The Five Financial Personalities
White Paper
Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America
Allianz Life Insurance Company of New York
ENT-1093-N
Page 1 of 12
. Introduction
The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study was a groundbreaking market research study by Allianz Life Insurance
Company of North America (Allianz) on the subject of the baby boomer generation and retirement in the
new economy.
The study took a broad and deep view of boomers as they approached and planned for retirement in the new
economic environment: what were their attitudes, fears, concerns, goals, and behaviors about retirement
planning, retirement preparedness, and retirement income? And just as important, how could the providers
who serve this generation better prepare for, and respond to, their changing needs?
Methodology
Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America contracted Larson Research and Strategy Consulting, Inc.
and DSS Research to field a nationwide online survey of 3,257 U.S. adults, aged 44-75. The online survey was
conducted in the United States between May 6, 2010 and May 12, 2010.
In addition to polling a representative sample of 1,642 U.S. households, the survey also targeted subsamples of
more affluent households and households that own annuities.
Results were weighted by age, gender, education,
race/ethnicity, and income to account for disproportionate sampling of certain populations. The margin of error
for the total sample was approximately +/- 1.7%.
In addition, we also conducted a nationwide qualitative research study with financial professionals who did
not currently sell annuities. The research was entirely anonymous as we conducted in-depth, one-on-one
interviews to determine general practice strategies and strategies for generating income in retirement,
as well as perceptions, beliefs, feelings about, and objections to annuities.
Allianz Life Insurance Company of New York (Allianz Life® of NY) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America.
Page 2 of 12
.
Overview
As a key component of the study, we identified several distinct
groupings of preretirement and retirement age consumers,
based on attitudinal, behavioral, psychographic, and demographic
characteristics. Quantifying and understanding the key differences
between these boomer segments enables specific, tailored, and
relevant solutions.
Five distinct financial “personalities” emerged as the respondents’
demographic data were analyzed and correlated with their
responses about economic resilience, concerns, attitudes,
and financial needs.
These personalities can be
summarized as follows:
The five distinct financial “personalities”
27%
7%
14%
Overwhelmed: 32% of the respondents said they felt unprepared
for retirement. The overwhelmed group responded that they
expect to have to reduce their living expenses in retirement, and
they’re counting on Social Security for retirement income.
The overwhelmed personality is in “survival mode.”
Iconic: 20% of the respondents are confident their income
will last throughout retirement. The iconic personality said they
feel that they have prepared well for the future.
They may have
reduced some of their spending, but they do have a handle on their
retirement expenses. This group believes in the “American Dream.”
Resilient: 27% of our respondents exhibited a “take-charge”
attitude according to our study; they’ve planned ahead and
value their independence, but most are planning on investing,
working longer, or supplementing Social Security with some other
form of income. The resilient personality is concerned about
outliving their income.
Distracted: This personality describes 7% of our respondents.
This group responded that they have seen their net worth drop
significantly.
However, they have not changed their retirement
plans or reevaluated their overall financial strategy. This group is
worried that their savings will not be adequate for retirement,
but they don’t have a plan for growing those savings.
20%
Savvy: 14% of those surveyed are either living comfortably in
retirement or will retire comfortably. The respondents in this
segment are financially independent, comfortable taking risks,
and confident that their income will last throughout their lives.
Savvy personalities tend to have large, diversified portfolios –
and, therefore, few financial concerns.
32%
Overwhelmed
Distracted
Iconic
Savvy
Resilient
This extensive and rigorous consumer segmentation of the
boomer and retirement market is presented here to advance
the industry’s collective understanding of this complex, critical
consumer, and assist in the effective marketing of products to
help meet their needs.
1
Page 3 of 12
.
The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study Five Financial Personalities White Paper
Segmentation methodology
The respondent pool for this segmentation was
comprised of 1,642 Americans, age 44-75, with
minimum household incomes of $30,000. The sample
was separated into several distinct groups or segments,
following a three-step process.
Step one is to identify the characteristics that define or
“drive” consumer retirement and financial strategies
behavior. A statistical technique called cluster analysis
is used to identify clusters or segments of consumers
– each cluster being distinct from the others based on
consumer behaviors and what drives them. Use of this
tool revealed that consumer behavior is being driven
by a specific combination of factors that includes
values, attitudes, life stage, lifestyle, wealth status
(a combination of income and investable assets), risk
orientation, and risk tolerance.
Based on this cluster
analysis, the five distinct consumer segments –
or retirement segments – were identified.
Step two involves identifying the descriptive
characteristics – those attributes that help complete
the picture of who these people are. These factors
include their demographics, family status, attitudes,
values, needs, expectations, behaviors and priorities
around retirement, retirement planning, income
planning, how the marketplace volatility affects them,
as well as dozens of other facts about them that were
provided by their responses to our 110-question survey.
Step three is the creation of in-depth segment
“portraits” that integrate all of this information –
detailed profiles of each segment that define, at a
deeper and more detailed level, who the consumers
are in each segment. For each segment, these portraits
include the “key indicators,” such as what percentage
of the overall market that segment represents, what
their average net worth is, what percent is working vs.
retired, how many have dependents, how many have
annuities, etc.
The in-depth portraits also included key
demographics, the impact of the downturn for them,
their attitudes toward retirement, their biggest worries
or concerns, their financial needs and/or attitudes, their
usage of financial professionals, and their attitudes
toward annuities. We also included a “defining
statement,” which reflects at a core level the
worldview of this particular boomer segment.
These in-depth portraits help provide the road map
toward understanding what these different segments
need and want from their financial providers, and the
values and attitudes that shed light on what may be
a more effective retirement solution for them.
2
Page 4 of 12
. Financial personality #1: Overwhelmed
“Financially speaking, I am pretty much in survival mode.”
The largest segment (32%) of respondents, which
we refer to as “Overwhelmeds,” feels unprepared for
retirement and lack confidence in how they will put
together a strategy for retirement security.
They tend to have the lowest income levels and
least education of the five segments (though 40%
have completed at least some college), are the least
knowledgeable about financial concepts, and often
feel financially like they are just keeping their heads
above water.
Generally in their late 40s or early 50s,
Overwhelmeds have a median income of $56,000,
according to our study. They do not have a lot of
investable assets ($80,000 is the average), and their
net worth is the lowest of our segments ($167,000).
This segment also has the highest percentage of
minorities and women. Often being single and
trying to make ends meet with their younger kids,
Overwhelmeds are unfortunately carrying the highest
level of credit card debt. They typically have a
modest-sized mortgage and a lower-value home.
As a group, Overwhelmeds tend to be somewhat
pessimistic.
One-third of the respondents in this
segment have been affected by job loss, either
personally or indirectly. Their financial worries tend
to focus on the here and now – getting bills paid and
getting food on the table. They worry about inflation
costs and not having enough money to pay for care
if they get sick, and also worry about when – or
even if – they’ll be able to retire.
They are planning
on working longer and many anticipate having to
continue working in retirement. While they expect to
reduce their living expenses significantly in retirement,
Overwhelmeds are also depending heavily on Social
Security to help get them by.
Overwhelmeds who responded have not done
a lot of financial planning – and unfortunately do not
yet see value in working with financial professionals,
whom they generally do not trust. Only 27% surveyed
have a financial professional, about half the rate of
other segments.
However, Overwhelmeds responded that they may
have a high need for guidance, and while they may
seem on the surface to be “unattractive” to the
financial services industry, as noted, this segment
represents a third of all Americans.
Financial
professionals should be reaching out to this vast
audience as it appears they may be the segment
that needs them the most.
Key insights about
Overwhelmeds
• High credit card debt, low level
of assets
• Seek safety, simplicity, and liquidity
• Worry about inflation costs and not
having enough money to retire or to
pay for care if they get sick
• Want to be free of obligations and
in control of their time
• Want to help their grown children
with daily expenses and also help
with expenses for grandchildren
3
Page 5 of 12
. The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study Five Financial Personalities White Paper
Financial personality #2: Resilient
“Deep down, I realized things would never be the same
in terms of financial security.”
Our study found that “Resilients” are solid
citizens – planners with strong values and an
independent streak. The resilient personality is
pragmatic and grounded.
They were hit pretty hard psychologically in the
recession; though they are generally moderately
affluent with a fairly sizable net worth, they have
definitely woken up to the need for better planning.
They state that they may want to rebuild their
portfolio and shore up a good solid strategy for having
stability in the future, but they also realize that they
may have to work longer.
Our study found that people with this financial
personality tend to be in their early to mid-50s and
are still working full-time, with a moderate amount of
debt. They are highly educated (second only to Savvys)
and typically have kids in their teens.
Nearly one-fifth of our respondents have been
affected by job loss. About half of the respondents in
our Resilient group said that they plan to retire; the
other half is unsure of when they’ll be able to afford
retirement.
Resilient personalities are concerned
about outliving their income. To address this concern,
most are planning on investing, working longer, or
supplementing Social Security with some other form
of income. Most resilient personalities expect to make
some reduction in their living expenses in retirement.
True to their name, Resilients are generally good
planners who are knowledgeable about household
finances and, despite setbacks, have managed pretty
well, financially speaking.
Their average investable
assets are $375,000, so they have a fairly sizable
portfolio to work with. They responded that they are
more focused on growth than other respondents
(perhaps due to losses they are trying to recoup) and
may be much more likely to have CDs and savings
bonds vs. annuities or municipal bonds.
Resilients tend to understand the value of a financial
professional, with 53% using a financial professional.
However, 11% are not receptive to working with
financial professionals and likely consider themselves
the “do it yourself” type that was observed in many
focus groups.
Key insights about Resilients
• Goals are to enjoy their work and
restore/rebuild investment portfolio
• Tend to take charge rather
than be led
• Value their independence and
don’t ever want to depend on others
• Feel they deserve everything they have
• More focused on growth than other
respondents
4
Page 6 of 12
.
Financial personality #3: Iconic
“I’ve worked hard and invested wisely for my retirement
security and I am enjoying it.”
“Iconics” in our study could be thought of as “true
blue,” retired Americans. They generally believe in the
American Dream, have worked hard, and lived within
their means. They tend to be on top of their financial
situation and, as a result, were less affected by the
recession. They’ve been proactive about ensuring they
have a safe and secure retirement.
Of all segments studied, they have the highest level
of annuity ownership (36%).
Interestingly, 53% have
a financial professional, but quite a high number (32%)
are not open to working with one, possibly because
they don’t feel they have enough money
or because this seems “an indulgence” to them.
Our study found that they are typically older (60+),
often live in smaller towns, and have grown children.
Iconics are moderately well-educated, have little debt,
and have a modest amount of investable assets and net
worth – and fully half of them have paid off their house
in full (that’s more than double the percentage of all
other segments, except Savvys).
They’re middle class, live mostly on a pension, and are
extremely disciplined and traditional in their viewpoints
and values. Iconic personalities reported that they
feel that they have prepared well for the future and
that they have a right to a comfortable retirement,
even if it means leaving a smaller inheritance for
their beneficiaries. They reported that they may have
reduced some of their spending, but they do have a
clear understanding of their retirement expenses.
Iconics generally have modest incomes (42% have a
$45,000-$75,000 household income) and are the
highest percentage of any segment average in our
study (83%) to be receiving a pension.
Generally, their
average investable assets are $295,000, and their
median net worth is $419,000 – both of which are
moderate levels relative to other segments
in our study.
Key insights about Iconics
• Optimistic about the future
• According to our study, they feel
they have a right to a comfortable
retirement even if it means leaving
less for their kids
• Life is focused on staying
healthy/getting in shape, traveling, and
spending time with family and friends
• A focus on simplicity and safety
more than return, fees, or flexibility
• They responded that their ideal
financial product would provide
guaranteed income for life and be
stable and predictable so they don’t
have to think about it
5
Page 7 of 12
. The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study Five Financial Personalities White Paper
Financial personality #4: Savvy
“I watch the markets and manage my investments.”
Our study found that “Savvys” are financially
sophisticated, confident, well-to-do people who pride
themselves on having prepared well for retirement
and on being “in the know” about most financial
concepts. According to our study, these smart,
assertive individuals like information and facts,
and want to be treated like a partner in the
decision-making process.
Key insights about Savvys
• Heavily invested in real estate (home
and/or other property) and an array
of financial products
• Focused on reasonable fees relative
to benefit
Generally, the Savvy personality is older
(predominantly over 60), is highly educated, and has
been retired or semi-retired for at least five years.
• Many are willing to trade liquidity and
security for a higher potential return
The Savvy group in our study is living comfortably
in retirement and appears to be the best-prepared
of the five financial personalities. They generally
have the highest level of investable assets – in large,
diversified portfolios – and the lowest level of debt.
• Some focus on simplicity and security
more than return, fees, or liquidity
• Tax-deferred growth is very important
Our study found that they are financially independent,
comfortable taking risks, and confident that their
income will last throughout their lifetimes. Although
the Savvy personality may have suffered some recent
market losses, these had little impact on spending
habits or daily life.
However, as a consequence, some
Savvys may have adopted a more conservative
approach to investing.
Savvys know and understand the value of working
with a financial professional – 67% of them have a
financial professional.
6
Page 8 of 12
. Financial personality #5: Distracted
“I am happy to live in the moment with a full house and a full life.”
In our study, “Distracteds” are the youngest of our
segments surveyed. Caught up in the complexity
of modern life, they tend to not focus on financial
planning, thinking of retirement as being far off and
even hard to imagine.
Our study found that they are typically in their late 40s
or early 50s. Distracteds are most likely to be married
with young children and working full-time, struggling
with the day-to-day pressures of raising a young family
and balancing home, career, and family life.
They have the highest income (by far) of any segment
in our study (their average household income is
$175,000), have the second-highest level of investable
assets, and are very well-educated. They also tend to
live in pricier homes in city or metropolitan settings.
They also tend to spend freely (especially on their kids),
and family and home expenditures take priority over
saving for retirement.
Consistent with this “live now/pay
later” philosophy, among our five groups, they report
that they owe the most on their mortgages and have
among the highest in credit card debt.
Those in this group reported that they expect to retire
in their early 60s – although they would prefer to retire
in their early 50s. They are relying on 401(k)s more than
any other group and counting on receiving their full
Social Security benefits. They may be worried that their
savings will not be adequate for retirement, but they
don’t have a plan for growing those savings.
Distracteds
tend to live in the present and externalize big decisions
(instead, wanting government to solve the country’s
financial problems).
That said, those in our study have the highest
percentage of individuals not currently working with
a financial professional who nonetheless say they are
either “open to it” or “definitely plan on it.” In other
words, they recognize the need to invest smarter but
have not yet made the commitment to do so.
Though they responded that the recession hit their
home values hard and many have seen their net worth
drop significantly, Distracteds have generally “tried not
to think about it.” They may have cut back on some
spending, but they have not changed their retirement
plans or reevaluated their overall financial strategy.
Key insights about Distracteds
• Their major focus in life is providing
for family (spouse, kids)
• Concerned that nest egg may not
be big enough
• Want a bigger government to solve
country’s financial problems
• Are open to working with a financial
professional
• Highest in credit card debt
7
Page 9 of 12
. The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study Five Financial Personalities White Paper
Conclusion
At this critical juncture in their lives, with life and career
transitioning to a new chapter, according to our study
boomers have been hit hard by marketplace volatility.
This has resulted in a seismic shift in how they think,
behave, and manage their money.
Though the mindsets of the five segments identified
here run the gamut from overwhelmed to savvy to
resilient, each group holds its own potential in terms
of investing strategies to provide security in retirement,
and what is desired from a financial professional.
Through our survey it was discovered that safety,
protection, and retirement security have become
paramount in the boomer mindset as the world around
them has shifted and they find themselves facing the
reality of the gap between their desired lifestyle and
the means to get there.
The 76-million baby boomers approaching retirement
have experienced a major wake-up call. The Allianz
Reclaiming The Future Study is the first step toward
successfully answering that call.
For this key segment of the population, there is a
heightened awareness that the safety nets of yesteryear
– defined benefit plans and Social Security – are
diminished and disappearing. The net worth of their
assets have been eroded by the turmoil in the financial
and housing markets. And as average life expectancies
continue to increase, the length of time spent in
retirement is also increasing.
Taken together, these
factors are creating one of the dramatic retirement
income challenges in history.
For more information about
the Reclaiming the Future Study
go to www.allianzlife.com.
8
Page 10 of 12
. The Allianz Reclaiming the Future Study revealed
several key findings:
• Americans believe that there is a retirement crisis and that they are unprepared.
• There are five distinct financial “personalities.”
• Americans fear outliving their money more than they fear death.
• The economic downturn was a big “wake-up call.”
• Annuity-like solutions are gaining relevance and appeal.
Page 11 of 12
. True to our promises …
so you can be true to yours.
®
As leading providers of annuities and life insurance, Allianz Life Insurance Company
of North America (Allianz) and its subsidiary, Allianz Life Insurance Company of
New York (Allianz Life® of NY), base each decision on a philosophy of being true:
True to our strength as an important part of a leading global financial organization.
True to our passion for making wise investment decisions. And true to the people
we serve, each and every day.
Through a line of innovative products and a network of trusted financial
professionals, Allianz and Allianz Life of NY together help people as they seek to
achieve their financial and retirement goals. Founded in 1896, Allianz, together with
Allianz Life of NY, is proud to play a vital role in the success of our global parent,
Allianz SE, one of the world’s largest financial services companies.
While we pride ourselves on our financial strength, we’re made of much more than
our balance sheet. We believe in making a difference with our clients by being true
to our commitments and keeping our promises.
People rely on Allianz and Allianz
Life of NY today and count on us for tomorrow – when they need us most.
Guarantees are backed solely by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of Allianz Life Insurance Company
of North America and Allianz Life Insurance Company of New York. Variable annuity guarantees do not apply to the
performance of the variable subaccounts, which will fluctuate with market conditions.
• Not FDIC insured • May lose value • No bank or credit union guarantee • Not a deposit • Not insured by any federal
government agency or NCUA/NCUSIF
Products are issued by Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America, 5701 Golden Hills Drive, Minneapolis, MN
55416-1297. www.allianzlife.com.
In New York, products are issued by Allianz Life Insurance Company of New York,
One Chase Manhattan Plaza, 38th Floor, New York, NY 10005-1423. www.allianzlife.com/new-york. Only Allianz Life
Insurance Company of New York is authorized to offer annuities and life insurance in the state of New York.
Variable
products are distributed by their affiliate, Allianz Life Financial Services, LLC, member FINRA, 5701 Golden Hills Drive,
Minneapolis, MN 55416-1297. www.allianzlife.com
Product and feature availability may vary by state and broker/dealer.
Page 12 of 12
(R-12/2014)
.