
estimated EPS, respectively, with much greater anticipated growth in 2015 EPS.
In most client
portfolios we remain modestly underweight large-cap shares and modestly overweight mid- and
small-cap shares.
With long-term Baa corporate bonds yielding approximately 5.0%, the implied PE ratio for
equities is 20x. While PE expansion is possible, it is more likely that interest rates will rise thus
lowering the implied equity multiple. As we discussed earlier this year, we continue to believe
that the drivers of share price increase going forward will be growth in EPS rather than multiple
expansion and continue to anticipate this growth to be modest and gradual.
Nevertheless,
diversified domestic equities continue to represent a competitive investment on a relative
risk/reward basis as compared to other asset classes. We continue to maintain exposure to both
growth and value equities and to both passive and active styles of management in most client
portfolios.
Most client portfolios are underweight foreign equities with much of such foreign equity
exposure hedged back to the U.S. dollar to mitigate the impact of currency conversion on client
portfolios.
We continue to have modest duration exposure in most fixed income portfolios.
We are not
likely to extend maturities as the Fed has signaled that tightening (or raising interest rates) may
commence this year. We continue to invest in high quality municipal bonds held as a risk
mitigator in most client portfolios, and anticipate that the Fed will be cautious in raising rates so
as not to upset the trend of improving economic conditions. Interest rates rose during the quarter
with the 10-year treasury closing at a yield of 2.35% (23 basis points higher than the 2.12% yield
at the start of the year).
The two-year and five-year treasury yield at quarter end was virtually
unchanged from the beginning of the year.
4
. Outlook
Domestically, economists seem encouraged and are forecasting higher economic growth during
the second half of the year. Including the slight contraction in the first quarter of the year,
consensus outlook is for annual growth of 2.5 - 3% in 2015. This notwithstanding a slower
acceleration in employment gains than many previously anticipated.
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development recently advised that worldwide
inflation is well below the 2% annual target of most central banks. While the inflation rate is
approximately 2.5% in the G – 20 countries, the OECD expressed concern with regard to the
risks of deflation.
Fresh stimulus is continuing to be injected into the worldwide economy by central banks in
Japan, Europe, India and China, among others, as the Federal Reserve is preparing domestic
markets for an eventual increase in interest rates.
Pressure on Chinese equities is likely to continue, given high valuations, although the Chinese
government is easing margin restrictions and has committed funds to help support share prices.
In the first half of the year, mergers and acquisition activity has been robust as companies
challenged by organic growth opportunities seek combinations in order to achieve efficiencies
and enhance profits.
Healthcare, pharmaceutical, technology and media, and insurance
companies have led the way.
We continue to anticipate a tepid growth environment and some volatility in the capital markets
as international macro-economic relationships adjust while central bank polices support
recovery. Although surges in share price may occur from time to time, we expect growth based
on earnings and economic fundamentals to be modest and anticipate equity returns consistent
with this. Finally, there has been much discussion regarding liquidity in the capital markets given
the enhanced capital requirements imposed by new regulations on financial institutions.
In times
of market volatility, price declines could be exacerbated by the absence of institutions willing to
buy securities for fear that such would adversely impact their capital and regulatory
requirements. Fixed income managers, in particular, have expressed their concerns on this
matter. Although this may give rise to additional market volatility, it does not in and of itself
affect fundamental valuations.
It does, however, underscore the importance of having an
appropriate investment time horizon and risk adjusted portfolio.
Postscript
As we prepared to mail this commentary equity markets in United States and China came under
renewed pressure. China equities continued in free fall bringing increased concerns as to the
recovery of the Chinese economy, the possible impact this will have on international trade, and
the pressure that further slowdown in China may have on commodity prices including oil and on
the larger world economy.
5
. The Bank of England held an emergency meeting at the end of June and has concluded that the
outlook for financial instability has worsened as a result of the Greek debt crisis and its
polarizing effect on Europe.
The OECD is now forecasting a slowdown in the world's major economies including the United
States and China.
The decline in commodity prices and slowing of world economies has caused concern among
some economists that there is a risk of stagflation – i.e., a stagnant or recessionary economy
coupled with an increase in consumer prices (the beginnings of which were noted above in the
OECD's report). Whether or not this is a valid concern, it is clear that reflating world economies
is not consistent with slowdowns, excess capacities, and weakened demand for commodities.
We believe that the Federal Reserve will stay attuned to and be sensitized to economic
developments worldwide and will accordingly be prudent and cautious before it begins raising
interest rates.
Finally, Greece has a €3.5 billion payment due on July 20. In a letter issued by the Greek
authorities to its Eurozone creditors there was some indication that Greece would agree to some
additional austerity measures and softened its demands for debt reduction. European shares rose
on the news.
We will continue to consider these and future developments as we address
appropriate portfolio construction and risk/reward balance for our clients.
The above commentary represents the economic and market views of our firm. We remind you,
however, that each client’s portfolio is managed individually. Please speak with your KLS
advisor with respect to your personal circumstances and individual portfolio performance.
July 8, 2015
The material contained herein is intended as a general market commentary.
The prices/quotes/statistics referenced herein have been obtained
from sources deemed to be reliable, but we do not guarantee their accuracy or completeness; any yield referenced is indicative and subject to
change. The views and strategies described herein may not be suitable for all investors. Certain opinions, estimates, investment strategies and
views expressed in this document constitute our judgment based on current market conditions and are subject to change without notice.
The
information contained herein should not be relied upon in isolation for the purpose of making an investment decision. This material is not
intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
6
.
.